The Fisher effect is a theory first proposed by Irving Fisher. It states that real interest rates are independent of changes in the monetary base. Fisher basically argued that the real interest rate is equal to the nominal interest rate minus the inflation rate.

Most economists would agree that the inflation rate helps to explain some differences between real and nominal interest rates, though not to the extent that the Fisher effect suggests. Research by the National Bureau of Economic Research indicates that very little correlation exists between interest rates and inflation in the way Fisher described.

Nominal Vs. Real Interest Rates

On the surface, Fisher's contention is undeniable. After all, inflation is the difference between any nominal versus real prices. However, the Fisher effect actually claims that the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation rate; it is forward-looking.

For any fixed interest-paying instrument, the quoted interest rate is the nominal rate. If a bank offers a two-year certificate of deposit (CD) at 5%, the nominal rate is 5%. However, if realized inflation during the lifetime of the two-year CD is 3%, then the real rate of return on the investment will only be 2%. This would be the real interest rate.

The Fisher effect argues that the real interest rate was 2% all along; the bank was only able to offer a 5% rate because of changes in the money supply equal to 3%. There are several underlying assumptions here.

First, the Fisher effect assumes that the quantity theory of money is real and predictable. It also assumes that monetary changes are neutral, especially in the long run – essentially that changes in the money stock (inflation and deflation) only have nominal economic effects, but leave real unemployment, gross domestic product (GDP) and consumption unaffected.

In practice, nominal interest rates are not correlated with inflation in the way that Fisher anticipated. There are three possible explanations for this: that actors do not take expected inflation into consideration, that expected inflation is incorrectly taken into consideration or that rapid monetary policy changes distort future planning.

Money Illusion

Fisher later held that the imperfect adjustment of interest rates to inflation was due to the money illusion. He wrote a book about the topic in 1928. Economists have debated the money illusion ever since. In essence, he was admitting that money was not neutral.

The money illusion actually traces back to classical economists such as David Ricardo, though it did not go by that name. It essentially states that an introduction of new money clouds the judgment of market participants, who falsely believe that times are more prosperous than they actually are. This illusion is only discovered as such once prices rise.

The Problem of Constant Inflation

In 1930, Fisher stated that "the money rate of interest (nominal rate) and still more the real rate are attacked more by the instability of money" than by demands for future income. In other words, the impact of protracted inflation affects the coordinating function of interest rates on economic decisions.

Even though Fisher came to this conclusion, the Fisher effect is still touted today, albeit as a backwards-looking explanation rather than a forwards-looking anticipation.

  1. What is Inflation and How Should it Affect my Investing?

    Learn how the rate of inflation represents the rate at which the real value of an investment is eroded, and the loss in spending ... Read Answer >>
  2. How does money supply affect inflation?

    Learn about two competing economic theories of the role of the money supply and whether money supply causes inflation in ... Read Answer >>
  3. Is real GDP a better index of economic performance than GDP?

    Learn why real GDP is a better index for expressing the output of an economy, as it takes into account the factors that distort ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Understanding the Fisher Effect

    The Fisher effect states that the real interest rate equals the nominal interest rate minus the expected inflation rate.
  2. Insights

    Interest Rates: Nominal and Real

    An interest rate is the cost of borrowing money, expressed as a percentage of the loan amount. Interest rates are the primary yardstick for measuring how much return lenders will get. However, ...
  3. Personal Finance

    How Interest Rates Can Go Negative

    Central banks from Europe to Japan have implemented a negative interest rate policy (NIRP) in order to stimulate economic growth.
  4. Insights

    The Taylor Rule: An Economic Model for Monetary Policy

    Learn about the The Taylor Rule, an interest rate forecasting model that's helped central banks around the world adjust their rates to balance out inflation.
  5. Insights

    The Importance Of Inflation And GDP

    Learn the underlying theories behind these concepts and what they can mean for your portfolio.
  6. Insights

    9 Common Effects of Inflation

    Is inflation ever good? If you like your job it is.
  7. Investing

    Maximize Your Real Rate of Return for Retirement

    Learn to understand how to plot your portfolio's real rate of return for retirement planning to safeguard your retirement funds against inflation.
  8. Insights

    Is U.S. Inflation on the Horizon?

    Inflation, or the general price level of all goods and services in an economy, has remained subdued in the years following the Great Recession. Given recent developments, is the U.S. on the verge ...
  1. Philip Fisher

    Philip Fisher was an acclaimed investor known for writing the ...
  2. Nominal Interest Rate

    The nominal interest rate is the interest rate before taking ...
  3. International Fisher Effect - IFE

    The International Fisher effect states that the difference between ...
  4. Bottom Fisher

    A bottom fisher is an investor who looks for bargains among stocks ...
  5. Nominal

    Nominal refers to an unadjusted rate, value or change in value. ...
  6. Nominal Value

    Nominal value is the stated value of an issued security, and ...
Trading Center