
Mutual Funds: Evaluating Performance
Perhaps you've noticed all those mutual fund ads that quote their amazingly high oneyear rates of return. Your first thought is "wow, that mutual fund did great!" Well, yes it did great last year, but then you look at the threeyear performance, which is lower, and the five year, which is yet even lower. What's the underlying story here? Let's look at a real example from a large mutual fund's performance:
1 year  3 year  5 year 
53%  20%  11% 
L
ast year, the fund had excellent performance at 53%. But, in the past three years, the average annual return was 20%. What did it do in years 1 and 2 to bring the average return down to 20%? Some simple math shows us that the fund made an average return of 3.5% over those first two years: 20% = (53% + 3.5% + 3.5%)/3. Because that is only an average, it is very possible that the fund lost money in one of those years.
It gets worse when we look at the fiveyear performance. We know that in the last year the fund returned 53% and in years 2 and 3 we are guessing it returned around 3.5%. So what happened in years 4 and 5 to bring the average return down to 11%? Again, by doing some simple calculations we find that the fund must have lost money, an average of 2.5% each year of those two years: 11% = (53% + 3.5% + 3.5%  2.5%  2.5%)/5. Now the fund's performance doesn't look so good!
It should be mentioned that, for the sake of simplicity, this example, besides making some big assumptions, doesn't include calculating compound interest. Still, the point wasn't to be technically accurate but to demonstrate the importance of taking a closer look at performance numbers. A fund that loses money for a few years can bump the average up significantly with one or two strong years.
It's All Relative
Of course, knowing how a fund performed is only one third of the battle. Performance is a relative issue, literally. If the fund we looked at above is judged against its appropriate benchmark index, a whole new layer of information is added to the evaluation. If the index returned 75% for the 1 year time period, that 53% from the fund doesn't look quite so good. On the other hand, if the index delivered results of 25%, 5%, and 5% for the respective one, three, and fiveyear periods, then the fund's results look rather fine indeed.
To add another layer of information to the evaluation, one can consider a fund's performance against its peer group as well as against its index. If other funds that invest with a similar mandate had similar performance, this data point tells us that the fund is in line with its peers. If the fund bested its peers and its benchmark, its results would be quite impressive indeed.
Looking at any one piece of information in isolation only tells a small portion of the story. Consider the comparison of a fund against its peers. If the fund sits in the top slot over each of the comparison periods, it is likely to be a solid performer. If it sits at the bottom, it may be even worse than perceived, as peer group comparisons only capture the results from existing funds. Many fund companies are in the habit of closing their worst performers. When the "losers" are purged from their respective categories, their statistical records are no longer included in the category performance data. This makes the category averages creep higher than they would have if the losers were still in the mix. This is better known as survivorship bias. (Learn more about survivorship bias in The Truth Behind Mutual Fund Returns.)
To develop the best possible picture of fund's performance results, consider as many data points as you can. Longterm investors should focus on longterm results, keeping in mind that even the best performing funds have bad years from time to time. (Dig into the numbers in Mutual Fund Ratings: Are They Deceiving?)


Survivorship Bias
The tendency for mutual funds with poor performance to be dropped ... 
Mutual Fund
An investment vehicle that is made up of a pool of funds collected ... 
Fund Supermarkets
An investment firm or brokerage that offers investors a wide ... 
Fund Of Funds
A mutual fund that invests in other mutual funds. This method ... 
Average Annual Return  AAR
A percentage figure used when reporting the historical return, ... 
Mutual Fund Yield
Dividend payments divided by the value of a mutual fundâ€™s shares. ...

How do I judge a mutual fund's performance?
Evaluate mutual fund performance utilizing resources such as Morningstar; compare the fund with others in its peer group ... Read Answer >> 
How do I calculate the loantovalue ratio using Excel?
Learn what a mutual fund and a money market fund are, and understand the differences between each and how they serve various ... Read Answer >> 
What is an appropriate large cap mutual fund fee?
Discover what an appropriate fee for a largecap mutual fund should be, and learn how choosing index mutual funds can lead ... Read Answer >> 
How much of a company's stock can a mutual fund own?
There is no written rule that stipulates how much of a company a mutual fund can own. Instead, there are two major factors ... Read Answer >> 
Can mutual funds invest in hedge funds?
Learn about mutual fund portfolio management techniques and mutual funds' ability to invest in hedge funds, as well as new ... Read Answer >> 
Do mutual funds pay dividends or interest?
Learn how and why mutual funds pay interest or dividends, including the different funds and which types generate each type ... Read Answer >>