4 Best Alternatives to Long-Term Care Insurance

These options may be a better fit to pay for long-term care

Long-term care insurance is a specific type of health coverage that reimburses for services not included in traditional medical plans or Medicare. It can be used by people with a variety of issues from different age groups, but it may not be the best option for all.

The potential need for long-term care should not be overlooked. A majority of people will require it when they get older. Approximately 70% of people who turn 65 today will require long-term care at some point, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

Long-term care insurance is expensive and not everyone is eligible, but these four alternatives can provide good coverage for those in need of long-term care.

Key Takeaways

  • To avoid being rejected for long-term care insurance or paying higher premiums, individuals can look to alternatives.
  • Short-term care insurance is one option, which is essentially long-term care insurance offered for up to a year. 
  • Critical care or critical illness insurance offers coverage for those who are diagnosed with serious illnesses, such as cancer. 
  • Annuities with long-term care riders or deferred annuities can be an alternative to long-term care insurance, potentially providing tax-free money when used for long-term care.

Long-Term Care Insurance: Affordability and Eligibility

Long-term care insurance can be expensive. It’s generally more cost-effective when purchased before a person turns 60. As of 2020, the average annual premium for a healthy couple, both age 55, was $3,050, according to the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance.

Even at these high premiums, insurance companies that offer this type of insurance can reject applicants after probing into their health histories.

Due to these factors, people may need other options for long-term care coverage.

1. Short-Term Care Insurance

Short-term care insurance, also known as convalescent insurance, typically offers $100 to $200 per day of healthcare coverage for one year or less.

Since there is no long-term commitment for the insurance companies, the premiums are normally lower than traditional long-term care coverage options. The average short-term care premium for a 65-year-old, for example, is $105 a month.

Since the premiums are lower and the coverage is for a year or less, many applicants who are rejected for long-term-care coverage may be accepted by short-term care insurance. These types of policies have short or no elimination periods, allowing benefits to start immediately for those in need.

With short-term care insurance, the benefits normally reset. This means that if someone files a claim but then recovers prior to receiving the full benefit, another claim can be filed in the future.

While this type of insurance coverage can help those who are rejected for long-term care insurance, the brevity of the insurance coverage could make it a partial solution. Medicare covers post-hospitalization rehab for up to 20 days, making it possible to stretch coverage that much farther than one year.

Short-term coverage is not usually available to people older than 85 to 89.

2. Critical Care or Critical Illness Insurance

Critical care and critical illness insurance are two types of coverage that extend lump-sum cash payments to people who are diagnosed with cancer, stroke, heart attack, and other serious illnesses.

In addition, two major carriers, Aflac and Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Co., offer critical care and critical illness insurance with daily or monthly benefits for inpatient rehab and continuing care.Aflac's daily benefits can last up to six months and Guarantee Trust's monthly benefits can last up to two years.

Daily and monthly benefits aside, critical care and critical illness insurance are normally less expensive than long-term care insurance. For example, if a 60-year-old woman is looking for critical care or illness insurance, she can receive a $50,000 lump sum payment from a plan for as little as $100 a month.

Even a monthly benefit insurance structure purchased through Guarantee Trust can get someone in need of long-term care up to $2,000 a month for two years and only cost around $110 a month.

People seeking long-term care coverage through critical care or critical illness insurance are not eligible if the issue is from a past diagnosis. Coverage is only valid if the injury or illness is recent and previously undiagnosed.

3. Annuities With Long-Term Care Riders

For people who are rejected by traditional long-term care insurance providers, it is possible to take out an annuity with a long-term care rider. Money invested in an annuity with a long-term care rider can be used tax-free to pay for long-term care as defined under the contract.

This gives a person a stream of monthly payments they can use specifically to pay for the care needed.

Medical underwriting for this type of option is less stringent than traditional long-term care, resulting in greater freedom in how people can use the care benefits. If it turns out long-term care is not needed, it is possible to redeem the accumulated value of the annuity. Upon the passing of the annuity owner, the heirs collect on the funds, minus any withdrawals for long-term care.

However, annuities need to be purchased upfront, requiring a large payment in return for monthly cash flow for a defined period. Annuities like these have minimum up-front premiums of $50,000, and the money is normally locked in for five to 10 years.

Those who are in need of long-term care are usually unable to perform the basic activities of daily living without assistance, including eating, bathing, walking, and dressing.

4. Deferred Annuities

Long-term care can be preplanned through the use of a deferred fixed annuity. If people take into account that they have a 70% chance of needing long-term care after age 65, it is smart to hedge against future costs by putting money down prior to retirement in return for a promise an insurer will pay monthly sums starting when a specific age is reached.

Say, for example, a person is 60 years old and decides to purchase a deferred annuity for $100,000. When that person reaches a designated age (72 if the annuity is in a tax-qualified retirement account), the distributions begin.

The amount of the payment will depend on the type of distribution. Required minimum distributions require calculations from an Internal Revenue Service schedule. Other distributions will typically depend on the contract terms of the annuity.

A deferred annuity differs from an annuity with a long-term care rider because it is not designed exclusively for long-term care. It can bring peace of mind to know that there will be monthly cash flow to pay for it if long-term care is needed.

A deferred annuity does not cover any long-term care needed prior to retirement.

Do I Really Need Long-Term Care Insurance?

You don't necessarily need long-term care insurance but you need some way to pay for the services you will require if you suffer an injury or illness, age-related or not, that affects your mobility and your ability to function for some period of time, whether short or long.

A standard health insurance policy will cover most of the cost of treatment of a disease or injury. Medicare may cover up to 20 days of post-op services.

What happens then? You might consider some of the options outlined above: Short-term care insurance; critical care insurance; an annuity with a long-term care rider, or a deferred annuity.

What Is Long-Term Care?

Long-term care is professional assistance with everyday activities that is provided to a person with a serious, ongoing disability or illness. Ideally, it is provided in the person's own home. Long-term care may be necessary suddenly, as the result of an injury or illness, or it can develop gradually as a person grows fragile with age.

I'm a Veteran. Am I Eligible for Long-Term Care?

If you are a veteran of the U.S. Armed Forces, you may be eligible for some Veterans Administration Services including nursing home care, assisted living services, and home health care.

You must be signed up for VA health benefits to be eligible.

The Bottom Line

A majority of people over age 65 will need long-term care at some point. Because long-term care insurance isn't for everyone, it's prudent to explore other options. Consider the above alternatives when planning ahead to pay the high costs of long-term care, should you need it down the road.

Article Sources
Investopedia requires writers to use primary sources to support their work. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. We also reference original research from other reputable publishers where appropriate. You can learn more about the standards we follow in producing accurate, unbiased content in our editorial policy.
  1. LongTermCare.gov. “How Much Care Will You Need.”

  2. American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. “2020 Long-Term Care Insurance Price Index Released for Age 55.”

  3. American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. ”Long-Term Care Insurance Health Qualifications. Are You Even Insurable?


  4. American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. "What Is Short-Term Care Insurance.”

  5. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. "What Part A Covers."

  6. American Association for Critical Illness Insurance. “What Is Cancer or Critical Illness insurance.”

  7. Golden Care. "Critical Care," Page 6.

  8. Aflac. "Critical Care Protection," Page 3.

  9. Golden Care. "Critical Care," Pages 2 and 4.

  10. Guaranty Income Life Insurance Company. “AnnuiCare.”

  11. LongTermCare.gov. “Annuities.”

  12. Internal Revenue Service. "Retirement Plan and IRA Required Minimum Distributions FAQs."

  13. National Institute on Aging. "What Is Long-Term Care?"

  14. Veterans Administration. "VA nursing homes, assisted living, and home health care."