Critical Illness Insurance: What Is It? Who Needs It?

If you’re lucky, you’ve probably never had to use critical illness insurance (sometimes called catastrophic illness insurance). Perhaps you’ve never even heard of it. But in the event of a big health emergency, such as cancer, a heart attack, or a stroke, critical illness insurance could be the only thing standing between you and financial ruin. Many people assume they’re fully protected with a standard health insurance plan, but the exorbitant costs of treating life-threatening illnesses are usually more than any plan will cover. Read on to learn more about critical illness insurance and whether it's something you and your family should consider.

Key Takeaways

  • Critical illness insurance provides additional coverage for medical emergencies like heart attacks, strokes, or cancer.
  • Because these emergencies or illnesses often incur greater-than-average medical costs, these policies pay out cash to help cover those overruns where traditional health insurance may fall short.
  • These policies come at a relatively low cost. However, the instances that they will cover are generally limited to a few illnesses or emergencies.

Critical Illness Insurance 101

As the average life expectancy in the United States continues to increase, insurance brokers are finding ways to make sure Americans can afford the privilege of getting older. Critical illness insurance was developed in 1996, as people realized that surviving a heart attack or stroke could leave a patient with insurmountable medical bills.

“Even with excellent medical insurance, just one critical illness can be a tremendous financial burden,” says CFP Jeff Rossi of Peak Wealth Advisors, LLC. Critical illness insurance provides coverage if you experience one or more of the following medical emergencies:

  • Heart attack
  • Stroke
  • Organ transplants
  • Cancer
  • Coronary bypass

Because these illnesses require extensive medical care and treatment, their costs can outstrip a family’s medical insurance policy quickly. If you don’t have an emergency fund or health savings account (HSA), you’ll have an even harder time paying those bills out of pocket. 

Many people are now choosing high-deductible health plans, which can be something of a double-edged sword: Consumers benefit from relatively affordable monthly premiums but could find themselves in a real pinch if a serious illness were to strike.

Critical illness insurance can pay for costs not covered by traditional insurance. The money can also be used for nonmedical costs related to the illness, including transportation, child care, etc. Typically, the insured will receive a lump sum to cover those costs. Coverage limits vary—you could be eligible for a few thousand dollars all the way up to $100,000, depending on your policy. Policy pricing is impacted by a number of factors, including the amount and extent of coverage, the sex, age, and health of the insured, and family medical history.

There are exceptions to critical illness insurance coverage. Some types of cancer may not be covered, while chronic illnesses are also frequently exempted. You may not be able to receive a payout if a disease comes back or if you suffer a second stroke or heart attack. Some coverage might end once the insured reaches a certain age. So, like any form of insurance, make sure to read the policy carefully. The last thing you want to worry about is your emergency plan

Why It May Be Important

You can purchase critical illness insurance on your own or through your employer (many offer it as a voluntary benefit). You can also add it to your current life insurance plan as a rider, which may be a more affordable option with the same benefit.

One of the reasons companies have been keen to add these plans is that they recognize employees are worried about high out-of-pocket expenses with a high-deductible plan. Unlike other healthcare benefits, workers generally bear the entire cost of critical illness plans. That makes it a money saver for companies, as well as workers.

A big draw of critical illness insurance is that the money can be used for a variety of things, such as:

  • To pay for critical medical services that might otherwise be unavailable
  • To pay for treatments not covered by a traditional policy
  • To pay for daily living expenses, enabling the critically ill to focus their time and energy on getting well instead of working to pay their bills
  • Transportation expenses, such as getting to and from treatment centers, retrofitting vehicles to carry scooters or wheelchairs, and installing lifts in homes for critically ill patients who can no longer navigate staircases
  • Terminally ill patients, or those simply in need of a restful place to recuperate, can use the funds to take a vacation with friends or family

Low Cost, Limited Coverage

Part of what makes these policies appealing is that they generally don’t cost much, especially when you get them through an employer. Some smaller plans run as little as $25 a month, which looks like a bargain compared to the cost of a typical, low-deductible health insurance policy. 

Despite these plans’ low price tag, some healthcare experts are skeptical as to whether they really are a good deal for consumers. One overarching concern is that they’ll only reimburse you for a somewhat narrow range of illnesses. If the illness you’re diagnosed with doesn’t fit the definition of a covered illness, you’re out of luck.

The more illnesses that are covered on your plan, the more you’ll pay in premiums. A 45-year-old female with an individual, cancer-only plan may pay $40 a month for $25,000 of coverage. That same woman may pay twice that a month if she expanded the coverage to include coronary illnesses, organ transplants, and certain other conditions.

Like all insurance policies, critical illness policies are also subject to a host of stipulations. Not only do they only cover the conditions listed in the policy, but they cover them only under the specific circumstances noted in the policy. A diagnosis of cancer, for example, may not be enough to trigger payment of the policy if the cancer has not spread beyond the initial point of discovery or is not life-threatening. A diagnosis of a stroke may not trigger a payment unless the neurological damage persists for more than 30 days. Other restrictions may include a specific number of days for which the policyholder must be ill or must survive after diagnosis.

Seniors should be particularly careful about these policies. There may be limits for payout on some policies, with persons over a certain age (such as 75) ineligible for payment, or they may include so-called “age reduction schedules,” which means your potential insurance payout shrinks as you get older.

It is important to note that many of these policies do not provide a guaranteed payment. For example, a typical insurance company discloses that in its critical illness policy "the expected benefit ratio for this policy is 60%. This ratio is the portion of future premiums that the company expects to return as benefits when averaged over all people with this policy." If 60% of the premiums are eventually paid out in claims, 40% of the premiums are never paid out at all.

Alternatives to Critical Illness Insurance

Insiders point out that there are alternative forms of coverage without all these restrictions. Disability insurance, for example, provides income when you can’t work for medical reasons, and financial protection isn’t limited to a narrow set of illnesses. This is an especially good option for anyone whose livelihood would take a significant hit from a prolonged work absence.

Consumers with a high-deductible plan can also make contributions to either a health savings account or flexible spending account (FSA), both of which offer tax benefits when used for qualified expenses.

You can also build a separate savings account to cover nonmedical outlays that could arise if you have cancer, for example, and have taken leave from your job.

The Bottom Line

Because medical bills are a common cause of bankruptcy in the United States, you should give protecting yourself against that fate consideration, especially if you have a family history of any of the aforementioned illnesses. Critical illness insurance can alleviate financial worry in the event that you become too sick to work. It provides flexibility in that you can use the money paid out as you wish to cover a wide variety of potential needs. There are some drawbacks and stipulations to this type of insurance coverage, though. As with all types of insurance, you should shop around to find the policy that best meets your needs and situation.

Article Sources

Investopedia requires writers to use primary sources to support their work. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. We also reference original research from other reputable publishers where appropriate. You can learn more about the standards we follow in producing accurate, unbiased content in our editorial policy.
  1. Healthcare Solutions Team. "Guide to Critical Illness Insurance Policies: Are They Right For You?" Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  2. Western & Southern Financial Group. "Critical Illness Insurance," Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  3. United Health Care. "Critical Illness Insurance." Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  4. Policy Genius. "Do I Need Critical Illness Insurance?" Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  5. Health Insurance.org. "What is a Critical Illness Plan?" Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  6. Insurance Information Institute. "What Are the Types of Disability Insurance?" Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  7. Healthcare.gov. "Using a Flexible Spending Account (FSA)." Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.

  8. American Journal of Public Health. "Medical Bankruptcy: Still Common Despite the Affordable Care Act." Accessed Sept. 10, 2021.