Commissions And Trade Complaints - FINRA 5% Markup Policy

FINRA has  set  a  guideline  to  ensure that  the  prices  investors  pay  and  receive  for securities are reasonably related to  the market  for the securities. As a general rule, FINRA considers a charge of 5% to be reasonable. The 5% policy is a guideline, not a rule. Factors that go towards what is considered reasonable are:

  • The price of the security
  • The value of the transaction
  • The type of security
  • The value of the members’ services
  • Execution expenses

When a customer is executing an order for a low priced or low total dollar amount, a firm’s minimum commission may be greater than 5% of the transaction.

Example:

A customer wants to purchase 1000 shares of XYZ at $1. If the firm’s minimum commission is $100 that would be 10% of the trade. But in this case it would be ok.

Stocks generally carry a higher degree of risk than bonds and, as a result, stocks justify a higher commission or profit to the dealer. Full service firms may be able to justify a larger commission simply based on the value of the services they provide.

Mark Ups / Mark Downs When Acting as a Principal

A firm that executes customer orders on a principal basis is entitled to a profit on those transactions. If the firm is selling the security to the customer, they will charge the customer a mark up. In the case of the firm buying the securities from the customer, they will charge the customer a mark down. The amount of the markup or markdown that a firm charges the customer is based on the inside market for the security.

Example:

Let’s assume that the brokerage firm is a market maker in ABCD.  In the morning, the firm purchased shares of ABCD for its own account at 9.50. The stock has been trading higher all day and is now quoted as follows:

Bid                  Ask

10.00             10.05

If a customer wants to purchase 100 shares ABCD from the dealer in the above example, the customer’s markup would be based on the current offering price of 10.05. As a result, the maximum amount the firm could charge the customer for the stock would be 10.552 per share or $1,055.20 for the entire order, which would include a 5% markup. Notice that the markup to the customer did not take into consideration the firm’s actual cost.

If a customer wanted to sell 100 shares of ABCD using the above quote, the minimum proceeds to the customer would be 9.50 per share or $950 for entire order, which would include a 5% markdown.

To determine the maximum or minimum prices for a customer use the following:

  • 105% of the offer price for customers who are purchasing the security
  • 95% of the bid price for customers who are selling the security

When determining the amount of the mark up or mark down the following are excluded:

  • The firm’s Actual cost
  • The firm’s quote if they are a market maker in the security
Transactions


Related Articles
  1. Professionals

    Transactions

    Riskless Principal Transactions If a brokerage firm receives a customer order to buy or sell a security and the firm does not have an inventory position in the security, the firm may still elect ...
  2. Professionals

    Broker Vs. Dealer

    The term broker dealer actually refers to the two capacities in which a firm may act when executing a transaction. When a firm is acting as a broker, it is acting as the customer’s agent ...
  3. Professionals

    Protection Of Customer Orders

    Customer orders are required to be protected by the firm at the price that is reportable to ACT. For example, if a customer placed an order to purchase 1000 shares of GHJK at 10.00 the firm would ...
  4. Professionals

    Broker-Dealers

    FINRA Series 6 Exam Study Guide - Broker-Dealers. The section talks about the roles of security firms for executing customer transactions 1). Agent/Broker 2). Principal/Dealer.
  5. Professionals

    Customer Confirmations

    All customers must be sent a confirmation at or before the completion of the transaction. Industry rules consider the completion of the transaction to be the settlement date. It is unlawful to ...
  6. Professionals

    Introduction

    A firm handling a customer’s order is entitled to be compensated for executing the customer’s order. How the firm is compensated depends on the way the firm executes the order. Firms ...
  7. Professionals

    Introduction

    Prior to executing a customer’s order, the firm must open an account for the customer. The representative opening the account should try to obtain all vital financial information relating ...
  8. Economics

    What's Involved in Customer Service?

    Customer service is the part of a business tasked with enhancing customer satisfaction.
  9. Professionals

    Confirmation of Transactions and Account Statements

    FINRA/NASAA Series 26 Section 8 - Confirmation of Transactions and Account Statements. In this section information disclosure requirements, confirmations notifications disclosure and customer ...
  10. Professionals

    B. Continuing Education

    Most registered agents and principals are required to participate in industry mandated continuing education programs. The continuing education program consists of a firm element, which is administered ...
RELATED TERMS
  1. Markdown

    The difference between the highest current bid price among dealers ...
  2. Customer's Loan Consent

    An agreement signed by the customer of an investment firm. The ...
  3. Markup

    The difference between an investment's lowest current offering ...
  4. Customer

    An individual or business that purchases the goods or services ...
  5. Customer Service

    The process of ensuring customer satisfaction with a product ...
  6. Trading Ahead

    When a specialist trades securities for his or her own firm's ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. How does a customer base dictate goodwill?

    Find out how a customer base dictates the value of the goodwill by providing a ready market for its products and spreading ... Read Answer >>
  2. Is good customer service something to look for in a company in which I am considering ...

    Learn about the importance of customer service when deciding whether to invest in a stock. Good customer service can ensure ... Read Answer >>
  3. A market maker in the stock ABCD has filled a portfolio over time with prices as ...

    C is closest. Mark-up rules of fair practice on Nasdaq require market pricing. The NASD views markups in excess of 5% above ... Read Answer >>
  4. A person purchases stock XYZ (an Over The Counter stock) from a company who is also ...

    The correct answer is c When the firm is a market maker in the stock then it must act as a principle. Principal is the main ... Read Answer >>
  5. How does a merger affect the customer?

    Learn how a merger may affect customers of the industry. The effects of mergers may be positive or negative, but there's ... Read Answer >>
  6. What's the difference between profit margin and markup?

    Learn to differentiate between profit margin and markup, two accounting terms that are often used interchangeably but actually ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Law Of Demand

    A microeconomic law that states that, all other factors being equal, as the price of a good or service increases, consumer ...
  2. Cost Of Debt

    The effective rate that a company pays on its current debt. This can be measured in either before- or after-tax returns; ...
  3. Yield Curve

    A line that plots the interest rates, at a set point in time, of bonds having equal credit quality, but differing maturity ...
  4. Stop-Limit Order

    An order placed with a broker that combines the features of stop order with those of a limit order. A stop-limit order will ...
  5. Keynesian Economics

    An economic theory of total spending in the economy and its effects on output and inflation. Keynesian economics was developed ...
  6. Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications ...

    A member-owned cooperative that provides safe and secure financial transactions for its members. Established in 1973, the ...
Trading Center