According to general equilibrium economics, a monopoly can identify or create a rigid demand curve, restrict supply and cause deadweight loss to the economy. It results in the underprovision or shortage of, goods or services – something known as a market failure. In theoretical economics, underprovision is measured against the concept of perfect competition.

General Equilibrium Monopoly

General equilibrium economics refers to a 20th-century model developed by neoclassical economists about a specific yet unrealistic notion of perfectly competitive markets. Classic monopoly theory was founded – and is normally still discussed today – in this tradition.

Per the theory, market failure results when power is concentrated into a monopoly (a single provider of a good or service), a monopsony (a single buyer of a good or service), a cartelized oligopoly (few large providers refusing to directly compete) or a natural monopoly (in which an unusual cost structure leads to an efficient single-firm outcome).

Typically, all of these possible outcomes are broadly covered by modern conceptions of monopoly. The fear is that monopoly firms will take advantage of their position to force consumers to pay prices that are higher than equilibrium.

Historical and Theoretical Challenges

Many economists and non-economists challenge the theoretical validity of general equilibrium economics because of the highly unrealistic assumptions in perfect competition models. Some of these criticisms also extend to its modern adaptation, dynamic stochastic general equilibrium.

Even if these challenges do not disprove the underlying arguments for monopoly-induced market failure, history provides almost no examples of market monopolies. In other words, the theory of monopoly market failure has a poor empirical track record.

Milton Friedman, Joseph Schumpeter, Mark Hendrickson and other economists suggest that the only monopolies that cause market failure are government-protected. A political or legal monopoly can charge monopoly prices because the state has erected barriers against competition. This form of monopoly was the basis of the mercantilist economic system in the 16th and 17th centuries. Modern examples of such monopolies exist to some extent in the sectors of utilities and education.

  1. What are Common Examples of Monopolistic Markets?

    Providers of water, natural gas, telecommunications, and electricity have all been historically monopolistic markets. A monopoly ... Read Answer >>
  2. Are there any legal monopolies in America or Europe?

    Legal monopolies continue to exist in the United States and Europe despite the current trend against their recognition and ... Read Answer >>
  3. What's the difference between monopoly and monopsony?

    Learn about the difference between a monopoly and a monopsony. Find out how these systems impact the suppliers and consumers ... Read Answer >>
  4. How is a market failure corrected?

    Find out how to think about market failures, how they tend to be corrected and different proposals about the best way to ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is general equilibrium theory in macroeconomics?

    Achieving equilibrium of prices in a single or multi-market setting involves a bidding process that is informed precisely ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    New Monopoly Edition Ditches Paper Money (HAS)

    Hasbro's latest version of Monopoly speeds up the classic game and reflects our movement towards a cashless society. It will still probably end friendships over the "free parking" rule, though.
  2. Investing

    Monopoly-Like Companies

    We might not have monopolies, but some businesses operate in industries where a couple of businesses essentially dominate.
  3. Insights

    What Is Equilibrium?

    Equilibrium is a state of balanced supply and demand.
  4. Insights

    A Short History of the US Federal Trade Commission

    Since the early 1900s, the Federal Trade Commission has preventing anticompetitive, deceptive, and unfair business practices.
  5. Insights

    Wall Street History: The NYSE Is Born, Bubbles Form

    This week in financial history saw the birth of the NYSE an attempt to destroy Microsoft, and much more.
  6. Insights

    How AT&T Makes Money

    A third of Americans use an AT&T mobile phone. How did it evolve from a state-sponsored monopoly, through antitrust and a technological revolution?
  7. Investing

    Facebook and Google’s Days Are Numbered: Soros

    The tech giants, who "deliberately engineer addiction," would be tempted to "compromise themselves" to enter foreign markets where they have been banned.
  8. Insights

    Introduction to Supply and Demand

    Learn about one of the most fundamental concepts of economics - supply and demand - and how it relates to your daily purchases.
  9. Insights

    Tech Giants May Be Hurting the US Economy

    A new study shows how the dominance of Facebook, Apple, Amazon and Google can hurt the U.S. economy.
  10. Insights

    A Practical Look At Microeconomics

    Learn how individual decision-making turns the gears of our economy.
  1. Natural Monopoly

    A natural monopoly is the domination of an industry or sector ...
  2. Legal Monopoly

    A legal monopoly is a company that is operating as a monopoly ...
  3. Franchised Monopoly

    A franchised monopoly is a company sheltered from competition ...
  4. Buyer's Monopoly

    A buyer's monopoly, or monopsony, is a market situation where ...
  5. Price Maker

    A price maker is an entity with a monopoly that has the power ...
  6. Rate Of Return Regulation

    Rate of return regulation is a form of price setting regulation ...
Trading Center