An investor who has sold stock short can receive some protection and generate premium income by selling puts against their short stock position. Selling puts against a short stock position will only partially hedge the unlimited upside risk associated with any short sale of stock. Additionally, the investor, in exchange for the premium received for the sale of the put, has further limited their maximum gain. Before entering a short stock short put position, an investor must determine:

  • Their Breakeven
  • Their Maximum Gain
  • Their Maximum Loss

Breakeven Short Stock Short Puts

An investor who has sold stock short and sold puts against their position is subject to a loss if the stock price begins to rise. To determine how high a stock price could rise after establishing a short stock short put position and still allow the investor to breakeven, use the following formula:

Breakeven = Stock Price + Premium

Example:

An investor establishes the following position:

Short 100 ABC at 55

Short 1 ABC November 55 put at 4

Using the above formula, we get:

55 + 4 = 59

In this case, the stock could rise to $59 by expiration and still allow the investor to breakeven excluding transaction costs.

Maximum Gain Short Stock Short Puts

An investor who has established a short stock short put position has limited the amount of their gain even further by selling puts, because the investor will be required to purchase the shares at the put’s strike price if the stock declines.

To determine the investor’s maximum gain use the following formula:

Maximum Gain = Breakeven – Strike Price

Example:

An investor establishes the following position:

Short 100 ABC at 55

Short 1 ABC November 55 put at 4

The investor will breakeven at 59 found by adding the stock price of 55 and the option premium of 4 together.

Using the above formula, we get:

59 - 55 = 4

The investor’s maximum gain in this case is $4 per share or $400 for the entire position. The investor received a total of $59 per share by establishing the position. If the stock fell to zero they would still be required to repurchase the shares at 55 under the terms of the put contract. Notice that the sales price and the put’s exercise price are the same and the amount of the investor’s maximum gain is equal to the amount of the premium received.

Let’s look at a position where the sale price of the stock and the strike price of the put are different.

Example:

An investor establishes the following position:

Short 100 XYZ at 60

Short 1 XYZ November 55 put at 4

The investor will breakeven at 64. $64 dollars per share were the total proceeds received by the investor for establishing the position.

To determine their maximum gain using the formula above, we get:

64 – 55 = 9

The investor’s maximum gain is $9 per share or $900 for the total position.

Maximum Loss Short Stock Short Puts

An investor who has sold puts against their short stock position has only limited their loss by the amount of the premium received from the sale of the put. As a result, the investor’s loss in a short stock short put position is still unlimited.

Underlying Position Most Protection Some Protection & Income

Long Stock

Long Puts

Short Calls

Short Stock

Long Calls

Short Puts

FOCUS POINT!

It’s important to note that any time an investor wants the most protection, they are going to buy the hedge. If the investor wants some protection and income, they will sell the hedge.

Need Help Passing Your Series 4 Exam?

Index Options

Related Articles
  1. Trading

    Solving Mixed Options Problems On The Series 7

    Learn to ace the questions that involve both options contracts and stock positions.
  2. Trading

    Prices Plunging? Buy A Put!

    Investors can make money on a falling stock by going long on a put.
  3. Investing

    Short Selling Risk Can Be Similar To Buying Long

    If more people understood short selling, it would invoke less fear, which could lead to a more balanced market.
  4. Trading

    Short Sales For Market Downturns

    This strategy can help in market downturns, but it's not for inexperienced traders.
  5. Trading

    How To Protect A Short Position With Options (FB, AAPL)

    Short selling can be a risky endeavor, but the inherent risk of a short position can be mitigated significantly through the use of options.
  6. Trading

    The Difference Between a Long and Short Position

    Stocks are owned in a long position and owed in a short position.
  7. Trading

    Guide to Short Selling

    Want to profit on declining stocks? This trading strategy does just that.
  8. Personal Finance

    Tips For Series 7 Options Questions

    We'll show you how to ace the largest and most difficult section of this exam.
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. Where do most fund managers get their market information?

    Many fund managers, whether they manage a mutual fund, trust fund, pension or hedge fund, have access to resources that the ...
  2. What's the difference between short-term investments and marketable securities?

    Understand the difference between short-term investments and marketable equity securities, and learn the importance of short-term ...
  3. Are fringe benefits direct or indirect costs?

    Learn how to allocate costs associated with fringe benefits provided to employees and how to determine when a cost is either ...
  4. How is a bank guarantee different from a traditional loan?

    Read about the differences between a traditional bank loan and a bank guarantee, and why a third party might require a guarantee ...
Trading Center