At their core, interest rate swaps are a derivative instrument built on the premise of comparative advantage. To see how interest rate swaps benefit both parties, try to understand gains from trade in a macro-setting and then apply those lessons to micro-swap transactions.

There are other possible advantages – information asymmetries might exist in capital markets, or the two parties may simply have different risk profiles – but the most common benefits are derived from comparative advantages in different credit markets.

What Is Comparative Advantage?

Comparative advantage refers to the ability of an entity to produce a good or service at a lower opportunity cost than another entity. This idea is centered on relative efficiency, not absolute efficiency.

Consider the following example: During a single hour of labor, Tom can either plant five trees or 10 bushes. During the same hour of labor, Jerry can either plant two trees or eight bushes. Tom is absolutely more efficient than Jerry in planting either type of plant.

However, for every bush that Tom plants, he gives up one-half of a tree (his opportunity cost); Jerry only has to sacrifice one-quarter of a tree to plant a bush. Jerry is relatively more efficient at planting bushes than Tom. This is Jerry's comparative advantage.

Suppose Tom plants one tree for Jerry in exchange for Jerry planting three bushes for him. On his own, Tom would normally have to give up one and a half trees to plant three bushes. Meanwhile, Jerry would have to give up four bushes to plant one tree on his own. By specializing and trading, both parties benefit.

Comparative Advantage in Interest Rate Swaps

Now, for instance, take the most simple version of an interest rate swap. One party trades fixed-rate interest payments in exchange for floating-rate interest payments of another party. Each demonstrates a comparative advantage in a particular credit market.

For instance, a company with a higher credit rating pays less to raise funds under identical terms than a less creditworthy company. The borrowing premium paid by the lower-rated company is greater in relation to fixed-interest rate borrowing than it is for floating rate borrowings.

Even though the company with the higher credit rating could get lower terms in both fixed and floating rate markets, it only has a comparative advantage in one of them. Suppose Company AA can borrow in the fixed-rate markets at 10 percent or the six-month LIBOR at LIBOR + 0.35 percent. Company BBB can borrow fixed at 11.25 percent or the six-month LIBOR + one percent.

Both companies would like to borrow $10 million over 10 years. A mutually profitable swap can be negotiated as follows: Company AA borrows at a 10 percent fixed rate and BBB borrows at LIBOR + one percent. Company AA agrees to pay BBB interest at the flat six-month LIBOR  (not + one percent) and receives a fixed rate of 9.9 percent in exchange.

The net effect is that Company AA is actually borrowing at LIBOR + 0.1 percent, or 0.25 percent less than if it went directly to floating rate lenders. Company BBB is actually borrowing, on net, a fixed rate of 10.9 percent (the one percent on LIBOR and 9.9 percent to AA), which is 0.35 percent less than a direct fixed loan. In this example, the two companies have arbitraged their relative opportunity cost differences.

  1. When was the first swap agreement and why were swaps created?

    Learn about the history of swap agreements, the first swap agreement between IBM and the World Bank, and how swaps have evolved ... Read Answer >>
  2. What's a good fixed asset turnover ratio?

    The fixed asset turnover ratio measures how well a company generates sales using its fixed assets. It's best to compare a ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is property, plant, and equipment?

    Property, plant, and equipment are physical or tangible assets that are long-term assets that typically have a life of more ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Trading

    How To Value Interest Rate Swaps

    An interest rate swap is a contractual agreement between two parties agreeing to exchange cash flows of an underlying asset for a fixed period of time.
  2. Trading

    Different Types of Swaps

    Identify and explore the most common types of swap contracts. Swaps are derivative instruments that represent an agreement between two parties to exchange a series of cash flows over a specific ...
  3. Investing

    The Fast-Paced World of Libor & Fixed Income Arbitrage

    LIBOR is an essential part of implementing the swap spread arbitrage strategy for fixed income arbitrage. Here is a step-by-step explanation of how it works.
  4. Managing Wealth

    An In-Depth Look at the Swap Market

    The swap market plays an important role in the global financial marketplace; find out what you need to know about it.
  5. Trading

    An Introduction To Swaps

    Learn how these derivatives work and how companies can benefit from them.
  6. Insights

    What Is ICE LIBOR And What Is It Used For?

    In the case of ICE LIBOR, an innocent-sounding set of letters has a profound bearing on every loan you make.
  7. Trading

    Hedging with currency swaps

    The wrong currency movement can crush positive portfolio returns. Find out how to hedge against it with currency swaps.
  8. Investing

    PIMCO’s Mutual Fund for Investment Grade Bonds (PTTRX)

    Explore the complicated and often arcane makeup of the PIMCO Total Return Fund, and identify the fund's management style and top five holdings.
  9. Insights

    Why Americans Think Bush Is To Blame For The Economy

    The perception of who is to blame for the economy played a major role in Obama's reelection.
  10. Investing

    The Insiders Who Fix Rates for Gold, Currencies And Libor

    The system by which benchmark rates are fixed for interest rates, currencies and gold is archaic - and, many would argue, deeply flawed.
  1. Swap Rate

    The swap rate is the fixed portion of a swap as determined by ...
  2. Liability Swap

    A liability swap is a financial derivative in which two parties ...
  3. Swap Curve

    A swap curve identifies the relationship between swap rates at ...
  4. Equity Swap

    An equity swap is an exchange of cash flows between two parties ...
  5. Swap

    A swap is a derivative contract through which two parties exchange ...
  6. Floating Price

    The floating price is a leg of a swap contract that depends on ...
Trading Center