It has become ingrained in us to max out our 401(k) plan or similar workplace defined contribution plan as the best way to save for retirement. This is certainly good advice. However, in recent years, another retirement savings vehicle has come about that might be superior to the 401(k): a health savings account (HSA).
Health savings accounts (HSAs) are tax-advantaged savings accounts designed to help people with high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) pay for out-of-pocket medical expenses. While these accounts have been available since 2004, too few Americans are taking advantage of them. According to a July 2015 report from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI), about 17 million people had HSA-eligible health insurance plans in 2014, but only 13.8 million of that number had opened an HSA. A February 2017 survey by America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) of its member insurers reported 20.2 million HSA enrollees in 59 HDHP plans in 2016, up from 19.7 million the previous year. These types of health plans are offered by about 43% of employers right now.
Moreover, in a later report the EBRI noted people with HSAs had an average balance of just $2,922 in 2016 – a pittance, considering that the allowable annual contribution in 2016 was $3,350 for those with individual health plans and $6,750 for those with family coverage. In addition, only 6% of HSAs were in investment accounts. EBRI found that virtually no one contributes the maximum, and nearly everyone takes current distributions to pay for medical expenses.
All of this means that consumers who have HSAs, as well as consumers who are eligible for HSAs but haven’t opened one, are missing out on an incredible option for funding their later years. It’s time to start a new trend.
Why Use an HSA for Retirement?
An HSA's triple tax advantage, which is similar to that of a traditional 401(k) plan or IRA, makes it a top-notch way to save for retirement. According to a recent story in The Wall Street Journal, HSAs are "the most tax-preferred account available,” says Michael Kitces, director of financial planning at Pinnacle Advisory Group Inc. in Columbia, Md. “Using one to save for retirement medical expenses is a better strategy than using retirement accounts."
What makes an HSA so good? Consider:
- Your contributions to an HSA can be made via payroll deductions, as well as from your own funds. If the latter, they are tax-deductible, even if you don't itemize. If they're made via the former, it puts them on a pre-tax basis, meaning that they reduce your federal and state income tax liability – and they're not subject to FICA taxes, either. In addition, any contributions your employer makes do not have to be counted as part of your taxable income.
- Your account balance grows tax-free. Any interest, dividends or capital gains you earn are nontaxable.
- Withdrawals for qualified medical expenses are tax-free. This is a key way in which an HSA is superior to a traditional 401(k) or IRA as a retirement vehicle: Once you begin to withdraw funds from those plans, you pay income tax on that money, regardless of how the funds are being used. Also better: Unlike a 401(k) or IRA, an HSA does not require the account-holder to begin withdrawing funds at a certain age. They can remain untouched as long as you like, although you may no longer contribute once you reach 65 and are eligible for Medicare.
What's more, the balance can be carried over from year to year; you are not legally obligated to "use it or lose it," as with a flexible spending account (FSA). It can move with you to a new job, too. You own the account, not your employer, which means the account is fully portable and goes when and where you do.
Who Can Open an HSA?
To qualify for an HSA, you must have a high-deductible health plan and no other health insurance. You are not yet eligible for Medicare, and you can't be claimed as a dependent on someone else's tax return.
A major concern consumers have about foregoing a preferred provider organization (PPO) or health maintenance organization (HMO) plan and choosing a high-deductible health plan instead is that they will not be able to afford their medical expenses. In 2018, an HDHP has a deductible of at least $1,350 for self-only coverage and $2,700 for family coverage. Depending on your coverage, in 2018 your annual out-of-pocket expenses could run as high as $6,650 for individual coverage – or $13,300 for family coverage – under an HDHP. This can be one reason these plans are surprisingly popular among affluent families who will benefit from the tax advantages and can afford the risk.
However, according to Fidelity, a lower-deductible plan such as a PPO could be costing you more than $2,000 a year in higher premiums because you’re paying the extra money regardless of the size of your medical expenses that year. With an HDHP, your spending more closely matches your actual healthcare needs. (Of course, if you are in a situation in which you know your healthcare costs are likely to be high – a woman who is pregnant, for instance, or someone with a chronic medical condition – a high deductible may not be the best choice for you.) Also, HDHPs completely cover some preventive care services.
So an HDHP might be more budget-friendly than you think – especially when you consider its advantages for retirement. Let’s take a look at how you could be using the features of an HSA to more easily and more robustly fund your retirement.
Max out Contributions Before Age 65
As mentioned above, your HSA contributions are tax-deductible before you turn 65 and become eligible for Medicare. The contribution limits of $3,450 (self-only coverage) and $6,900 (family coverage) include employer contributions. The contributions limits are adjusted annually for inflation.
If you have an HSA and you're 55 or older, you can make an extra "catch-up" contribution of $1,000 per year and a spouse who is 55 or older can do the same, provided each of you has his or her own HSA account. Your family's total annual contribution cannot exceed $8,750.
You can contribute up to the maximum regardless of your income, and your entire contribution is tax-deductible. You can even contribute in years when you have no income. You can also contribute if you’re self-employed.
“Maxing out contributions before age 65 allows you to save for general retirement expenses beyond medical expenses," says Mark Hebner, founder and president, Index Fund Advisors, Inc., in Irvine, Calif. and author of “Index Funds: The 12-Step Recovery Program for Active Investors."
"Although you will not receive the tax exemption," Hebner adds, "it gives retirees more access to more resources to fund general living expenses."
Don’t Spend Your Contributions
This may sound counterintuitive, but we're looking at an HSA primarily as an investment tool. Granted, the basic idea behind an HSA is to give people with a high-deductible health plan a tax break to make their out-of-pocket medical expenses more manageable.
But that triple tax advantage means that the best way to use an HSA is to treat it as an investment tool that will improve your financial picture in retirement. And the best way to do that is to never spend your HSA contributions during your working years and pay cash out of pocket for your medical bills. In other words, think of your HSA contributions the same way you think of your contributions to any other retirement account: untouchable until you retire. Remember, the IRS does not require you to take distributions from your HSA in any year, before or during retirement.
If you absolutely must spend some of your contributions before retirement, be sure to spend them on qualified medical expenses. These distributions are not taxable. If you are forced to spend the money on anything else before you’re 65, you will pay a 20% penalty and you will also pay income tax on those funds.
Invest Your Contributions Wisely
The key to maximizing your unspent contributions, of course, is to invest them wisely. Your investment strategy should be similar to the one you’re using for your other retirement assets, such as a 401(k) plan or an IRA. When deciding how to invest your HSA assets, make sure to consider your portfolio as a whole so that your overall diversification strategy and risk profile are where you want them to be.
Your employer might make it easy for you to open an HSA with a particular administrator, but the choice of where to put your money is yours. An HSA is not as restrictive as a 401(k); it’s more like an IRA. Since some administrators only let you put your money in a savings account, where you’ll barely earn any interest, make sure to shop around for a plan with high-quality, low-cost investment options, such as Vanguard or Fidelity funds.
How Much Could You End Up With?
Let's do some simple math to see how handsomely this HSA savings and investment strategy can pay off. We’ll use something close to a best-case scenario and say you’re currently 21, you make the maximum allowable contribution every year to a self-only plan, and you contribute every year until you’re 65. We’ll assume that you invest all your contributions and automatically reinvest all your returns in the stock market, earning an average annual return of 8%, and that your plan has no fees. By retirement, your HSA would have more than $1.2 million.
What about a more conservative estimate? Suppose you’re now 40 years old and you only put in $100 per month until you’re 65, earning an average annual return of 3%. You’d still end up with nearly $45,000 by retirement. Try out an online HSA calculator to play with the numbers for your own situation.
Maximize Your HSA Assets in Retirement
Here are some options for using your accumulated HSA contributions and investment returns in retirement. Remember, distributions for qualified medical expenses are not taxable, so you want to use the money exclusively for those expenses if possible. There are no required minimum distributions, so you can keep the money invested until you need it.
If you do need to use the distributions for another purpose, they will be taxable. However, after age 65, you won’t owe the 20% penalty. Using HSA assets for purposes other than qualified medical expenses is generally less detrimental to your finances once you’ve reached retirement age because you may be in a lower tax bracket if you’ve stopped working, reduced your hours or changed jobs. In this way, an HSA is effectively the same as a 401(k) or any other retirement account, with one key difference: There is no requirement to begin withdrawing the money at age 70½. So you don’t have to worry about saving too much in your HSA and not being able to use it all effectively.
Withdrawals: It's All in the Timing
By waiting as long as possible to spend your HSA assets, you maximize your potential investment returns and give yourself as much money as possible to work with. You’ll also want to consider market fluctuations when taking distributions, the same way you would when taking distributions from any investment account. You obviously want to avoid selling investments at a loss to pay for medical expenses.
Choose a Beneficiary
When you open your HSA, you will be asked to designate a beneficiary to whom any funds still in the account should go upon your death. The best person to choose is your spouse because he or she can inherit the balance tax-free. (As with any investment with a beneficiary, however, you should revisit your designations from time to time because death, divorce or other life changes may alter your choices.) Anyone else you leave your HSA to will be subject to tax on the plan’s fair market value when they inherit it. Your plan administrator will have a designation-of-beneficiary form you can fill out to formalize your choice.
Pay Health Expenses in Retirement
Fidelity Investments’ most recent Retirement Health Care Cost survey calculates that the cost of healthcare throughout retirement for a couple where the spouses are both 65 years old is $275,000. That's up $15,000 over 2016. Funds captured in an HSA can help out with such skyrocketing costs.
Qualified payments for which tax-free HSA withdrawals can be made include:
- Office-visit co-payments
- Health insurance deductibles
- Dental expenses
- Vision care (eye exams and eyeglasses)
- Prescription drugs and insulin
- Medicare premiums
- A portion of the premiums for a tax-qualified long-term care insurance policy
- Hearing aids
- Hospital and physical therapy bills
- Wheelchairs and walkers
You can also use your HSA balance to pay for in-home nursing care, retirement community fees for lifetime care, long-term care services, nursing home fees, and meals and lodging that are necessary while obtaining medical care away from home. You can even use your HSA for modifications that make your home easier to use as you age, such as ramps, grab bars and handrails. One strategy might be to bunch qualified medical costs into a single year and tap the HSA for tax-free funds to pay them, compared with withdrawing from other retirement accounts that would trigger taxable income.
“Using HSA money to pay for medical expenses and long-term care insurance in retirement is a great benefit for investors given the tax exemption on any withdrawals made to fund either," says Hebner. "In other words, it’s the most cost-effective way to fund those expenses because they provide investors the highest after-tax value." Also, note that there are limitations on how much you can pay tax-free for long-term care insurance based on your age.
Reimburse Yourself for Earlier Expenses
An HSA doesn’t require you to take a distribution to reimburse yourself in the same year your incur a particular medical expense.The key limitation is that you can’t use an HSA balance to reimburse yourself for medical expenses you incurred before you established the account. So keep your receipts for all healthcare expenses you pay out of pocket after you establish your HSA. If, in your later years, you find yourself with more money in your HSA than you know what to do with, you can use your HSA balance to reimburse yourself for those earlier expenses.
The strategies described in this article are based on federal tax law. Most states follow federal tax law when it comes to HSAs, but yours may not. At the time of writing, Alabama, California and New Jersey tax HSA contributions, and New Hampshire and Tennessee tax HSA earnings. Even if you live in a state that taxes HSAs, however, you’ll still get the federal tax benefits.
In some states, bills have been presented, but not passed, to change tax law to match the federal treatment of HSAs. The taxation of these plans could change in the future at either the state or federal levels. The plans could even be eliminated altogether, but if that happens, we would likely see them grandfathered for existing account holders, as was the case with Archer MSAs.
The Bottom Line
A health savings account, available to consumers who choose a high-deductible health plan, has been largely overlooked as an investment tool, but with its triple tax advantage, it provides an excellent way to save, invest and take distributions without paying taxes. The next time you’re choosing a health insurance plan, take a closer look at whether a high deductible health plan might work for you. If so, open an HSA and start contributing as soon as you’re eligible. Through maximizing your contributions, investing them and leaving the balance untouched until retirement, you’ll generate a significant addition to your other retirement options.
Of course, you can't let the savings tail wag the medical dog. Hoarding your HSA monies rather than attending to your health is not recommended. However, if you’re financially able to use post-tax dollars for your current healthcare costs while saving your pre-tax HSA dollars for later, you’ll probably be glad you did.