Convergence

What is 'Convergence'

Convergence is the movement of the price of a futures contract towards the spot price of the underlying cash commodity as the delivery date approaches. 

BREAKING DOWN 'Convergence'

When a futures contract's delivery date is several months or years in the future, the contract will often trade at a premium to the expected spot price of the underlying commodity on the delivery date. This situation is known as contango​. As the delivery date approaches, the futures contract will depreciate in price; in theory, it will be identical to the spot price on the delivery date.

The chart below shows the prices for wheat futures contracts for different delivery dates, as of October 14, 2015. The upward slope represents contango.

Source: CME Group

The chart below plots the changes in price of wheat futures expiring in December 2015 versus the spot price of wheat, both on the left vertical axis. The basis, or the difference between these two prices, is plotted on the right vertical axis. The fall in the basis as the delivery date nears represents convergence.

Sources: CME Group and investing.com

The principle of convergence also applies when a commodity futures market is in backwardation​, that is, when futures contracts are trading at a discount to the expected spot price. In this case, futures prices will appreciate as expiration approaches, equaling the spot price on the delivery date.

Arbitrage

That the spot price of a commodity would equal the futures price on the delivery date is fairly straightforward: purchasing the commodity outright on Day X (paying the spot price) and purchasing a contract that requires delivery of the commodity on Day X (paying the futures price) are in essence the same thing. The latter just adds an extra step.

If these prices somehow diverged on the delivery date, there would be an opportunity for arbitrage, that is, to make a functionally risk-free profit by buying the lower-priced commodity and selling the higher-priced futures contract (assuming the market is in contango; vice-versa if the market is in backwardation). While such opportunities may arise briefly due to market inefficiencies, arbitrageurs would in theory drive the price of the commodity up by increasing demand for it and push the price of the futures contract down by increasing the supply. In other words, the prices would converge.

Futures and spot prices do occasionally fail to converge, as happened with wheat, corn and soybeans at different points between 2005 and 2010. There are a number of theories as to why this could happen, but none is generally accepted.

Contango and Backwardation

We may ask why a futures contract would be more expensive than the underlying commodity in the first place, that is, why a futures market would find itself in a state of contango. The commodity itself does not change (unless it is perishable), so why pay extra for the privilege of waiting for it? The answer is in part practical: if you do not need palladium until next October, there is little reason to pay to store, protect and insure it in the mean time. It is easier to leave those expenses, known as the cost of carry, to the counterparty​. Since such convenience does not come for free, there is a premium on the futures contract.

Another way of explaining contango is through the time value of money. If a bond or savings account yields 5% annually, then $1,000 today is theoretically equal to $1,050 next year. Commodities like copper, on the other hand, do not generate interest. As mentioned above, they're more likely to cost money over time. Tying capital up in commodities implies an opportunity cost, which is compensated with higher prices for futures contracts.

The use of futures contracts as a hedge against volatile commodity prices also helps explain contango. The farther away the delivery date, the more time there is for things to go wrong—for wars to start, for crops to fail, for prices to swing. The party signing up for delivery two years from now at a certain price is taking on considerable risk and demands a premium for it. If that same party is signing up for delivery in a week, they will be content with something very close to the spot price.

As for why backwardation occurs, it can be because a commodity producer wants to hedge against future price movements. It is not uncommon for commodities with less predictable supply, such as perishables and oil, to be in backwardation. Farmers and petrostates need to guarantee a measure of revenue; unlike speculators, they are sometimes willing to forgo potential profits in exchange for security.

RELATED TERMS
  1. Current Delivery

    A type of futures contract that requires the delivery of the ...
  2. Contango

    A situation where the futures price of a commodity is above the ...
  3. Forwardation

    A term used in pricing futures contracts. Forwardation is a ...
  4. Spot Commodity

    A commodity traded on the spot market. That is, with the expectation ...
  5. Delivery Price

    The financial value of the conveyance of the underlying commodities ...
  6. Narrow Basis

    A condition found in futures markets in which the spot price ...
Related Articles
  1. Markets

    Crude Oil Prices: Comparing Future Price Vs. Current Market Price

    Discover the differences between oil futures market prices and oil spot market prices and what leads to the differences between the two.
  2. Investing Basics

    What Does Contango Mean?

    Contango​ is when the futures price of a commodity is higher than the expected future spot price.
  3. Options & Futures

    Contango Versus Normal Backwardation

    It’s important for both hedgers and speculators to know whether the commodity futures markets are in contango or normal backwardation.
  4. Options & Futures

    20 Investments: Futures Contract

    What Is It? As the name implies, futures are contracts on commodities, currencies, and stock market indexes that attempt to predict the value of these securities at some date in the future. ...
  5. Futures Traders

    Futures are financial contracts giving the buyer an obligation to purchase an asset (and the seller an obligation to sell an asset) at a set price at a future point in time. Futures are also ...
  6. Professionals

    Summary And Review

    Summary And Review
  7. Professionals

    Offsetting Contracts, Settlements And Delivery

    Offsetting Contracts, Settlements And Delivery
  8. Trading Strategies

    Market Strength: S&P 500 Futures

    If you've ever watched financial television before or after the markets open you will probably notice that they often quote the latest index futures price on the "bug" in the bottom corner. ...
  9. Professionals

    Forward Markets and Contracts: Settlement Procedures

    CFA Level 1 - Forward Markets and Contracts: Settlement Procedures. Learn the differences between being long or short in a forward contract. Also contrasts how physical and cash deliveries are ...
  10. Professionals

    Effects On Commodity Delivered Or Purchased

    Effects On Commodity Delivered Or Purchased
RELATED FAQS
  1. How are commodity spot prices different than futures prices?

    Find out more about commodity spot and futures prices, how to calculate a commodity's futures price, and the differences ... Read Answer >>
  2. Why do futures' prices converge upon spot prices during the delivery month?

    It's a fairly safe bet that as the delivery month of a futures contract approaches, the future's price will generally inch ... Read Answer >>
  3. How do commodity spot prices indicate future price movements?

    Find out more about commodity spot and futures prices, how to calculate commodity futures prices and how spot prices indicate ... Read Answer >>
  4. What are some securities that have spot rates?

    Learn about the types of assets that have spot rates, and understand how the spot rate is used to determine the fair market ... Read Answer >>
  5. What's the best way to play backwardation in the futures market?

    Backwardation is a market condition in which a futures contract far from its delivery date is trading at a lower price than ... Read Answer >>
  6. How do I learn technical skills for trading commodities?

    Learn what resources are available to learn about trading commodities, and understand some of the differences between stocks ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Stop-Limit Order

    An order placed with a broker that combines the features of stop order with those of a limit order. A stop-limit order will ...
  2. Keynesian Economics

    An economic theory of total spending in the economy and its effects on output and inflation. Keynesian economics was developed ...
  3. Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications ...

    A member-owned cooperative that provides safe and secure financial transactions for its members. Established in 1973, the ...
  4. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles - GAAP

    The common set of accounting principles, standards and procedures that companies use to compile their financial statements. ...
  5. DuPont Analysis

    A method of performance measurement that was started by the DuPont Corporation in the 1920s. With this method, assets are ...
  6. Call Option

    An agreement that gives an investor the right (but not the obligation) to buy a stock, bond, commodity, or other instrument ...
Trading Center