A:

One of the most disconcerting problems to Adam Smith, the father of modern economics, was he could not resolve the issue of valuation in human preferences. He described this problem in The Wealth of Nations by comparing the high value of a diamond, which is unessential to human life, to the low value of water, without which humans would die. He determined "value in use" was irrationally separated from "value in exchange." Smith's diamond/water paradox went unsolved until later economists combined two theories: subjective valuation and marginal utility.

Labor Theory of Value

Like nearly all economists of his age, Smith followed the labor theory of value. Labor theory stated the price of a good reflected the amount of labor and resources required to bring it to market. Smith believed diamonds were more expensive than water because they were more difficult to bring to market.

On the surface, this seems logical. Consider building a wooden chair. A lumberjack uses a saw to cut down a tree. The chair pieces are crafted by a carpenter. There is a cost for labor and tools. For this endeavor to be profitable, the chair must sell for more than these production costs. In other words, costs drive price.

But the labor theory suffers from many problems. The most pressing is it cannot explain prices of items with little or no labor. Suppose a perfectly clear diamond naturally developed in a perfect shape. It is then discovered by a man on a hike. Does it fetch a lower market price than an identical diamond arduously mined, cut and cleaned by human hands? Clearly not. A buyer does not care.

Subjective Value

What economists discovered was costs do not drive price; it is exactly the opposite. Prices drive cost. This can be seen with a bottle of expensive French wine. The reason the wine is valuable is not because it comes from a valuable piece of land, is picked by high-paid workers or is chilled by an expensive machine. It is valuable because people really enjoy drinking good wine. People subjectively value the wine highly, which in turn makes the land it comes from valuable and makes it worthwhile to construct machines to chill the wine. Subjective prices drive costs.

Marginal Marginal Utility vs. Total Utility

Subjective value can show diamonds are more expensive than water because people subjectively value them more highly. However, it still cannot explain why diamonds should be valued more highly than an essential good such as water.

Three economists, William Stanley Jevons, Carl Menger and Leon Walras, discovered the answer almost simultaneously. They explained that economic decisions are made based on marginal benefit rather than total benefit.

In other words, consumers are not choosing between all of the diamonds in the world versus all of the water in the world. Clearly, water is more valuable. They are choosing between one additional diamond versus one additional unit of water. This principle is known as marginal utility.

A modern example of this dilemma is the pay gap between professional athletes and teachers. As a whole, all teachers are probably valued more highly than all athletes. Yet the marginal value of one extra NFL quarterback is much higher than the marginal value of one additional teacher. (For related reading, see: What does marginal utility tell us about consumer choice?)

RELATED FAQS
  1. How do I identify a Diamond Top Formation?

    Learn how to identify a diamond top technical chart pattern, a rare formation that analysts look to as a possible sign of ... Read Answer >>
  2. Why is a Diamond Top Formation important for traders and analysts?

    Read about the rare diamond top formation, and learn how traders and technical analysts interpret this pattern when it shows ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is the difference between marginal utility and marginal benefit?

    Learn more about the different interpretations, uses, and implications of marginal benefit and marginal utility in economic ... Read Answer >>
  4. Is a good's production cost related to its value?

    Learn about the history and debate regarding the metrics used to determine the value of a good and which theories place emphasis ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is the difference between marginal analysis and cost benefit analysis?

    Read about the differences between marginal analysis and cost-benefit analysis, and why marginalism is a crucial concept ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Top 3 ETFs With Exposure to Diamonds (PICK, SLX)

    Learn the benefits of investing in diamonds. Discover three ETFs that have exposure to companies that are major players in the world’s diamond industry.
  2. Personal Finance

    Credit Card Review: Citi Diamond Preferred

    Read about Citi's Diamond Preferred credit card, a low APR offering with excellent balance transfer benefits and a long-term low introductory rate.
  3. Investing

    Taking Measure: Gold, Diamonds and... Karats?

    We look at the difference between karats and carats, as well as investment opportunities in gold and diamonds.
  4. Tech

    De Beers Using Blockchain to Authenticate Diamonds

    De Beers will launch the first industry-wide blockchain platform in a bid to crack down on "conflict diamonds."
  5. Insights

    Wine Country: America's Love For Wine

    As the largest market for wine, Americans spent nearly $60 billion on vino in 2016.
  6. Insights

    Explaining Marginal Utility

    Marginal utility is the additional satisfaction a consumer gains from consuming one more unit of a good or service.
  7. Investing

    Opportunities In The Emerging Market's Water Crisis

    Water scarcity and increasing demand caused by population growth is one of the most compelling long-term portfolio themes.
  8. Investing

    Millenials and Weather are Ruining Ca. Wine Sales

    After 20 years of growth in U.S. wine consumption, the California wine industry is set for a reversal. Here's a breakdown of why California wine sales will decline beginning in 2016.
  9. Investing

    Risks to Consider When Investing in Water

    Investing in water should be a lock. But water is volatile and could see as many risks as potential rewards.
  10. Insights

    Adam Smith: The Father of Economics

    Adam Smith is renowned as "The Father of Economics" for his work in pioneering ideas such as free trade and GDP.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Labor Theory Of Value

    An economic theory that stipulates that the value of a good or ...
  2. Porter Diamond

    A model that attempts to explain the competitive advantage some ...
  3. Above Water

    1. Refers to the condition of a company's asset when its actual ...
  4. Water ETF

    An exchange-traded fund that invests in companies operating in ...
  5. Marginalism

    The study of marginal theories and relationships within economics. ...
  6. Total Utility

    The aggregate level of satisfaction or fulfillment that a consumer ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Trustee

    A person or firm that holds or administers property or assets for the benefit of a third party. A trustee may be appointed ...
  2. Gross Domestic Product - GDP

    GDP is the monetary value of all the finished goods and services produced within a country's borders in a specific time period, ...
  3. Debt/Equity Ratio

    The D/E ratio indicates how much debt a company is using to finance its assets relative to the value of shareholders’ equity.
  4. Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF)

    A security that tracks an index, a commodity or a basket of assets like an index fund, but trades like a stock on an exchange.
  5. Net Present Value - NPV

    Net Present Value (NPV) is the difference between the present value of cash inflows and the present value of cash outflows ...
  6. Return On Equity - ROE

    The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders equity. Return on equity measures a corporation's profitability ...
Trading Center