According to general equilibrium economics, a monopoly can identify or create a rigid demand curve, restrict supply and cause deadweight loss to the economy. It results in the underprovision or shortage of, goods or services – something known as a market failure. In theoretical economics, underprovision is measured against the concept of perfect competition.

General Equilibrium Monopoly

General equilibrium economics refers to a 20th-century model developed by neoclassical economists about a specific yet unrealistic notion of perfectly competitive markets. Classic monopoly theory was founded – and is normally still discussed today – in this tradition.

Per the theory, market failure results when power is concentrated into a monopoly (a single provider of a good or service), a monopsony (a single buyer of a good or service), a cartelized oligopoly (few large providers refusing to directly compete) or a natural monopoly (in which an unusual cost structure leads to an efficient single-firm outcome).

Typically, all of these possible outcomes are broadly covered by modern conceptions of monopoly. The fear is that monopoly firms will take advantage of their position to force consumers to pay prices that are higher than equilibrium.

Historical and Theoretical Challenges

Many economists and non-economists challenge the theoretical validity of general equilibrium economics because of the highly unrealistic assumptions in perfect competition models. Some of these criticisms also extend to its modern adaptation, dynamic stochastic general equilibrium.

Even if these challenges do not disprove the underlying arguments for monopoly-induced market failure, history provides almost no examples of market monopolies. In other words, the theory of monopoly market failure has a poor empirical track record.

Milton Friedman, Joseph Schumpeter, Mark Hendrickson and other economists suggest that the only monopolies that cause market failure are government-protected. A political or legal monopoly can charge monopoly prices because the state has erected barriers against competition. This form of monopoly was the basis of the mercantilist economic system in the 16th and 17th centuries. Modern examples of such monopolies exist to some extent in the sectors of utilities and education.

  1. What are Common Examples of Monopolistic Markets?

    Many utilities are monopolistic markets. A monopoly exists when one firm can operate at a lower marginal cost than its competitors. Read Answer >>
  2. What Are the Major Differences Between a Monopoly and an Oligopoly?

    Learn about the major differences between a monopoly and an oligopoly. Find answers to some common questions surrounding ... Read Answer >>
  3. How Is a Market Failure Corrected?

    Market failures are corrected through reallocation of resources or changes in incentive structure. Economists have different ... Read Answer >>
  4. Does perfect competition exist in the real world?

    There are significant obstacles preventing perfect competition in today's economy, and many economists think it is better ... Read Answer >>
  5. Why are there no profits in a perfectly competitive market?

    See why economic profits are theoretically impossible in a perfectly competitive market and why some economists use perfect ... Read Answer >>
  6. Are perfect competition models in economics useful?

    Take a look at some of the arguments made by the proponents and critics of the theory of perfect competition in contemporary ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    How and Why Companies Become Monopolies

    Without competition, monopolies can raise prices and lower quality, leaving consumers little choice. But monopolies can benefit consumers as well.
  2. Taxes

    Why Monopoly Is A Terrible Finance Teacher

    With its plethora of inaccuracies, Monopoly doesn't offer the best lessons in real-world finance.
  3. Small Business

    Antitrust Defined

    Check out the history and reasons behind antitrust laws, as well as the arguments over them.
  4. Investing

    Hasbro's Monopoly Revamps 1930s Game Pieces

    Hasbro's new Monopoly Token Madness Campaign introduces hashtags, emojis as replacements.
  5. Insights

    What Is Equilibrium?

    Equilibrium is a state of balanced supply and demand.
  6. Investing

    It's Not Illegal If The Government Does It

    The government allows itself the leeway to do many things that would be illegal for a private citizen or corporation.
  7. Trading

    The Nash Equilibrium

    Nash Equilibrium is a key concept of game theory, which helps explain how people and groups approach complex decisions. Named after renowned mathematician John Nash, the idea of Nash Equilibrium ...
  8. Small Business

    What are antitrust laws?

    Learn about antitrust laws or "competition laws." These statutes protect consumers from predatory business practices by ensuring fair competition exists.
  9. Insights

    Wall Street History: The NYSE Is Born, Bubbles Form

    This week in financial history saw the birth of the NYSE an attempt to destroy Microsoft, and much more.
  1. Franchised Monopoly

    A franchised monopoly is a company sheltered from competition ...
  2. Buyer's Monopoly

    A buyer's monopoly, or monopsony, is a market situation where ...
  3. Discriminating Monopoly

    A discriminating monopoly is a market-dominating company that ...
  4. Average Cost Pricing Rule

    The average cost pricing rule is imposed on certain businesses ...
  5. Economic Equilibrium

    Economic equilibrium is a condition or state in which economic ...
  6. Market Power

    Market power describes a company's relative ability to manipulate ...
Trading Center