Now that you're familiar with both NPV and IRR and understand the shortcomings of PB period and ARR, let's compare the advantages and disadvantages of NPV and IRR. Advantages:
- The NPV method is a direct measure of the dollar contribution to the stockholders.
- The IRR method shows the return on the original money invested.
- The NPV method does not measure the project size.
- The IRR method can, at times, give you conflicting answers when compared to NPV for mutually exclusive projects. The "multiple IRR problem" can also be an issue, as discussed below.
The Multiple IRR Problem
A multiple IRR problem occurs when cash flows during the project lifetime are negative (i.e. the project operates at a loss or the company needs to contribute more capital).
This is known as a "non-normal cash flow," and such cash flows will give multiple IRRs.
Why Do NPV and IRR Methods Produce Conflicting Rankings?
When a project is an independent project, meaning the decision to invest in a project is independent of any other projects, both the NPV and IRR will always give the same result, either rejecting or accepting a project.
While NPV and IRR are useful metrics for analyzing mutually exclusive projects - that is, when the decision must be one project or another - these metrics do not always point you in the same direction. This is a result of the timing of cash flows for each project. In addition, conflicting results may simply occur because of the project sizes.
The timing of cash flows as well as project sizes can produce conflicting results in the NPV and IRR methods.
Example: NPV and IRR Analysis
Assume once again that Newco needs to purchase a new machine for its manufacturing plant. Newco has narrowed it down to two machines that meet its criteria (Machine A and Machine B), and now it has to choose one of the machines to purchase. Further, Newco has assumed the following analysis on which to base its decision:
We first determine the NPV for each machine as follows:
NPVA = ($5,000) + $2,768 + $2.553 = $321
NPVB = ($10,000) + $5,350 + $5,106 = $456
According to the NPV analysis alone, Machine B is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.
The next step is to determine the IRR for each machine using our financial calculator. The IRR for Machine A is equal to 13%, whereas the IRR for Machine B is equal to 11%.
According to the IRR analysis alone, Machine A is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.
The NPV and IRR analysis for these two projects give us conflicting results. This is most likely due to the timing of the cash flows for each project as well as the size difference between the two projects.
InvestingUse this method to choose which project or investment is right for you.
InvestingRead about the similarities and differences between an investment's internal rate of return (IRR) and its return on investment (ROI).
InvestingThe internal rate of return, or IRR, is a popular metric businesses use to measure a project’s return on investment.
Small BusinessThe internal rate of return on investments is explained and illustrated in different investment scenarios.
Small BusinessUsing internal rate of return and net present value for capital budgeting evaluations often end in the same result. But there are times when using NPV to discount cash flows makes more sense.
Financial AdvisorInternal rate of return, or IRR, is one of the most popular methods of evaluating potential projects. Learn more about this important metric.
InvestingWe look at three widely used valuation methods and figure out how companies justify spending.
Financial AdvisorHow you can use the internal rate of return to compare and purchase a permanent life insurance policy.
Small BusinessModified internal rate of return (MIRR) is a variant of the more traditional internal rate of return calculation.
Personal FinanceDiscover more about the specific tasks that project managers are responsible for and the average salary that can be expected in such a position.