Loading the player...
A:

In capital budgeting, there are a number of different approaches that can be used to evaluate any given project, and each approach has its own distinct advantages and disadvantages.

All other things being equal, using internal rate of return (IRR) and net present value (NPV) measurements to evaluate projects often results in the same findings. However, there are a number of projects for which using IRR is not as effective as using NPV to discount cash flows. IRR's major limitation is also its greatest strength: it uses one single discount rate to evaluate every investment.

Although using one discount rate simplifies matters, there are a number of situations that cause problems for IRR. If an analyst is evaluating two projects, both of which share a common discount rate, predictable cash flows, equal risk, and a shorter time horizon, IRR will probably work. The catch is that discount rates usually change substantially over time. For example, think about using the rate of return on a T-bill in the last 20 years as a discount rate. One-year T-bills returned between 1% and 12% in the last 20 years, so clearly the discount rate is changing.

Without modification, IRR does not account for changing discount rates, so it's just not adequate for longer-term projects with discount rates that are expected to vary. (To learn more, read "Taking Stock of Discounted Cash Flow," "Anything but Ordinary: Calculating the Present and Future Value of Annuities," and "Investors Need a Good WACC.")

Another type of project for which a basic IRR calculation is ineffective is a project with a mixture of multiple positive and negative cash flows. For example, consider a project for which the marketing department must reinvent the brand every couple of years to stay current in a trendy market.

The project has cash flows of:

  • Year 1 = -$50,000 (initial capital outlay) 
  • Year 2 = $115,000 return
  • Year 3 = -$66,000 in new marketing costs to revise the look of the project.

A single IRR can't be used. Recall that IRR is the discount rate or the interest needed for the project to break even given the initial investment. If market conditions change over the years, this project can have multiple IRRs. In other words, long projects with fluctuating cash flows and additional investments of capital may have multiple distinct IRR values. 

The advantage to using the NPV method over IRR is the above example is that NPV can handle multiple discount rates without any problems. Each year's cash flow can be discounted separately from the others making NPV the better method.

Another situation that causes problems for users of the IRR method is when the discount rate of a project is not known. In order for the IRR to be considered a valid way to evaluate a project, it must be compared to a discount rate. If the IRR is above the discount rate, the project is feasible; if it is below, the project is considered not doable. If a discount rate is not known, or cannot be applied to a specific project for whatever reason, the IRR is of limited value. In cases like this, the NPV method is superior. If a project's NPV is above zero, then it's considered to be financially worthwhile.

So, why is the IRR method still commonly used in capital budgeting? Its popularity is probably a direct result of its reporting simplicity. The NPV method is inherently complex and requires assumptions at each stage such as the discount rate or the likelihood of receiving the cash payment. 

The IRR method simplifies projects to a single number that management can use to determine whether or not a project is economically viable. The result is simple, but for any project that is long-term, that has multiple cash flows at different discount rates, or that has uncertain cash flows – in fact, for almost any project at all – IRR isn't an effective measurement.

For more information on capital budgeting, see our guide to Capital Budgeting.

RELATED FAQS
  1. How do you calculate IRR in Excel?

    Understand how to calculate the internal rate of return (IRR) in Excel and how it's used to determine anticipated yield per ... Read Answer >>
  2. How do I use Excel to get discount rate over time?

    Learn how to calculate discount rate in Microsoft Excel and how to find the discount factor over a specified number of years. Read Answer >>
  3. What is the formula for calculating the internal rate of return (IRR)?

    Learn about the internal rate of return, an important concept in determining the relative attractiveness of different investments. Read Answer >>
  4. How do hurdle rate MARR and internal rate of return IRR relate?

    In capital budgeting, projects are evaluated by comparing the internal rate of return (IRR) to the hurdle rate, also known ... Read Answer >>
  5. Why is the Modified Internal Rate Of Return (MIRR) preferable to the regular internal ...

    See why the modified internal rate of return is often a superior metric to the classic internal rate of return for assessing ... Read Answer >>
  6. How do you use discounted cash flow to calculate a capital budget?

    Learn how discounted cash flows are used in creating capital budgets as a part of the net present value and internal rate ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Small Business

    Capital Budgeting: Which is Better, IRR or NPV?

    Using internal rate of return and net present value for capital budgeting evaluations often end in the same result. But there are times when using NPV to discount cash flows makes more sense.
  2. Investing

    Internal rate of return: An inside look

    The internal rate of return can be used to measure an compare capital projects, stock buyback programs, and investments to determine which will yield the most favorable return.
  3. Small Business

    Calculating IRR with Excel

    Find out how to calculate the internal rate of return on investments using Microsoft Excel, as illustrated in different investment scenarios.
  4. Investing

    Private Equity on Steroids: How Debt Fuels Outsized Returns

    Hot Air: Many private equity firms use a legal technique that can boost returns by 25% or more, Bloomberg says
  5. Investing

    Top 3 Pitfalls Of Discounted Cash Flow Analysis

    Find out why the Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) method can be difficult to apply to real-life valuations.
  6. Small Business

    Capital Budgeting

    Capital budgeting is a planning process used by companies to evaluate which large projects to invest in, and how to finance them. It is sometimes called “investment appraisal.”
  7. Small Business

    How to Calculate NPV Using XNPV Function in Excel

    Learn how to calculate the net present value (NPV) of your investment projects using built-in functions from Excel using the XNPV function.
  8. Insurance

    Get Sale Prices On Healthcare With Discount Plans

    Medical discount plans can help the uninsured or underinsured afford better healthcare.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Internal Rate of Return - IRR

    Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is a metric used in capital budgeting ...
  2. Modified Internal Rate Of Return - MIRR

    While the internal rate of return (IRR) assumes the cash flows ...
  3. Discount Rate

    Discount rate is the interest rate charged to commercial banks ...
  4. Financial Management Rate Of Return - FMRR

    The financial management rate of return is a real estate measure ...
  5. Annuity Method of Depreciation

    The annuity method of depreciation is a process used to calculate ...
  6. Discounted Payback Period

    The discounted payback period is a capital budgeting procedure ...
Trading Center