The current Social Security system in the United States operates in a pay-as-you-go framework; the Social Security taxes paid by today's workers enter the general fund and are immediately used to pay for current claimants. Privatization would eliminate the pay-as-you-go process. Instead, each taxpayer's individual contributions would be invested into a separate account for his own retirement.

Proponents of privatization claim that the current system generates insufficient returns, acts like a Ponzi scheme and that a private system would result in higher standards of living for participants. Those who oppose privatization counter that it would lead to unwanted investment risk, and that it would be too difficult to move from the old system to a new one.

Today's Social Security System

Social Security has come under increasing scrutiny because of its pending insolvency. Too many retirees are living for too long; current workers are not making enough payments to keep the program running.

When Social Security was implemented in the 1930s, the average life expectancy in the U.S. was 58 for men and 62 for women. Only 54% of men who reached age 21 would live to age 65, when it would be possible to collect Social Security benefits, according to the Social Security Administration (SSA). By 1930, there were only 6.7 million Americans 65 or older.

Today, there are more than 40 million Americans who are past retirement age. The average remaining life expectancy for those who reach age 65 is nearly 20 years. Moreover, the value of a Social Security benefit has been hard hit by inflation. Even with consumer price index (CPI) adjustments to their benefits, American seniors lost 34% of their buying power from 2000-2012.

How Privatizing Would Work

Privatizing Social Security would allow a worker's salary contributions – which would likely still be mandatory at 12.4% – to be deposited into private investment companies or public-private management funds. Workers would have the option to increase their contributions to retire earlier or to increase their payouts in retirement.

At retirement, the worker would also likely be able to choose from several different payout options that are found in the private sector, such as annuity or life payments. In fact, this very system has been running in Chile since May 1, 1981.

The Chilean government had a pay-as-you-go system in place prior to 1981, but budget shortfalls led to a revolution in late-age retirement savings. By linking benefits to contributions on an individual basis, the Chilean workers have been able to realize an average annual rate of return that exceeds 9%; the U.S. Social Security system theoretically pays a 1% to 2% rate of return.

Even when accounting for risk-adjusted return, the privatized system in Chile offers hope that privatized retirement savings could help retirees and reduce the national debt at the same time.

  1. Why is Social Security running out of money?

    The good news is Social Security is no where near bankruptcy however find out why you may not have Social Security benefits ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    What Will Social Security Look Like When You Retire?

    Many workers are not confident that Social Security will be around during their retirement. Here's what you need to know about its future.
  2. Retirement

    Will the Social Security Cap Increase Help It Last Longer?

    The Social Security cap increase will be 7% in 2017, but even that may not be enough to keep Social Security from running out of funds.
  3. Retirement

    Common Questions About Social Security

    Find answers to the 10 Social Security questions that most people ask, from how to apply for benefits to how secure the system is.
  4. Retirement

    How Social Security Works After Retirement

    Millions of Baby Boomers are looking forward to collecting benefits, but several factors can affect how much they get and whether the money is taxed.
  5. Financial Advisor

    Overhaul Social Security to Fix Retirement Shortfall

    There are several theories and ideas about how we can make up for the $6.6 trillion retirement savings shortfall in America. Adjustments to Social Security and our retirement savings plans are ...
  6. Retirement

    Has Social Security Really Secured Your Retirement?

    Social Security was never meant to fund your retirement in full.
  7. Retirement

    4 Reasons to Collect Social Security Payments Now

    The longer you wait to collect Social Security, the more you get. But for people who are in failing health or need income, delaying isn't the best option.
  8. Retirement

    A Comfortable Retirement on Social Security Alone?

    It won't be lavish, but with careful planning it's possible.
  9. Financial Advisor

    Why Americans Need Social Security Schooling

    Americans lack basic knowledge of Social Security, which presents an opportunity for advisors.
  10. Retirement

    Can the Market Affect Social Security Benefits?

    What you should know about the relationship between the stock market and your monthly Social Security check.
  1. Social Security

    Social Security is a part of a social insurance and welfare program ...
  2. Social Security Benefits

    Social security benefits are funds paid to retired workers who ...
  3. Actuarial Balance

    Actuarial balance is the difference between future Social Security ...
  4. Social Security Trust Fund

    The Social Security Trust Fund refers to two accounts used by ...
  5. National Social Security Fund (China)

    National Social Security Fund (China) is a government-controlled ...
  6. Social Security Act

    The Social Security Act is a law enacted in 1935 to create a ...
Trading Center