Earnings Quality: Measuring The Discretionary Portion Of Accruals
By
Using the raw accrual amounts as a proxy for earnings management is a simple method to evaluate earnings quality because firms can have high accruals for legitimate business reasons, such as sales growth. A more complicated proxy can be created by attempting to categorize total accruals into nondiscretionary and discretionary accruals. The nondiscretionary component reflects business conditions (such as growth and the length of the operating cycle) that naturally create and destroy accruals, while the discretionary component identifies management choices. The result of pulling discretionary accrual amounts from the total accrual amount is a metric that reflects accruals that are due to management's choices alone; in other words, there appears to be no business reason for these accruals. So, discretionary accruals are a better proxy for earnings quality.
There are many approaches used in an attempt to estimate this nondiscretionary accrual proxy, but estimating the nondiscretionary component of accruals typically involves a regression model. Identifying discretionary accruals by regression can be difficult in practice, and different approaches differ in practically every respect: how to measure the dependent variable (total net accruals or net operating accruals), what to use as independent variables and whether to use a crosssectional model or a timeseries model.
Measuring the Dependent Variable
Either total net accruals or net operating accruals can be used as the dependent variable. Recall from above that we have defined both of these dependent variables from the cash flow statement as:
Total Net Accruals = Net Income  ฮCash  Cash Dividends  Stock Repurchases + Equity Issuance 
And
Net Operating Accruals = Net Income  Cash Flow from Operations 
Many studies have used the balance sheet to calculate total net accruals or net operating accruals, but due to nonarticulation issues, the cashflow approach is better suited to describing accruals in all situations, and we will not detail how to calculate accruals from balance sheet data here.
Choosing Independent Variables
The independent variables are data items that should have some relationship to nondiscretionary accruals. For example, normal accruals driven by sales, PP&E, expected sales growth and current operating performance. A simple (and one of the most commonly used) model to estimate the nondiscretionary accrual component is the Modified Jones Model (1991). It may or may not be the best model. It surely isn't perfect, but other variables can be added to the equation in an attempt to increase the model's precision. In addition, a fourth variable such as the lifecycle score may capture relationships in total net accruals or operating net accruals that the current three variables in the regression fail to capture. The model can be represented as follows:
TNA / ATA = ฮฒ_{0} + ฮฒ_{1}(1/ATA) + ฮฒ_{2}(ฮSales โ ฮRec / ATA) + ฮฒ_{3}(GPPE / ATA ) + ฮต 
Or
NOA / ATA = ฮฒ_{0} + ฮฒ_{1}(1/ATA) + ฮฒ_{2}(ฮSales โ ฮRec / ATA) + ฮฒ_{3}(GPPE / ATA ) + ฮต 
Where:
TNA= Total net accruals
NOA= Net operating accruals
ATA = Average total assets
ฮSales = Change in sales
ฮRec= Change in accounts receivable
GPPE = Gross PP&E
Each ฮฒ is the estimated relationship of the independent variable to the dependent variable, and the error term represents the composite effect of all variables not explicitly stated as an independent variable.
Using CrossSectional or TimeS
The model can be employed by regressing accrual data from many firms in the same industry for one time period (crosssectional) or by regressing accrual data from the same firm across several time periods (timeseries). There are disadvantages to both methods, but the crosssectional analysis is probably a better method for the following technical reasons:
 Timeseries analysis may not have enough enough observations in the estimation period to obtain reliable parameter estimates for a linear regression.
 The coefficient estimates on ฮSales and GPPE may not be stationary over time.
 The selfreversing property of accruals may result in serially correlated residuals.
If any of these issues above is true, it is impossible to make valid statistical inferences from the regression results obtained with timeseries analysis.
TimeSeries Analysis
To estimate the nondiscretionary accrual amounts, firmspecific amounts for each independent variable are used for each period/year over a sequence of periods/years. In essence, think of each data item [(TNA / ATA), (1/ATA),(ฮSales โ ฮRec / ATA) and (GPPE / ATA )] as coming from the same firm, with each data set being from a different time period. For example, the data set might be one firm with accounting data from each year between 1977 and 2007.
The error term, ฮต, is the estimate of discretionary accruals. This discretionary accrual estimate for the firm can then be used to rank the firm with respect to its peers and all other firms in the universe. A high level of discretionary accruals relative to peers would indicate that earnings quality is relatively low. Meanwhile, a low level of discretionary accruals would indicate that earnings quality is relatively high.
CrossSectional Analysis
In a crosssectional analysis, the model is a twostage model. This means that results from the first part of the analysis are plugged into the next stage to get the needed estimate.
To estimate the nondiscretionary accrual amounts, firmspecific amounts for each independent variable are used for a particular period across several different firms. In essence, think of each data item [(TNA / ATA), (1/ATA),(ฮSales โ ฮRec / ATA) and (GPPE / ATA )] as coming from the same time period with the next data set being from a different firm. For example, the data set might be 45 different firms with accounting data for the year ending 2007.
Once ฮฒ_{0}, ฮฒ_{1}, ฮฒ_{2} and ฮฒ_{3} have been estimated for the crosssection of firms for the period (which is calculated by the computer running a regression equation), we have denoted these estimates as ฮฒ_{0}, ฮฒ_{ 1}, ฮฒ_{ 2}, ฮฒ_{ 3}. Use these crosssectional coefficients along with a specific firm's data to estimate the individual firm's nondiscretionary accruals for the period. After processing, the calculation results in an estimate for nondiscretionary accruals scaled by average total assets, represented by NDA / ATA below.
NDA / ATA = ฮฒ_{ 0} + ฮฒ_{ 1}(1/ATA) + ฮฒ_{ 2}(ฮSales โ ฮRec / ATA) + ฮฒ_{ 3}(GPPE / ATA ) + ฮต 
Total discretionary accruals are the difference between the individual firm's scaled total net accruals and its estimated total nondiscretionary accrual amount.
TDA = TNA / ATA โ NDA / ATA 
If, instead, the regression is run with net operating accruals as the dependent variable, the equations would yield an estimate for just the operating component of nondiscretionary accruals.
ODA = NOA / ATA โ NDA / ATA 
The discretionaryaccrual estimate for the firm, whether it is based on total net accruals or net operating accruals, can then be ranked against the discretionary accrual estimates of the firm's peers and all other firms in the universe. This ranking is a comparative measure of the size of discretionary accruals, and it is a proxy for the quality of the firm's earnings. A high amount of discretionary accruals indicates lowerquality earnings and is a red flag that management may be using aggressive accounting to overstate earnings.
Earnings Quality: Conclusion

ShortTerm Debt
An account shown in the current liabilities portion of a company's ... 
Audit
An unbiased examination and evaluation of the financial statements ... 
IRR Rule
A measure for evaluating whether to proceed with a project or ... 
Profit and Loss Statement (P&L)
A financial statement that summarizes the revenues, costs and ... 
Discounted Payback Period
A capital budgeting procedure used to determine the profitability ... 
Contribution Margin
A cost accounting concept that allows a company to determine ...

What is finance?
"Finance" is a broad term that describes two related activities: the study of how money is managed and the actual process ... Read Full Answer >> 
What items are considered liquid assets?
A liquid asset is cash on hand or an asset that can be readily converted to cash. An asset that can readily be converted ... Read Full Answer >> 
What is the 'Rule of 72'?
The 'Rule of 72' is a simplified way to determine how long an investment will take to double, given a fixed annual rate of ... Read Full Answer >> 
What is the formula for calculating EBITDA?
When analyzing financial fitness, corporate accountants and investors alike closely examine a company's financial statements ... Read Full Answer >> 
How do I calculate the P/E ratio of a company?
The priceearnings ratio (P/E ratio) is a valuation measure that compares the level of stock prices to the level of corporate ... Read Full Answer >> 
What is a stock split? Why do stocks split?
All publiclytraded companies have a set number of shares that are outstanding on the stock market. A stock split is a decision ... Read Full Answer >>