Using Caution When Trading Pink Sheets Stocks

Finding stocks with higher-than-average returns is difficult because markets are efficient, and information is readily reflected in stock prices. Investors, therefore, need to find the diamond in the rough. The Pink Sheets represent highly speculative penny stocks that trade over-the-counter (OTC) and are only loosely regulated. For this reason, some investors turn to Pink Sheets stocks to find a security that can return multiples of its basis - where more risk may translate to more return (or not!).

What Are the Pink Sheets?

Pink sheets is a daily publication of bid-ask stock quotations for companies unable or unwilling, for one reason or another, to be listed on a major, national exchange. The pink sheets name came about because the paper the quotes were printed on was pink. Because pink sheets is a quotation service and not an exchange, investors must do their due diligence before trading in these over-the-counter (OTC) stocks and follow several rules to ensure the investments are sound and made at expected prices.

Stocks listed on the Pink Sheets will have ticker symbols ending in .PK.

Who Trades on the Pink Sheets?

Roughly 10,000 stocks trade on the pink sheets, ranging from small, speculative companies to large, foreign companies. Companies trade OTC for several reasons:

• A company fails to meet the listing requirements for the major stock exchanges.
• A company is de-listed from the major exchanges, often for lack of financial information.
• A company falls off after their stock drops under $1.00.
• A foreign company does not want to meet the filing and listing requirements of the major U.S. exchanges when they already meet the requirements in their home country. Hiring a team of regulatory and legal personnel who are experts in U.S. security law and filing requirements is expensive; especially considering the companies already have a similar team to handle these requirements in their home country.

Household names like Nestle, Nintendo, and Volkswagen are three examples of quality companies that list on the pink sheets.

Pros and Cons to Pink Sheets Stocks

One advantage of investing in pink sheet stocks is to find fallen angels or diamonds in the rough that could indeed be very good investments and bargain basement prices. Indeed one advantage lies in their inexpensive prices. Some shares can be bought for less than $1.00.

In contrast, there are quite a few potential downsides. Pink sheets stocks lack liquidity and are often thinly traded, which can make them volatile. The bid-ask spread is wide, and investors need to be patient and cautious when putting in any buy or sell order. In addition, despite some of the quality companies, many are worthless.

Because pink sheets is not an exchange, but a quotation service, it is unregulated and can, therefore, result in scams or other potentially harmful investments. Minimal to no transparency or fundamental information is available for many of the stocks, while some are subject to various schemes. 

The pink sheets also disallow margins and short selling, which can be either positive or negative, depending on the investor's viewpoint. As a result of the aforementioned downsides, investors need to be cautious.

Caveat Emptor

Investors should also be aware of four additional cautions.

1. First, most OTC stocks do not meet the minimum requirements for most exchanges and do not file with the SEC. Therefore, credible and reliable fundamental data are not available for analysis. 
2. Second, historically, Pink Sheets stocks are penny stocks and are often near-insolvent companies.
3. Third, some stocks are illegitimate shell companies set up to scam investors by issuing press releases and having “analysts” promote the stock and issue more worthless shares. 
4. Fourth, pink sheets only have one requirement for a company to list: A company needs to have one market maker quoting its stock. The listing companies do not have to provide any financial information at all. 

One common scam involving OTC investors is the pump and dump scheme where promoters buy penny stocks, promote and push up the prices for other investors and then dump their stocks while the late investors are stuck with worthless stock they overpaid to own. These stocks are often promoted in spam emails or on message boards and blogs. 

Seeking Improvement

Pink sheets has attempted to do away with many of the downsides, both real and perceived, associated with the service. For instance, by starting a premium listing service called OTCQX. This service has three different levels of trade minimums, and companies need to meet some or all of the requirements for being listed on a major exchange, including posting quarterly and annual reports and making public all relevant information.  

Despite these new service levels, investors should still follow some simple rules when trading on the pink sheets. These include doing your homework and knowing the company you are investing in. Just like when investing in any stock, investors should look for catalysts that will cause a potential investment to go up. Examples of catalysts include any upcoming news in favor of a company, such as winning a legal battle, the potential for a merger or acquisition, or a new product or service that will increase profits. Investors also need to set limits on the level of investment and sell signals. In addition, using a limit order instead of a market order should reduce the volatility concern.

The Bottom Line

Pink sheets stocks offer exciting opportunities to increase portfolio returns by large magnitudes in a short time. However, these opportunities come with significant risks. Investors need to be extremely cautious and diligent with research and analysis of each investment. Setting up strict investment guidelines and using limit orders when trading will decrease the potential risks. The pink sheets listing is full of many worthless companies, some of which are pure scams. Finding the hidden gem is difficult, but can be very rewarding.