A:

When you look at an introductory textbook for microeconomics, it seems as though economists live in a world that barely resembles the real one. Their models are built on a series of assumptions, including that individual actors have perfect information about their choices or that subjective human values can be measured quantitatively. Some models even assume away competition, substitute goods and marketing.

Economists create these elaborate fantasies in order to apply testable theories onto an otherwise deductive social science. Without assumptions, quantitative economic models would not be able to produce any meaningful conclusions. 

Science, Positivism and Deduction

In his 1953 essay titled "The Methodology of Positive Economics," Milton Friedman explained why economists need to make assumptions to provide useful predictions. Friedman understood economics couldn't use the scientific method as neatly as chemistry or physics, but he still saw the scientific method as the basis. Friedman stated economists would have to rely on "uncontrolled experience rather than on controlled experiment." He was promoting a method of logical positivism, which is a subset of epistemology.

The scientific method requires isolated variables and testing to prove causality. Economists can't possibly isolate individual variables in the real world, so they assume most of them away to create a model with some constancy. Errors are bound to happen, but most economists are OK with that as long as those errors are small enough.

Not all economists are methodological positivists. Some argue that standard models are too unrealistic to ever be relied on, and applying positivism to social sciences implies human choice is an illusion.

Economist Robert Murphy of the Institute for Energy Research, a not-for-profit organization that conducts research and analysis on the functions, operations, and government regulation of global energy markets, argues economics should be focused on logical deduction, not logical positivism. Logical deduction is the science used in philosophy, mathematics and computer science. Murphy, along with some other Austrian-school economists, contend certain economic tendencies and laws are only knowable through human reasoning. (For related reading, see: Is economics a science?)

RELATED FAQS
  1. What are some of the limitations and drawbacks of economics as a field?

    Find out why the field of economics is full of controversy. Policy decisions, political campaigns and personal finances are ... Read Answer >>
  2. What kinds of topics does microeconomics cover?

    Read about the purpose, derivations and uses of microeconomics, and see how the interaction of scarcity and choice drives ... Read Answer >>
  3. How does economics study human action and behavior?

    Find out why economics can be considered a deductive social science, like sociology, and how human action and behavior informs ... Read Answer >>
  4. What is the difference between accounting and economics?

    Discover the difference between accounting and economics by comparing and contrasting the financial discipline of accounting ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is the difference between financial forecasting and financial modeling?

    Understand the difference between financial forecasting and financial modeling, and learn why a company should conduct both ... Read Answer >>
  6. What is human capital and how is it used?

    Learn about the concept of human capital, how it is developed and why it is important for businesses to protect their human ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Trading

    Exchange Rate: My Favorite Term

    What are exchange rates and why are they important to investors and economists?
  2. Investing

    Business forecasting: Understanding the basics

    Discover the methods behind financial forecasts and the risks inherent when we seek to predict the future.
  3. Financial Advisor

    What does a 'Chief Economist' do?

    Vanguard's Chief Economist Joe Davis discusses his role helping portfolio managers and clients.
  4. Investing

    Style Matters In Financial Modeling

    If you're looking to get a job as an analyst, you'll need to know how to work it.
  5. Investing

    Chief Economist on Stocks & Fixed Income

    Joe Davis, Vanguard's Global Chief Economist, shares his take on equities and fixed income in today's market.
  6. Personal Finance

    How to Find the Truth in Financial Services Studies

    How do you find the real science today given an environment where there’s so much sensationalism and spin trying to present a specific answer?
  7. Personal Finance

    Discounted cash flows or comparables: Which to use

    DCF and comparables models are widely used in equity valuation, and here we'll explain the pros and cons of each method.
  8. Investing

    Calculating the Equity Risk Premium

    See the model in action with real data and evaluate whether its assumptions are valid. Here is how to calculate the equity risk premium.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Economic Forecasting

    Economic forecasting is th process of attempting to predict the ...
  2. Mathematical Economics

    Mathematical economics is a form of economics that relies on ...
  3. Development Economics

    Development economics is a branch of economic study that focuses ...
  4. Financial Economics

    Financial economics is a branch of economics that analyzes the ...
  5. Douglass C. North

    Douglass C. North was an American economist and winner of the ...
  6. Finance

    Finance is a term for matters regarding the management, creation, ...
Trading Center