Paradox of Rationality

A A A

DEFINITION

The irony that rational decision-making in game theory situations often has poorer payoffs or outcomes than choices made illogically or naively. The paradox of rationality underscores the contradiction between intuition and reasoning according to game theory. This paradox arises because the rational outcomes predicted by backward induction, the main form of game theory analysis, diverge widely from intuitive choices. The paradox of rationality is consistently observed in experimental studies of game theory using such well-known games as prisoner’s dilemma and the centipede game.

INVESTOPEDIA EXPLAINS



The paradox of rationality is highlighted by a popular game theory scenario known as the Traveler’s Dilemma, devised by economist Kaushik Basu in 1994. Traveler’s Dilemma presents a scenario in which an airline damages identical antiques purchased by two independent travelers.

When pressed for compensation by the travelers for the damage, the airline manager – who has no clue about the value of the damaged goods – comes up with a novel solution to the problem of estimating the antiques’ value. He tells the two travelers to separately write down the value as any number between $2 and $100. If both write down the same number, the inference is that they are telling the truth and the airline will reimburse them that amount. But if they write different numbers, the manager will assume that the lower number is the actual value and that the higher value is inaccurate. The airline will therefore pay both travelers the lower figure, with a bonus of $2 for the traveler who wrote the lower number and a penalty of $2 for the traveler with the higher number. Thus, if A writes $50 and B write $55, A receives $52 ($50 + $2 bonus) as compensation, while B gets $48 ($50 - $2 penalty).

According to backward induction, the rational choice in terms of the Nash equilibrium is $2. However, in experimental studies, most people pick $100 or a number close to it. This includes people who have made a naïve selection without thinking the problem through, as well as those who are aware that they are deviating from the rational choice. The fact that substantially higher payoffs are possible by rejecting the rational choice and acting illogically or naively is the paradox of rationality.


RELATED TERMS
  1. Zero-Sum Game

    A situation in which one person’s gain is equivalent to another’s loss, so that ...
  2. Centipede Game

    An extensive-form game in game theory in which two players alternately get a ...
  3. Decision Analysis - DA

    A systematic, quantitative and visual approach to addressing and evaluating ...
  4. Decision Theory

    An interdisciplinary approach to determine how decisions are made given unknown ...
  5. Decision Tree

    A schematic tree-shaped diagram used to determine a course of action or show ...
  6. Game Changer

    1. A person who is a visionary. 2. A company that alters its business strategy ...
  7. Iterated Prisoner's Dilemma

    A normal prisoner's dilemma played repeatedly by the same participants. An iterated ...
  8. Prisoner's Dilemma

    A paradox in decision analysis in which two individuals acting in their own ...
  9. Game Theory

    A model of optimality taking into consideration not only benefits less costs, ...
  10. Skin In The Game

    A term coined by renowned investor Warren Buffett referring to a situation in ...
Related Articles
  1. Advanced Game Theory Strategies For ...
    Economics

    Advanced Game Theory Strategies For ...

  2. Utilizing Prisoner’s Dilemma In Business ...
    Economics

    Utilizing Prisoner’s Dilemma In Business ...

  3. Can Games Make You A Better Investor?
    Investing Basics

    Can Games Make You A Better Investor?

  4. How To Survive The Trading Game
    Active Trading

    How To Survive The Trading Game

  5. Using Decision Trees In Finance
    Options & Futures

    Using Decision Trees In Finance

  6. Rolling Over Company Stock: A Decision ...
    Retirement

    Rolling Over Company Stock: A Decision ...

  7. Do Financial Decisions Get Better With ...
    Active Trading Fundamentals

    Do Financial Decisions Get Better With ...

  8. Why is Game Theory useful in business?
    Options & Futures

    Why is Game Theory useful in business?

  9. Game Theory: Beyond The Basics
    Options & Futures

    Game Theory: Beyond The Basics

  10. The Basics Of Game Theory
    Fundamental Analysis

    The Basics Of Game Theory

comments powered by Disqus
Hot Definitions
  1. National Best Bid and Offer - NBBO

    A term applying to the SEC requirement that brokers must guarantee customers the best available ask price when they buy securities and the best available bid price when they sell securities.
  2. Maintenance Margin

    The minimum amount of equity that must be maintained in a margin account. In the context of the NYSE and FINRA, after an investor has bought securities on margin, the minimum required level of margin is 25% of the total market value of the securities in the margin account.
  3. Leased Bank Guarantee

    A bank guarantee that is leased to a third party for a specific fee. The issuing bank will conduct due diligence on the creditworthiness of the customer looking to secure a bank guarantee, then lease a guarantee to that customer for a set amount of money and over a set period of time, typically less than two years.
  4. Degree Of Financial Leverage - DFL

    A ratio that measures the sensitivity of a company’s earnings per share (EPS) to fluctuations in its operating income, as a result of changes in its capital structure. Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) measures the percentage change in EPS for a unit change in earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT).
  5. Jeff Bezos

    Self-made billionaire Jeff Bezos is famous for founding online retail giant Amazon.com.
  6. Re-fracking

    Re-fracking is the practice of returning to older wells that had been fracked in the recent past to capitalize on newer, more effective extraction technology. Re-fracking can be effective on especially tight oil deposits – where the shale products low yields – to extend their productivity.
Trading Center