1. Perspectives on the Risk-Return Relationship
  2. Understanding Mutual Fund Returns
  3. Fund I-Q No.2: Favorable Risk-Return Profile
  4. Scoring Risk-Return Data

By Richard Loth (Contact | Biography)

As mentioned previously, a mutual fund's risk-return profile is important for a number of reasons:

  • Common sense tells us that a fund investor should get a return equal to or better than the fund's risk rating.
  • A risk-return profile helps an investor to make individual fund choices that are consistent with the over all risk profile of his or her portfolio.
  • A risk profile is a handy screening device to determine whether a fund's investment advisor is chasing risky investments to boost fund performance.
Investment Quality No.2 relates to the fund manager's ability and commitment to managing a mutual fund's assets according to as a positive a risk-return spread as possible over the course of several years. (For related reading, see Why Fund Managers Risk Too Much.)

As is always the case with any financial indicator, fund risk-return ratings should not be looked at in isolation. It would be prudent to correlate these findings with the long-term (five to 10 years) total returns and the management costs of the fund. For example, in comparing two funds with equal performance records, the one with less risk would warrant a higher investment quality rating than the other.

It is worthwhile to look at the risk-return relationship of some mutual funds to see this fund criterion in action. Morningstar's fund report provides an easy-to-use rating, which is the one we will apply here to a selection of stock and bond funds.



After perusing the following fund information, which fund do you think goes to the head of the class for the best positive risk-return spread?

Large-Cap Stock Return Risk
Fidelity Contrafund (FCNTX) High Below-Average
Janus (JANSX) Average Above-Average
Vanguard U.S, Growth (VWUSX) Average Average
Marsico Focus (MFOCX) Above-Average Average
White Oak Select Growth (WOGSX) Average High
Bond Return Risk
Pioneer High-Yield (TAHYX) Average Above-Average
Fidelity Intermediate (FTHRX) Average Below-Average
Davis Appreciation & Income (APFCX) High Low

If you chose the Davis Appreciation & Income Fund, you have grasped the concept behind fund investment quality. In general, most mutual funds will have but one positive "notch," or spread, between their return and risk rating spread. The Marsico and Fidelity Intermediate funds are examples of this status, while the stellar Fidelity Contrafund has a two "notch" positive spread. The Janus, White Oak, and Pioneer funds all show negative spreads, which is a circumstance that should raise some serious concern for fund investors.

Return to the Main Menu.

Scoring Risk-Return Data
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Measuring a Fund's Risk and Return

    Learn the importance of the risk-return relationship in selecting a mutual fund.
  2. Investing

    3 Fidelity Mutual Funds with Long Track Records

    Learn about mutual funds, provided by Fidelity Investments, that have long track records. Learn about the risks and rewards of lower-quality bonds.
  3. Investing

    Mutual Fund Investment Quality: Conclusion

    Check in here for an overview of mutual fund investment quality and how to find it.
  4. Financial Advisor

    Advising FAs: Explaining Mutual Funds to a Client

    More than 80 million people, or half of the households in America, invest in mutual funds. No matter what type of investor you are, there is bound to be a mutual fund that fits your style.
  5. Investing

    A Fund's Investment Objective

    Learn to evaluate a fund's investment objective, or "style".
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. How does the number of credit card accounts I have affect my credit score?

    Your credit score, which is also referred to as your FICO score, is a measure that creditors use to assess your potential ...
  2. What is the 'three-legged stool'?

    The "three-legged stool" was a retirement terminology from the past that many financial planners used to describe the three ...
  3. If I am looking to get an investment banking job, what education do employers prefer? MBA or CFA?

    If you are looking specifically for an investment banking position, an MBA may be marginally preferable over the CFA. The ...
  4. Is a Simplified Employee Pension (SEP) IRA tax deductible?

    Learn everything you need to know about your SEP IRA, including the benefits to employers and whether or not a SEP IRA is ...
Trading Center