Depending upon the investor, exchange-traded funds may have possible drawbacks. No-load mutual fund investors would need to open a brokerage account and pay commissions to trade. Frequent, small investments that are part of a dollar-cost averaging strategy could prove to be more expensive. Additionally, investors need to understand that passive ETFs are subject to tracking errors, some to a greater degree than others, where the manager may not be able to purchase some illiquid securities in the index and must attempt index replication through sampling the liquid securities in it. Product complexity is always a consideration.

Investors must also understand differences in settlement procedures. Whereas mutual funds settle next-day, ETFs settle in three business days. The investor must have cash on hand to pay for purchases. Retail investors would be more likely to find these differences a challenge than institutional ones. Below is a table that better illustrates the differences between the two financial instruments.

ETF Mutual Fund
Daily and continuous pricing Forward pricing
Exchange traded Fund redemption at day\'s end
No tax effect of trading on shareholders Large redemptions may cause capital gains distributions for non-redeeming fund shareholders
In-kind redemption reduces shareholder tax liability Fund managers limited in their ability to manage taxes due to cash redemptions
Limit, stop limit orders, short selling allowed No limit order pricing or short selling permitted
May be purchased and sold on margin No margin trades allowed
Lower expense ratios as client services born by brokerage firms Expenses tend to be higher due to sales loads
May be purchased in any brokerage account Fund availability depends on existence of selling agreements with the broker/dealer
Brokerage commissions applicable transaction costs, load funds through a broker often have sales charge or commission

Whatever choice investors make, they need to have a clear picture of their objectives and constraints, either through simple data gathering or more elaborate work with an investment advisor who can put together an Investment Policy Statement. Additionally, as with any investment, investors need to understand the risk and return profile of the asset classes in which they plan to invest and how the instruments work. Once they do, the choice of mutual fund or exchange-traded fund is simply a matter of implementation.



Unit Investment Trusts

Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    5 Things All Financial Advisors Should Know About ETFs

    Discover five things all financial advisors should know about ETFs, including when ETFs may be a better choice for your clients than mutual funds.
  2. Financial Advisor

    Index Mutual Funds Vs. Index ETFs

    When considering an index mutual fund versus the ETF variety, investors should consult an experienced professional.
  3. Investing

    No Load Vs. Index Fund: Is One Better Than the Other?

    Find out how no-load funds, index mutual funds and ETFs can help investors boost returns just by cutting down on expenses and sales charges.
  4. Trading

    Fund Costs and Expenses

    How much a fund charges for its services is the most important indicator of how well it will perform.
  5. Investing

    Comparing ETFs Vs. Mutual Funds For Tax Efficiency

    Explore a comparison of mutual funds and exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, and learn what makes ETFs a significantly more tax-efficient investment.
  6. Investing

    When Is the Right Time to Change From Mutual Funds to ETFs

    Find out how to determine when it's the right time for you to switch from mutual funds to ETFs, including the benefits of ETFs and who they are best for.
  7. Investing

    ETFs Or Mutual Funds For Your IRA?

    Most actively managed mutual funds fail to beat the market over a long period of time, so it's probably best to go with ETFs for your IRA.
  8. Investing

    What You Need to Know About Mutual Funds

    Mutual funds are a good investment opportunity, but investors should know how they operate.
  9. Financial Advisor

    5 Secrets You Didn’t Know About Mutual Funds

    Learn five of the "secrets" about mutual funds that can have a significant impact on mutual fund choices and investor profitability.
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. What is the difference between yield and return?

    While both terms are often used to describe the performance of an investment, yield and return are not one and the same ...
  2. What are the Differences Among a Real Estate Agent, a broker and a Realtor?

    Learn how agents, realtors, and brokers are often considered the same, but in reality, these real estate positions have different ...
  3. What is the difference between amortization and depreciation?

    Because very few assets last forever, one of the main principles of accrual accounting requires that an asset's cost be proportionally ...
  4. Which is better, a fixed or variable rate loan?

    A variable interest rate loan is a loan in which the interest rate charged on the outstanding balance varies as market interest ...
Trading Center