Accounting practices in the United States have matured over the years, but there are still plenty of ways that companies can disguise their financial results. You can spot these practices in instances when financial statements are depicting overly positive earnings in combination with negative cash flow or in underregulated micro-cap stocks or restatements in larger companies.
In this article, we'll explore why companies utilize creative accounting and how it can be detected by looking at a company's financial statements and disclosures. Investors armed with this information should be able to steer clear of potential problems and—on the other side—find opportunities for investment in misunderstood companies. (See also: Find Investment Quality in the Income Statement.)
Premature or Fictitious Revenue
One of the most common techniques used by public companies looking to artificially boost their income is to prematurely recognize revenue or simply fabricate sales altogether. Exactly when revenue should be recognized varies greatly, but in the end, the point where payment and the delivery of goods are guaranteed is the defining criteria of when revenue should be realized.
- Look at the Revenue Recognition: The easiest way to detect premature revenue is to look at a company's revenue recognition policies found in their 10-Q or 10-K financial statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Investors should carefully read these footnotes and look for the ways in which companies recognize their revenue and note any recent changes in the policies. If revenue has increased from a previous period, compare the recognition policies to ensure that the increase is actually due to enhanced business operations.
- Monitor Accounts Receivable: Since revenue that is prematurely recognized, and in some instances artificially created, are subject to collection uncertainty, accounts receivable will typically increase on the company's balance sheet, while its uncollectible charge will gradually increase as well. Investors that see a liberal revenue recognition policy may want to check for unusual increases in accounts receivable to see if there's a problem.
- Check the Capacity: In many cases, companies that fabricate revenue will not have the manufacturing capacity to justify the sales that they record. As a result, investors can check the manufacturing capacity in order to identify possible fraud. The process of checking this will vary by industry and may include looking at revenue per employee, revenue per property or a consideration of total assets. These figures should be compared with other similar firms in the competing industry. (See also: Footnotes: Start Reading the Fine Print.)
Common Types of Revenue Manipulation
- Side Letters: Letters outside of normal corporate reporting channels between the company and its customers that may include misleading conditions such as liberal rights of return, rights to cancel orders at any time, contingencies that could nullify the sale, or even total absolution of payment in some cases.
- Related Party Transactions: Sometimes sales transactions will occur as a result of an existing arrangement with a customer that may not have the same recurring self-financed prospects of an unrelated party transaction.
- Percentage-of-Completion Contracts: Contracts may be accounted for either by using the percentage-of-completion or the completed-contract method. The former can be easily abused by companies by aggressively estimating their progress.
- Channel Stuffing: Channel stuffing occurs when a company ships products to distributors who are encouraged to buy under a short-term offer of deep discounts. Effectively, these are not a proper indicator of future sales and can be considered unsustainable.
Pro-Forma Earnings, Classification and Disclosure
Many companies issue pro-forma income statements, in addition to GAAP-adjusted statements, as a way to provide a better understanding of changes in operating results. In legitimate cases, this means taking out one-time charges to smooth results. However, companies can also manipulate their financial results under the guise of pro-forma income statements. (See also: Understanding Pro-Forma Earnings.)
Pro-forma income statements are financial results that do not adhere to GAAP; these modified statements are legitimately used by companies to smooth earnings by removing one-time items, thus providing investors with a picture that reflects the usual business operations of the firm. For example, a one-time expense to fix a building as a result of weather damage can be rightfully viewed as an item that does not contribute to the representative valuation of the company.
Despite the positive reasoning behind these measures, there are many ways in which pro-forma earnings can be manipulated. For example, companies can selectively add back a variety of adjustments beyond interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, such as non-recurring, non-cash and non-operating items. As a result, it is important for investors to always remember to look at GAAP earnings for a clearer picture of true financial performance.
Aside from pro-forma income statements, companies can also mislead investors by creatively classifying their income in several ways, including:
- Operating income is not strictly defined under the GAAP because classification lines are often subject to discretion—items that are classified into this element can be selectively chosen by management. For example, non-recurring income such as special charges, shareholder class action settlements, and unusual events may be included or omitted within the metric to present a value that is pleasing to shareholders.
- Sales and gross profits can also be manipulated in many ways within the constraints of the GAAP. For example, companies can classify sales as either the gross amount billed to a customer or expected amount to be received. Furthermore, sales can also depend on whether or not shipping and handling is treated as a part of revenue. Finally, gross margins can be manipulated by moving certain expenses between SG&A and other costs of sales. In the end, these changes do not impact net income like fictitious sales figures, but they do create artificially higher or lower income statement metrics that can mislead shareholders. As a result, it is very important for investors to look closely at a company's GAAP results in addition to pro-forma results, in addition to closely looking at each line item.
The Bottom Line
There are many ways in which public companies can creatively manipulate their income statements, from modifying revenue themselves and creatively classifying income to utilizing misleading pro-forma income statements. While these practices are often legitimate, as long as they are not abused, investors should dig a little deeper for some real peace of mind. (See also: Uncovering a Career in Forensic Accounting.)