The herd instinct kicks into overdrive when mutual fund investors hear the word "recession" and news reports show stock prices dropping. Fears of further declines and mounting losses chase investors out of stock funds and push them toward bond funds in a flight to safety.
This flight may be an effective tactic for investors who are risk-averse as they flee equities for the perceived safety of the fixed-income investment world. However, while some funds are less volatile than stocks, this is not true for the entire universe of mutual funds.
Read on for a look at bond funds that tend to outperform during tough market conditions like recessions.
A Strategy for Any Market
While bond funds and similarly conservative investments have shown their value as safe havens during tough times, investing like a lemming isn't the right strategy for investors seeking long-term growth. Investors also must understand that the safer an investment seems, the less income they can expect from the holding.
Market timing seldom works. Trying to time the market by selling your stock funds before they lose money and using the proceeds to buy bond funds or other conservative investments and then doing the reverse to capture the profits when the stock market rises is a risky game to play. The odds of making the right move are stacked against you. Even if you achieve success once, the odds of repeating that win over and over again throughout a lifetime of investing simply aren't in your favor.
A far better strategy is to build a diversified mutual fund portfolio. A properly constructed portfolio, including a mix of both stock and bonds funds, provides an opportunity to participate in stock market growth and cushions your portfolio when the stock market is in decline. Such a portfolio can be constructed by purchasing individual funds in proportions that match your desired asset allocation. Alternatively, you can do the entire job with a single fund by purchasing a mutual fund with "growth and income" or "balanced" in its name.
(To learn more, read: Managing A Portfolio Of Mutual Funds.)
- When there's an economic slowdown or even a recession, the prevailing wisdom is that investors should move away from equity funds and move toward fixed income.
- Fixed income may be a smart move, but don't try to time the markets by exiting stock funds when you think growth is slowing and then start investing in bond funds.
- Instead, have a diversified portfolio with a mix of bond and equity funds so that you can weather whatever challenges the economy is facing without seeing your holdings take a huge hit.
1. Federal Bond Funds
Several types of bond funds are particularly popular with risk-averse investors. Funds made up of U.S. Treasury bonds lead the pack, as they are considered to be one of the safest. Investors face no credit risk because the government's ability to levy taxes and print money eliminates the risk of default and provides principal protection.
Bond funds investing in mortgages securitized by the Government National Mortgage Association (Ginnie Mae) are also backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. Most of the mortgages (typically, mortgages for first-time homebuyers and low-income borrowers) securitized as Ginnie Mae mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are those guaranteed by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA), Veterans Affairs or other federal housing agencies.
Options to consider include federal bond funds, municipal bond funds, taxable corporate funds, money market funds, dividend funds, utilities mutual funds, large-cap funds, and hedge funds.
2. Municipal Bond Funds
Next, on the list are municipal bond funds. Issued by state and local governments, these investments leverage local taxing authority to provide a high degree of safety and security to investors. They carry a greater risk than funds that invest in securities backed by the federal government but are still considered to be relatively safe.
3. Taxable Corporate Funds
Taxable bond funds issued by corporations are also a consideration. They offer higher yields than government-backed issues but carry significantly more risk. Choosing a fund that invests in high-quality bond issues will help lower your risk. While corporate bond funds are riskier than funds that only hold government-issued bonds, they are still less risky than stock funds.
(For related reading, see: Corporate Bonds: An Introduction To Credit Risk.
4. Money Market Funds
When it comes to avoiding recessions, bonds are certainly popular, but they aren't the only game in town. Ultra-conservative investors and unsophisticated investors often stash their cash in money market funds. While these funds provide a high degree of safety, they should only be used for short-term investment.
(To learn more, read: Introduction To Money Market Mutual Funds.)
There's no need to avoid equity funds when the economy is slowing, instead, consider funds and stocks that pay dividends, or that invest in steadier, consumer staples stocks; in terms of asset classes, funds focused on large-cap stocks tend to be less risky than those focused on small-cap stocks, in general.
5. Dividend Funds
Contrary to popular belief, seeking shelter during tough times doesn't necessarily mean abandoning the stock market altogether. While investors stereotypically think of the stock market as a vehicle for growth, share price appreciation isn't the only game in town when it comes to making money in the stock market. For example, mutual funds focused on dividends can provide strong returns with less volatility than funds that focus strictly on growth.
(To learn more, see: Dividends Still Look Good After All These Years.)
6. Utilities Mutual Funds
Utilities-based mutual funds and funds investing in consumer staples are less aggressive stock fund strategies that tend to focus on investing in companies paying predictable dividends.
7. Large-Cap Funds
Traditionally, funds investing in large-cap stocks tend to be less vulnerable than those in small-cap stocks, as larger companies are generally better positioned to endure tough times. Shifting assets from funds investing in smaller, more aggressive companies to those that bet on blue chips provide a way to cushion your portfolio against market declines without fleeing the stock market altogether.
8. Hedge and Other Funds
For wealthier individuals, investing a portion of your portfolio in hedge funds is one idea. Hedge funds are designed to make money regardless of market conditions. Investing in a foul weather fund is another idea, as these funds are specifically designed to make money when the markets are in decline.
In both cases, these funds should only represent a small percentage of your total holdings. In the case of hedge funds, hedging is the practice of attempting to reduce risk, but the actual goal of most hedge funds today is to maximize return on investment. The name is mostly historical, as the first hedge funds tried to hedge against the downside risk of a bear market by shorting the market (mutual funds generally can't enter into short positions as one of their primary goals). Hedge funds typically use dozens of different strategies, so it isn't accurate to say that hedge funds just hedge risk. In fact, because hedge fund managers make speculative investments, these funds can carry more risk than the overall market. In the case of foul weather funds, your portfolio may not fare well when times are good.
The Bottom Line
Regardless of where you put your money, if you have a long-term timeframe, look at a down market as an opportunity to buy. Instead of selling when the price is low, look at it as an opportunity to build your portfolio at a discount. When retirement becomes a near-term possibility, make a permanent move in a conservative direction. Do it because you have enough money to meet your needs and want to remove some of the risks from your portfolio for good, not because you plan to jump back in when you think the markets will rise again.