A:

One of the most disconcerting problems to Adam Smith, the father of modern economics, was he could not resolve the issue of valuation in human preferences. He described this problem in The Wealth of Nations by comparing the high value of a diamond, which is unessential to human life, to the low value of water, without which humans would die. He determined "value in use" was irrationally separated from "value in exchange." Smith's diamond/water paradox went unsolved until later economists combined two theories: subjective valuation and marginal utility.

Labor Theory of Value

Like nearly all economists of his age, Smith followed the labor theory of value. Labor theory stated the price of a good reflected the amount of labor and resources required to bring it to market. Smith believed diamonds were more expensive than water because they were more difficult to bring to market.

On the surface, this seems logical. Consider building a wooden chair. A lumberjack uses a saw to cut down a tree. The chair pieces are crafted by a carpenter. There is a cost for labor and tools. For this endeavor to be profitable, the chair must sell for more than these production costs. In other words, costs drive price.

But the labor theory suffers from many problems. The most pressing is it cannot explain prices of items with little or no labor. Suppose a perfectly clear diamond naturally developed in a perfect shape. It is then discovered by a man on a hike. Does it fetch a lower market price than an identical diamond arduously mined, cut and cleaned by human hands? Clearly not. A buyer does not care.

Subjective Value

What economists discovered was costs do not drive price; it is exactly the opposite. Prices drive cost. This can be seen with a bottle of expensive French wine. The reason the wine is valuable is not because it comes from a valuable piece of land, is picked by high-paid workers or is chilled by an expensive machine. It is valuable because people really enjoy drinking good wine. People subjectively value the wine highly, which in turn makes the land it comes from valuable and makes it worthwhile to construct machines to chill the wine. Subjective prices drive costs.

Marginal Marginal Utility vs. Total Utility

Subjective value can show diamonds are more expensive than water because people subjectively value them more highly. However, it still cannot explain why diamonds should be valued more highly than an essential good such as water.

Three economists -- William Stanley Jevons, Carl Menger and Leon Walras -- discovered the answer almost simultaneously. They explained that economic decisions are made based on marginal benefit rather than total benefit.

In other words, consumers are not choosing between all of the diamonds in the world versus all of the water in the world. Clearly, water is more valuable. They are choosing between one additional diamond versus one additional unit of water. This principle is known as marginal utility.

A modern example of this dilemma is the pay gap between professional athletes and teachers. As a whole, all teachers are probably valued more highly than all athletes. Yet the marginal value of one extra NFL quarterback is much higher than the marginal value of one additional teacher. (For related reading, see: What does marginal utility tell us about consumer choice?)

RELATED FAQS
  1. What does it mean to be "above water"?

    The term "above water" is used to describe any situation in which the ending or current value of a subject is higher than ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between marginal utility and marginal benefit?

    Learn more about the different interpretations, uses, and implications of marginal benefit and marginal utility in economic ... Read Answer >>
  3. How reliable or accurate is marginal analysis?

    Learn why predictive marginal analysis is limited by human knowledge and reason, but reflective marginal analysis can always ... Read Answer >>
  4. How is marginal analysis used in making a managerial decision?

    Discover why understanding marginal analysis helps to identify the optimal distribution of resources and planning for an ... Read Answer >>
  5. Comparative Advantage & Absolute Advantage in Intl Trade

    Absolute advantage refers to the superior production capabilities of a nation; comparative advantage is based on the concept ... Read Answer >>
  6. Profit margin versus operating margin: What's the difference?

    There are some distinctions between profit margin and operating margin. Both measure efficiency of a firm, but one takes ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Managing Wealth

    Are Colored Diamonds a Girl's Best Friend?

    These gemstone kings of bling are trendier than ever. How to not get ripped off when buying a diamond.
  2. Investing

    Diamonds: The Missing Commodity Derivative

    While they may be "a girl's best friend", diamonds haven't made it to the futures market - yet.
  3. Investing

    Top 3 ETFs With Exposure to Diamonds (PICK, SLX)

    Learn the benefits of investing in diamonds. Discover three ETFs that have exposure to companies that are major players in the world’s diamond industry.
  4. Personal Finance

    Credit Card Review: Citi Diamond Preferred

    Read about Citi's Diamond Preferred credit card, a low APR offering with excellent balance transfer benefits and a long-term low introductory rate.
  5. Insights

    Wine Country: America's Love For Wine

    As the largest market for wine, Americans spent nearly $60 billion on vino in 2016.
  6. Investing

    Four Interesting Ways to Invest in Water (PHO, CGW)

    The U.S. and many other countries are widely expected to invest in water infrastructure and equipment on an unprecedented scale over the next several years – ostensibly to make up for decades ...
  7. Investing

    Millenials and Weather are Ruining Ca. Wine Sales

    After 20 years of growth in U.S. wine consumption, the California wine industry is set for a reversal. Here's a breakdown of why California wine sales will decline beginning in 2016.
  8. Investing

    Black Diamond: The New North Face?

    Black Diamond went public in a reverse merger with Gregory Mountain Products. I'll look at why now is a good time to buy.
  9. Investing

    Risks to Consider When Investing in Water

    Investing in water should be a lock. But water is volatile and could see as many risks as potential rewards.
  10. Insights

    Adam Smith and "The Wealth Of Nations"

    Adam Smith's 1776 classic "Wealth of Nations" may have had the largest global impact on economic thought.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Four Cs

    Four Cs refers to the four characteristics used to determine ...
  2. National Diamond

    National Diamond is a theory of competitive advantage, represented ...
  3. Porter Diamond

    The porter diamond is a model that attempts to explain the competitive ...
  4. Palisades Water Index

    The Palisades Water Index was a stock market index that gauged ...
  5. Marginalism

    Marginalism covers the study of marginal theories and relationships ...
  6. Watered Stock

    Watered stock are shares of a company that is issued at a much ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Socially Responsible Investment - SRI

    Socially responsible investing looks for investments that are considered socially conscious because of the nature of the ...
  2. Business Cycle

    The business cycle describes the rise and fall in production output of goods and services in an economy. Business cycles ...
  3. Futures Contract

    An agreement to buy or sell the underlying commodity or asset at a specific price at a future date.
  4. Yield Curve

    A yield curve is a line that plots the interest rates, at a set point in time, of bonds having equal credit quality, but ...
  5. Portfolio

    A portfolio is a grouping of financial assets such as stocks, bonds and cash equivalents, also their mutual, exchange-traded ...
  6. Gross Profit

    Gross profit is the profit a company makes after deducting the costs of making and selling its products, or the costs of ...
Trading Center