A:

Economists and statisticians use several different methods to track economic growth. The most well-known and frequently tracked metric is gross domestic product (GDP). Over time, however, some economists have highlighted limitations and biases in GDP calculation. Organizations such as the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) also keep relative productivity metrics to gauge economic potential. Some suggest measuring economic growth through increases in the standard of living, although this can be tricky to quantify.

Gross Domestic Product

Gross domestic product is the logical extension of measuring economic growth in terms of monetary expenditures. If a statistician wants to understand the productive output of the steel industry, for example, he needs only to track the dollar value of all of the steel that entered the market during a specific period.

Combine the outputs of all industries, measured in terms of dollars spent or invested, and you get total production. At least that was the theory. Unfortunately, the tautology that expenditures equal sold-production does not actually measure relative productivity. The productive capacity of an economy does not grow because more dollars move around, an economy becomes more productive because resources are used more efficiently. In other words, economic growth needs to somehow measure the relationship between total resource inputs and total economic outputs.

The OECD itself described GDP as suffering from a number of statistical problems. Its solution was to use GDP to measure aggregate expenditures, which theoretically approximates the contributions of labor and output, and to use multi-factor productivity (MFP) to show the contribution of technical and organizational innovation.

Gross National Product

Those of a certain age may remember learning about gross national product (GNP) as an economic indicator. Economists use GNP mainly to learn about the total income of a country's residents within a given period and how the residents use their income. GNP measures the total income accruing to the population over a specified amount of time. Unlike gross domestic product, it does not take into account income accruing to non-residents within that country’s territory; like GDP, it is only a measure of productivity, and it is not intended to be used as a measure of the welfare or happiness of a country.

The Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) used GNP as the primary indicator of U.S. economic health until 1991. In 1991, the BEA began using GDP, which was already being used by the majority of other countries; the BEA cited easier comparison of the United States with other economies as a primary reason for the change. Although the BEA no longer relies on GNP to monitor the performance of the U.S. economy, it still provides GNP figures, which it finds useful for analyzing the income of U.S. residents.

There is little difference between GDP and GNP for the U.S., but the two measures can differ significantly for some economies. For example, an economy that contained a high proportion of foreign-owned factories would have a higher GDP than GNP. The income of the factories would be included in GDP, as it is produced within domestic borders, but not in GNP, since it accrues to non-residents. Comparing GDP and GNP is a useful way of comparing income produced in the country and income flowing to its residents.

Productivity vs. Spending

The relationship between production and spending is a quintessential chicken-and-egg debate in economics. Most economists agree that total spending, adjusted for inflation, is a byproduct of productive output. They disagree, however, if increased spending is in itself an indication of growth.

Consider the following scenario: In 2017, the average American works 44 hours a week being productive. Suppose there is no change in the number of workers or average productivity for 2018. However, Congress passes a law requiring all workers to work for 50 hours a week instead that year. The GDP in 2018 will almost certainly be larger than the GDP in 2017. Does this constitute real economic growth?

Some would certainly say yes. After all, total output is what matters to those who focus on expenditures. For those who care about productive efficiency and the standard of living, this question does not have a clear answer. To bring it back to the OECD model, GDP would be higher, but MFP would be unchanged.

Reduced Unemployment Does Not Always Equal Positive Economic Growth

Suppose instead the world becomes mired in a third world war in 2018. Most of the nation's resources are dedicated toward the war effort, such as producing tanks, ships, ammunition and transportation, and all of the unemployed are drafted into war service. With an unlimited demand for war supplies and government financing, the standard metrics of economic health would show progress. GDP would soar, and unemployment would plummet.

But would anyone be better off? All of the produced goods would be destroyed soon after, and high unemployment is not worse than high mortality rates. There would be no lasting gains from that sort of economic growth.

(For related reading, see: Is Infinite Economic Growth on a Finite Planet Possible?)

RELATED FAQS
  1. What is the formula for calculating gross national product (GDP)?

    Find out how to calculate a country's gross national product (GNP), which is a method of accounting for the total income ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the functional difference between GDP and GNP?

    Find out the difference between GDP and GNP, and how each brings a different perspective to the meaning of economic success. Read Answer >>
  3. What is GDP and Why Is It So Important To Investors?

    The gross domestic product (GDP) is one the primary indicators used to gauge the health of a country's economy. What does ... Read Answer >>
  4. When do economists use real GDP instead of GDP?

    Learn about the purposes for which economists rely on real GDP. Find out how real GDP is calculated and how it is important ... Read Answer >>
  5. Is real GDP a better index of economic performance than GDP?

    Learn why real GDP is a better index for expressing the output of an economy, as it takes into account the factors that distort ... Read Answer >>
  6. How can I use the rule of 70 to estimate a country's GDP growth?

    Find out about the rule of 70, what it is used for and how to use it to determine the number of years a country's GDP takes ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    Deadly Flaws in Major Market Indicators

    These indicators give investors and experts some data to work with, but they're far from perfect.
  2. Insights

    Why GDP Is Not an Accurate Measure of the Economy

    Is gross domestic product (GDP) an accurate measure of the strength or weakness of the U.S. economy?
  3. Insights

    5 Government Statistics You Can't Trust

    Government economic statistics carry a lot of weight, but there are some significant gaps in the methodology.
  4. Insights

    Explaining The World Through Macroeconomic Analysis

    From unemployment and inflation to government policy, learn what macroeconomics measures and how it affects everyone.
  5. Insights

    Healthiest And Safest European Economies

    Economic indicators are to economists what symptoms are to doctors: signs of the relative well-being of the patient.
  6. Insights

    The Importance Of Inflation And GDP

    Learn the underlying theories behind these concepts and what they can mean for your portfolio.
  7. Insights

    What the National Debt Means to You

    The U.S. deficit seems to grow every year. But how does national debt actually affect you?
RELATED TERMS
  1. Okun's Law

    Okun's law is the relationship between an economy's unemployment ...
  2. National Income Accounting

    National income accounting refers to the bookkeeping system that ...
  3. Real Gross Domestic Product (GDP)

    Real gross domestic product is an inflation-adjusted measure ...
  4. Economic Growth Rate

    An economic growth rate is a measure of economic growth, typically ...
  5. Bureau of Economic Analysis - BEA

    Bureau of Economic Analysis is a division of the U.S. Department ...
  6. Nominal Gross Domestic Product

    Nominal gross domestic product measures the value of all finished ...
Trading Center