Principal Trading vs. Agency Trading: An Overview
Have you ever wondered what happens when you buy or sell a stock through a stockbroker? Trading is as simple as clicking a mouse, but it is actually quite a complicated matter behind the scenes. When entering an equity order on your computer or through your broker, you are, on some occasions, trading with another person through an exchange. On other occasions, you are only making a trade with your broker. These two main types of trades are known as principal and agent transactions. Principal trades involve a brokerage's own inventory of securities, while agency trading involves trading with another investor, potentially at another brokerage.
- Principal trading is when a brokerage completes a customer's trade using their own inventory.
- Agency trading involves a brokerage finding a counterparty to the customer's trade, which can include customers at other brokerages.
- Principal trading allows brokers to also profit from the bid-ask spread.
- With agency trading, the broker must find someone willing to buy or sell the security for the same price as the counterparty.
Principal trading occurs when a brokerage buys securities in the secondary market, holds these securities for a period of time and then sells them. The purpose behind principal trading is for firms (also referred to as dealers) to create profits for their own portfolios through price appreciation. So, when an investor buys and sells stock through a brokerage firm that acts as the principal, the firm will use its own inventory on hand to fill the order for the client. With this method, brokerage firms earn extra income (over and above the commissions charged) by making money from the bid-ask spread as well.
For instance, if you were looking to buy 100 shares of ABC at $10, the principal firm would first check its own inventory to see whether or not the shares are available to sell to you. If they are available, the firm would sell the shares to you and then report the transaction to the necessary exchange. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and exchanges require that the brokerage firms complete the trades at prices comparable to those of the market.
An agency transaction is the other popular method for executing a client's orders. More complicated than regular principal transactions, these deals involve the search for and transfer of securities between clients of different brokerages. The increasing number of participants in the securities market and the need for extremely accurate bookkeeping, clearing, settlement, and reconciliation make ensuring the smooth flow of the securities markets quite a task.
Agency transactions are comprised of two distinct parts. First, your brokerage needs to bring your request to the appropriate market in order to find a party wishing to assume the opposite position. So, if you wish to buy at a certain price, the broker needs to find someone wishing to sell at the same price and vice versa. Once both parties are found, the exchange records the transaction on its ticker tape, and an exchange of money and securities between the parties occurs on the settlement.
The second portion of the agency transaction occurs after the trade is completed and has been properly documented on the exchange. This portion is commonly referred to as clearing. While all brokers maintain individual books recording the entire amount of buy and sell orders transacted by clients, the actual act of clearing these transactions is handled by a larger institution. In North America, the institution handling the vast majority of clearing and safekeeping duties is the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC).
The basic act of clearing involves matching buys and sells. Once the transactions are executed on the exchange, details of the trades are sent to a subsidiary of the DTCC called the National Securities Clearing Corporation and are subsequently recorded and matched for accuracy. After all the trades sent by member firms to the DTCC are matched for buys and sells, the DTCC then notifies all member firms of their associated obligations and arranges the transfer of the appropriate funds and securities.
Thus, rather than having individual brokers dealing with one another after every trade on a securities exchange, the DTCC acts as an intermediary, collecting all transactions and streamlining the transfer of stocks and cash. This reduces the amount of time required for delivery and receipt of obligations and provides flexibility for brokerages in choosing dealing partners. This entire clearing process usually takes two business days to complete.
It is important to note that the DTCC not only facilitates but also guarantees delivery. If one party fails to deliver the securities or cash to the other, the DTCC will step in and fulfill the obligations of the failing party.
Although you cannot specify to your broker how you want the trade to be filled, as a client you have the right to know how your transaction was completed. Brokers are required to inform you whether a filled trade was an agency or principal transaction. Typically, you are notified in your trade confirmation sent in the mail or electronically.
Although this information might not make you any more money in the market, it is important for investors to understand the process of filling orders. These two ways of transacting orders not only help reduce the risk for investors, but also give brokerage clients a relatively liquid and efficient way of placing and executing trades.