It can be really easy to get caught up in the hype of how great exchange-traded funds (ETF) are. Yet they still come with many of the same risks as stocks and mutual funds, plus some unique risks for ETFs. Here's a look at the "fine print" for ETFs.
- ETFs are considered to be low-risk investments because they are low-cost and hold a basket of stocks or other securities, increasing diversification.
- Still, unique risks can arise from holding ETFs, including special considerations paid to taxation depending on the type of ETF.
- For active traders of ETFs, additional market risk and specific risk such as the liquidity of an ETF or its components can arise.
Tax efficiency is one of the most promoted advantages of an ETF. While certain ETFs, such as a U.S. Stock Equity Index ETF, come with great tax efficiency, many other types do not. In fact, not understanding the tax implications of an ETF you're invested in can add up to a nasty surprise in the form of a bigger-than-expected tax bill.
ETFs create tax efficiency by using in-kind exchanges with authorized participants (AP). Instead of the fund manager needing to sell stocks to cover redemptions like they do in a mutual fund, the manager of an ETF uses an exchange of an ETF unit for the actual stocks within the fund. This creates a scenario where the capital gains on the stocks are actually paid by the AP and not the fund. Thus you will not receive capital gains distributions at the end of the year.
However, once you move away from index ETFs there are more taxation issues that can potentially happen. For example, actively managed ETFs may not do all of their selling via an in-kind exchange. They can actually incur capital gains which would then need to be distributed to the fund holders.
Tax Exposures to Different ETF Types
If the ETF is of the international variety it may not have the ability to do in-kind exchanges. Some countries do not allow for in-kind redemption, thus creating capital gain issues.
If the ETF uses derivatives to accomplish their objective, then there will be capital gains distributions. You cannot do in-kind exchanges for these types of instruments, so they must be bought and sold on the regular market. Funds that typically use derivatives are leveraged funds, and inverse funds.
Finally, commodity ETFs have very different tax implications depending on how the fund is structured. There are three types of fund structures and they include: grantor trusts, limited partnerships (LP) and exchange-traded notes (ETN). Each of these structures have different tax rules. For example, if you are in a grantor trust for a precious metal you are taxed as if it were a collectible.
The takeaway is that ETF investors need to pay attention to what the ETF is investing in, where those investments are located and how the actual fund is structured. If you have doubts on the tax implications check with your tax advisor.
One of the most advantageous aspects of investing in an ETF is the fact that you can buy it like a stock. However this also creates many risks that can hurt your investment return.
First it can change your mindset from investor to active trader. Once you start trying to time the market or pick the next hot sector it is easy to get caught up in regular trading. Regular trading adds cost to your portfolio thus eliminating one of the benefits of ETFs, low fees.
Additionally, regular trading to try and time the market is really hard to do successfully. Even paid fund managers struggle to do this every year, with most not beating the indexes. While you may make money you would be further ahead to stick with an index ETF and not trade it.
Finally, adding on to those excess trading negatives you subject yourself to more liquidity risk. Not all ETFs have a large asset base or high trading volume. If you find yourself in a fund that has a large bid-ask spread and low volume you could run into problems with closing out your position. That pricing inefficiency could cost you even more money and even incur greater losses if you can't get out of the fund in a timely fashion.
ETFs are often used to diversify passive portfolio strategies, but this is not always the case. There are many types of risk that come with any portfolio, everything from market risk to political risk to business risk. With the wide availability of specialty ETFs it's easy to increase your risk across all areas and thus increase the overall riskiness of your portfolio.
Every time you add a single country fund you add political and liquidity risk. If you buy into a leveraged ETF you are amplifying how much you will lose if the investment goes down. You can also quickly mess up your asset allocation with each additional trade that you make, thus increasing your overall market risk.
By being able to trade in and out of ETFs with many niche offerings it can be easy to forget to take the time to ensure you are not too making your portfolio too risky. Finding this out would happen when the market is going down and there is not much you can do to fix it then.
Although rarely considered by the average investor, tracking errors can have an unexpected material effect on an investor's returns. It is important to investigate this aspect of any ETF index fund before investing.
The goal of an ETF index fund is to track a specific market index, often referred to as the fund's target index. The difference between the returns of the index fund and the target index is known as a fund's tracking error.
Most of the time, the tracking error of an index fund is small, perhaps only a few tenths of one percent. However, a variety of factors can sometimes conspire to open a gap of several percentage points between the index fund and its target index. In order to avoid such an unwelcome surprise, index investors should understand how these gaps may develop.
Lack of Price Discovery
One risk that some analysts fear may be on the horizon is a situation where a vast majority of investing turns to passive indexed investing utilizing ETFs. If a preponderance of investors hold ETFs and do not trade the individual stocks that sit inside of them, then price discovery for the individual securities that constitute and index may be less efficient. In the worst case, if everybody owns just ETFs, then nobody is left to price the component stocks and thus the market breaks.
The Bottom Line
ETFs have become so popular because of the many advantages they offer. Still, investors must keep in mind that they aren't without risks. Know the risks and plan around them then you can take full advantage of the benefits of an ETF.