Value Investing: Finding Value In Financial Reports And Balance Sheets
By Amy Fontinelle
There is plenty of information about a company that you'll want to know as a value investor but that you can't get from a casual glance at a stock quote or from reading most stock market commentary. In this section, we'll tell you where to find that information and what to look for.
Financial reports are a company's annual and quarterly performance results. The annual report is SEC form 10-K and the quarterly report is SEC form 10-Q. Companies are required to file these reports with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). You can find them at the SEC website or at the company's corporate or investor relations website.
You can learn a lot from a company's annual report. It will explain what products and/or services the company sells and give you an idea of how the company sees itself. For example, most people think of books when they think of Amazon.com. However, Amazon's annual report says, "We seek to be Earth's most customer-centric company for three primary customer sets: consumers, sellers, and enterprises. In addition, we generate revenue through other marketing and promotional services, such as online advertising, and co-branded credit card agreements." This statement tells investors that the company has a much broader focus than books. A company's financial reports will also describe its recent major accomplishments, changes in leadership, risk factors, intellectual property, any regulatory changes that affect the company and more.
If you're interested in investing in a company but you're not sure you understand its business model, try reading the annual report - it might be eye-opening. For example, you might not think of yourself as someone who would invest in a pharmaceutical company, but when you read its annual report and learn about what its major drugs are, why people need them and how they work, you might discover that you understand more than you expected to. However, if you're still lost after doing this research, you should probably pass on the stock.
Of course, financial reports also provide the financial data that investors want to analyze, such as revenues, operating expenses, net income, total assets, total debt and more. Financial reports also make it easy to compare these numbers across time by providing historical data along with current data. For example, a look at Amazon's 2010 10-K shows that Amazon's net sales have increased every year for the last five years, from $10,711 million in 2006 to $34,204 million in 2010. If you want to go back further in time, you can also look up older annual reports. Historical data should be analyzed to determine the effectiveness of growth prospects and to create forecasts.
Financial reports can also tell you a lot about the company's weaknesses. Amazon's 2010 annual report says, for example, "We Have a Rapidly Evolving Business Model and Our Stock Price Is Highly Volatile," "We May Be Subject to Product Liability Claims if People or Property Are Harmed by the Products We Sell," and "We Could Be Liable for Fraudulent or Unlawful Activities of Sellers." As a potential investor, you will want to think about how much of a threat these weaknesses are to your likelihood of earning a profit.
An essential component of any financial report is the company's financial statements. We'll examine two - the balance sheet and the income statement - that will give you many of the numbers you'll need for your value investment analysis.
The Balance Sheet
A company's balance sheet provides a big picture of the company's financial condition. The balance sheet consists of two sections, one listing the company's assets and another listing its liabilities and equity.
The assets section is broken down into a company's cash and cash equivalents; investments; trade receivables or accounts receivable; inventories; deferred tax assets; intangible assets; goodwill; property, plant and equipment; ant other assets. These subcategories won't be identical for every company you examine because different companies have different types of assets.
The liabilities section lists the company's accounts payable, accrued liabilities, convertible notes, long-term debt, other non-current liabilities, and any other outstanding debts that the company may have. The shareholders equity section of the balance sheet reflects how much money is invested into the company in addition to the cumulative retained earnings. Again, these subcategories won't be identical for every company you examine because different companies have different types of liabilities. (For example, an insurance company might list "unearned premiums" as a liability, but a food service company would not.)
One important ratio that value investors like to calculate using balance sheet data is called the current ratio. The current ratio compares the company's total current assets to its total current liabilities. Current assets will be utilized within a year and current liabilities must be covered within the same time frame.
The higher the ratio, the better, but value investors like to see a current ratio of at least 2 to 1, meaning that the company has at least twice as many current assets as current liabilities. The current ratio indicates how easily a company can cover its current obligations and reveal the general liquidity position of the firm. Comparing a company's current ratio for the most recent year to that of previous years and to that of similar companies for the same years will help you put this number into perspective.
For some calculations, you can let someone else do the math for you - Yahoo! Finance, for example, provides the current ratio and many other important metrics under a category called "Key Statistics" when you look up a company's ticker symbol.
While you're at it, you can also calculate net current assets per share. To get net current assets (also called working capital or current capital), you subtract current liabilities from current assets. Divide the result by the number of shares outstanding and you get net current assets per share. (You can find a company's shares outstanding through the company's financial statement - specifically the income statement.) A lower net current asset per share figure is considered a green light for value investors to continue with the analysis.
The balance sheet also provides a snapshot of a company's long-term finances. Long-term assets may be lumped together under a term like "fixed assets" or "property, plant and equipment." Included in these categories are assets such as the real estate and factories the company owns. "Intangible assets" is also a long-term asset; it attempts to measure the value of the company's intellectual property holdings (copyrights, trademarks and patents). Long-term liabilities are a company's financial obligations whose maturity is longer than one year, including real estate leases and bond issues.
Another important number to get from the balance sheet is the company's debt-to-assets ratio. To get this number, divide total liabilities by total assets. (Note that the term "debt" is used very loosely in this ratio because it includes all of a company's liabilities, not just its long term debt.) Graham avoided companies whose debt exceeded 50% of assets. The lower the company's debt ratio, the better. (Read The Debt Ratio to learn more.)
Book value per share and price-to-book ratio are also meaningful. Book value is the company's net worth - its assets minus its liabilities. The book value per share statistic is obtained by dividing the company's net worth by the number of shares outstanding. Value investors are interested in companies when their stock price is below book value per share. If a company has a net worth of $10 million and it has 500,000 shares outstanding, its book value per share is $10,000,000 / 500,000, or $20. If the stock is trading for $15, it may be worth researching further. Comparing the $15 stock price to the $20 book value gives us the price-to-book ratio. ($15/$20 = 0.75)
These aren't the only financial ratios you can calculate using the numbers on the balance sheet, but they are a few of the most basic ones. (For further reading, see Reading The Balance Sheet and our Financial Ratio Tutorial.)
If a company's balance sheet doesn't check out or if you can't understand it, cross the stock off your list and move on.
Next, let's look at what you can learn from income statements.
Known as "the Oracle of Omaha", Buffett is Chairman of Berkshire ...
The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders ...
An announcement by an investor who holds a security that he or ...
The total return received from holding an asset or portfolio ...
A psychological phenomenon in which past events seem to be more ...
A ratio of a company’s cash flow from operations to its total ...
Learn what the average price to book (P/B) ratio is in the banking industry and how the P/B evaluation is used when analyzing ...
Read about some of the formulas for free cash flow, why investors perform cash flow analysis and what a high or rising cash ...
Learn how to differentiate between two of the most popular ratios used in finance and accounting: return on sales and return ...
Read the books that taught master investor Warren Buffet everything he knows about the market, stocks, security analysis ...