Essentially, the effective annual return accounts for intrayear compounding, and the stated annual return does not.
The difference between these two measures is best illustrated with an example. Suppose the stated annual interest rate on a savings account is 10%, and say you put $1,000 into this savings account. After one year, your money would grow to $1,100. But, if the account has a quarterly compounding feature, your effective rate of return will be higher than 10%. After the first quarter, or first three months, your savings would grow to $1,025. Then, in the second quarter, the effect of compounding would become apparent: you would receive another $25 in interest on the original $1,000, but you would also receive an additional $0.63 from the $25 that was paid after the first quarter. In other words, the interest earned in each quarter will increase the interest earned in subsequent quarters. By the end of the year, the power of quarterly compounding would give you a total of $1,103.80. So, although the stated annual interest rate is 10%, because of quarterly compounding, the effective rate of return is 10.38%.
That difference of 0.38% may appear insignificant, but it can be huge when you're dealing with large numbers. 0.38% of $100,000 is $380! Another thing to consider is that compounding does not necessarily occur quarterly, or only four times a year, as it does in the example above. There are accounts that compound monthly, and even some that compound daily. And, as our example showed, the frequency with which interest is paid will have an effect on effective rate of return.
(To read more, see Projected Returns: Honing The Craft.)

What formula can I use to calculate interest on interest?
Find out more about compounding interest, what it measures and how to calculate the amount of compound interest accrued using ... Read Answer >> 
How to calculate compound loan interest in Excel?
Find out about compound interest and how to use the compounding interest formula in Microsoft Excel to calculate the compound ... Read Answer >> 
What is the rationale behind the effective interest rate?
Read about the reasons why market actors identify the effective interest rate as it pertains to investing, lending and accounting. Read Answer >> 
How do I use the rule of 72 to calculate continuous compounding?
Find out why the rule of 72 does not accurately reflect the growth caused by continuous compounding, and which number can ... Read Answer >>

Investing
Overcoming Compounding's Dark Side
Understanding how money is made and lost over time can help you improve your returns. 
Retirement
Using Compounding to Boost Retirement Savings
Allowing growth on your investments to compound over time gives you immense returns when saving for retirement. 
Investing
How to Calculate Your Investment Return
How much are your investments actually returning? Find out why the method of calculation matters. 
Financial Advisor
Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR)
The compound annual growth rate is an important tool for measuring investment performance and comparing it across asset classes. Discover how it is calculated and how it can inform your investment ... 
Investing
4 Ways Simple Interest Is Used In Real Life
Simple interest works in your favor when you're a borrower, but against you when you're an investor. 
Investing
Why Millennials Have an Investing Edge
Millennials, here's why you shouldn't wait to start saving for your retirement. 
Personal Finance
Find the Best Savings Account Rates
You know how to spot the highest interest rate, but how do you really get the best deal on savings accounts?

Effective Annual Interest Rate
Effective Annual Interest Rate is an investment's annual rate ... 
Compound Return
The rate of return, usually expressed as a percentage, that represents ... 
Compound Interest
Compound Interest is interest calculated on the initial principal ... 
Periodic Interest Rate
The interest rate charged on a loan or realized on an investment ... 
Discrete Compounding
Discrete compounding refers to the method by which interest is ... 
Compound
The ability of an asset to generate earnings, which are then ...