People often leave assets to minors, but is making a minor an IRA beneficiary a good idea? After all, there are many ways to give assets to those for whom you wish to leave a legacy. You can leave tangible assets, such as cars, houses, or other belongings, or liquid assets, such as cash or securities. However, the age of the person to whom you leave these assets will often determine the form of, and the conditions under which they receive, the property. Here are some of the advantages and potential pitfalls of leaving an IRA to a minor.
- IRAs provide better opportunities for long-term growth than other assets you could leave a minor.
- As required minimum distributions (RMDs) are based on life expectancy, a minor’s RMDs will be lower than those of most other IRA holders, who are usually adults when they open one.
- IRAs do not have to be used for a specific purpose to avoid taxation, providing the beneficiary with greater flexibility.
Why Choose a Minor as an IRA Beneficiary?
There are several reasons why a donor might choose to bestow an IRA upon a beneficiary who has not yet attained the age of majority. One of the most obvious is that IRAs can provide much greater flexibility and potential for long-term growth than, for example, savings bonds. Also, IRAs do not have to be used for higher education or any other specific purpose in order to escape taxation.
More important, young beneficiaries get the benefit of a lower required minimum distribution (RMD) over their lives. This is because the life expectancy of the beneficiary is used when calculating their RMDs.
For example, if you died and left $100,000 of IRA money to a one-year-old granddaughter this year, her current life expectancy would be 81.6 years. Assuming that the money in the account grows at 8% to 10% per year, she could withdraw several million dollars from the account over her life. Of course, if the money were inside a Roth IRA, she would probably save at least a million dollars in taxes as well.
Leaving an IRA to a minor requires the appointment of a guardian to manage it until the child reaches adulthood.
Problems With Minor Ownership
Common law dictates that certain legal measures must be taken to protect minors in these circumstances. Minors cannot own legal property of any kind in their name; a guardian must be appointed to manage the property on their behalf until they reach the age of majority. Appointing a guardian is your responsibility. If you do not do this, then the court will appoint one for you—one who may have very different ideas about how the account should be managed and invested.
There is no escaping this appointment, as the law prohibits IRA custodians from dealing directly with minors in any capacity. A will alone will not rectify this problem for you, because wills only deal with probatable assets, and IRAs are exempt from probate.
One of the minor’s parents or another relative can petition the court for guardianship if you make no appointment, but this can be costly, time-consuming, and in the end totally unnecessary. It can also become a protracted legal battle if the minor’s parents have divorced and both seek custody of the account.
Options for the IRA
There are a few alternatives that you can have your guardian implement once your beneficiary receives the IRA. One is to put the distributions inside a custodial account, such as an UGMA or UTMA. However, this could have adverse tax consequences for the minor’s parents (or whoever claims the minor as a dependent on a tax return): If the minor’s income is above a certain level, then the parent or guardian must pay tax on the excess at their top marginal tax rate. This also gives the minor sole custody of the property at the age of majority, an age at which he or she may not be ready to handle a large sum of money.
Another possible solution is to put the money into a 529 plan, which allows the assets to grow tax free until they are used to pay for qualified higher education expenses. However, if the minor decides not to pursue a college education, then this plan can also backfire.
A more comprehensive (albeit expensive) solution may be to substitute a revocable living trust as the beneficiary for the IRA, with the minor as the beneficiary for the trust. The guardian would then be appointed as the trustee. The trust will allow you to provide specific instructions as to how you want the guardian to handle the IRA distributions for the minor.
There are several types of trusts that you can use to this end. A “conduit” trust would siphon the distributions directly from the IRA to the minor so that the trust is not taxed (a situation you want to avoid whenever possible, as trust tax rates are currently among the highest in existence). If the minor has special needs, an accumulation trust may be appropriate. Although this arrangement does keep the money inside the trust to be taxed at higher trust rates, it also ensures that the money will be used for the minor’s benefit, conceivably even after he or she reaches adulthood.
The Bottom Line
There are several alternatives to choose from if you wish to leave your IRA to a minor beneficiary. Check with your IRA custodian to see what its requirements are regarding this matter. If your wishes cannot be fulfilled through mere beneficiary designations or guardian appointments, then consider using a trust to ensure that the minor receives the IRA distributions in the manner you specify.