Government deficits crowd out private investment, although the mechanism through which that occurs can be more or less direct. The crowding out is in a relative, not absolute sense. Like any other economic good, investment capital is scarce. Any government bonds issued to pay for a deficit are purchased with investment funds that might have otherwise gone toward private investment.

If the government decides to raise taxes to finance a deficit, those additional taxes will further discourage private investment. Should the government decide to monetize the debt, the cost-of-living increases will also eat at savings and investment.

Crowding out also occurs in the market for loanable funds in general. Government bonds are a form of debt that has less counterparty risk than even the safest government bonds. When new government bonds are introduced, risk-averse investors are pulled away from other forms of safe income securities. This also raises the rate of interest that competing bonds have to offer. As with total private investments, these changes are relative rather than absolute.

Crowding Out, Interest Rates and Small Businesses

One of the more controversial alleged effects of government deficit spending relates to small business lending. Critics of expansionary fiscal policy argue that the real interest rate (not the market interest rate) is artificially inflated by large deficits. This, they assert, disproportionately affects small business lenders. The superabundance of cheap loans makes it easy for the government to borrow, but hard for individuals and small companies to survive marginal increases in the real rate.

Many academics and policy analysts contend that deficits disproportionately affect small businesses. Others argue that it's theoretically possible for the real interest rate to push away some lenders, but that loose monetary policy can help make up for any negative impact.

Interest rates do not necessarily need to rise to present this type of opportunity cost from fiscal deficits. The new real rate of interest need only be higher than it otherwise would have been without the government crowding out effect.

The Fallacy of Crowding In

Some proponents of fiscal deficits counter that, while crowding out is possible in financial markets, there is an opposite effect as well. This theory, known as "crowding in," argues that government spending will create such an increase in aggregate demand that the private sector has to ramp up production. This added production requires that additional capital be invested.

This argument is an extension of the traditional multiplier effect, whereby a dollar spent from government creates more than a dollar's worth of growth in gross domestic product (GDP). Those who disagree with this argument see several statistical flaws in it. They argue that the most obvious is that businesses cannot conjure investment capital just because aggregate demand is stronger. Instead, they believe it is more likely that the cost of capital will rise and that certain businesses will profit at the expense of others.

  1. What is the role of deficit spending in fiscal policy?

    Read about the role deficit spending can play in a government's fiscal policy, and learn why economists are torn about the ... Read Answer >>
  2. How does contractionary fiscal policy lead to the opposite of the crowding out effect?

    Find out how contractionary fiscal policy can theoretically lead to a crowding-in effect in the credit market by encouraging ... Read Answer >>
  3. Which countries run the largest budget deficits?

    Discover the countries with the largest budget deficits and what it means. Deficits are influenced by the economy and also ... Read Answer >>
  4. Is a current account deficit good or bad for the economy?

    Take a deeper look at the nature of a country's current account balance, and see why trade deficits are neither good nor ... Read Answer >>
  5. How Should You View a Balance of Payments Deficit?

    Discover how it might be possible to run a balance of payments deficit, what causes them in international trade and whether ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    Twin Deficits: Twice the Fun for the U.S

    Learn more about what it means for U.S. to run both fiscal and current account deficits.
  2. Trading

    How the Power of the Masses Drives the Market

    Market psychology is an undeniably powerful force. Find out what you can do about it.
  3. Insights

    Why Deficits Are Flawed Measures of Unfair Trade

    Trump’s obsession with erasing the $500B U.S. trade deficit is flawed economics, experts say.
  4. Insights

    The Current State of the U.S. Debt

    Discover the current state of U.S. national debt, whether it's increasing or decreasing, and what is projected for the next 10 years.
  5. Personal Finance

    6 Things You Didn't Know About The U.S. Budget Deficit

    The country appears to be spiralling into more debt all the time, but is it really as bad as it looks?
  6. Personal Finance

    Debt Versus Deficit: Understanding the Differences

    Gain an understanding how deficit differs from debt, and how they are related.
  7. Investing

    Why Money Flow From Japan Matters to the U.S. Equity Market

    Discover why Japanese savers and investors may have a lot to say about the future of the U.S. equity market, and why the trade deficit is responsible.
  8. Insights

    The Hidden Truth Behind The U.S. Economic Recovery

    Learn how the economy is being artificially propped up by unsustainable monetary and fiscal policies.
  9. Investing

    Explaining Government Bonds

    A government bond is a debt security a government issues.
  1. Crowded Short

    A crowded short is a trade on the short side with a large number ...
  2. Inactive Bond Crowd

    The inactive bond crowd is a group of exchange members who buys ...
  3. Active Bond

    An active bond is one that is repeatedly traded on the New York ...
  4. Deficit Hawk

    Slang for someone who wants the government to keep the federal ...
  5. Net Borrower

    A net borrower is an entity that borrows more than it saves or ...
  6. Public Sector Net Borrowing

    Public sector net borrowing is a British term referring the fiscal ...
Trading Center