Exchange-Traded Funds: Index Funds Vs. ETFs
In much of the previous discussion comparing mutual funds to ETFs, the merits of actively managed mutual funds are compared to the passively managed ETFs. In some ways, it is like comparing apple to oranges. They have entirely different characteristics. If a passive approach is desired, an investor should then consider how best to implement it - by using index funds or exchange traded funds.
Index Funds and ETFs
Index funds have been available in the U.S. since the 1970s; ETFs were first traded in the U.S. in 1993. Although the number of index funds and ETFs are close, ETFs cover about five times as many indexes. Some of the newer ETFs track some indexes that are more appropriate for an ETF structure than for an index fund. Consequently, an investor might only be able to track an index by using ETFs because there are no index funds available that can track that same index
ETFs and index funds each offer advantages and disadvantages for managing the costs of the underlying assets. In some cases, the difference in fees might favor one over the other. Investors can buy no-load index funds without incurring any transaction costs. Investors buying ETFs will have to pay brokerage commissions.
The nature of ETFs requires them to accumulate dividends or interest received from the underlying securities until it is distributed to shareholders at the end of each quarter. Index funds invest their dividends or interest income immediately. (For more insight, read Advantages Of Exchange-Traded Funds.)
An investor with a portfolio of index funds or ETFs occasionally rebalances the portfolio, selling some of the positions and purchasing others. A portfolio containing ETFs incurs commissions by buying and selling the ETFs. Because the investor typically trades in board lots, getting the exact weightings of each ETF desired is practically impossible. This is especially true for small portfolios. With index funds, an investor can achieve exact asset allocation weightings because the investor can purchase fractional units. No-load funds have no transaction costs. (For more on this topic, read Rebalance Your Portfolio To Stay On Track.)
The technique of using ETFs for dollar-cost averaging - spending a fixed dollar amount at regular intervals on a portfolio - is generally impractical. The commission costs and the extra cost involved in buying odd-lot shares makes this strategy very expensive to implement. Mutual funds are a more suitable investment vehicle for dollar-cost averaging.
A lack of liquidity on some ETFs, resulting in an increase in the bid-ask spread, adds to the cost of trading ETFs. Also, the less popular ETFs are not likely to have the same arbitrage interest of other ETFs, resulting in a potentially larger difference between market prices and net asset value (NAV). Investors in index funds can always get the NAV at the end of the day.Exchange-Traded Funds: Equity ETFs
Exchange-traded funds that follow a specific benchmark index ...
An exchange-traded fund (ETF) that tracks other ETFs rather than ...
A security that tracks an index, a commodity or a basket of assets ...
One of two types of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) available for ...
A security that tracks a particular set of equities, similar ...
An exchange-traded fund (ETF) that employs an active investment ...
Learn about the difference between an index fund and an exchange-traded fund and how index fund investing compares to value ... Read Answer >>
Learn advantages to investing in exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, and index funds, and decide whether to include them in your ... Read Answer >>
An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is a security that tracks an index but has the flexibility of trading like a stock. Just like ... Read Answer >>
Learn about exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which can generate capital gains for their shareholders due to occasional and substantial ... Read Answer >>
Understand all the various costs, both explicit and hidden, involved in trading exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, and see how ... Read Answer >>
Investing in ETFs or index funds is a matter of personal choice, but market logic advocates ETFs for rebalancing funds and ... Read Answer >>