A:

First, let's review what economic factors must be present in an industry with perfect competition.

5 Requirements of Perfect Competition

  • All firms sell an identical product.
  • All firms are price-takers.
  • All firms have a relatively small market share.
  • Buyers know the nature of the product being sold and the prices charged by each firm.
  • The industry is characterized by freedom of entry and exit.

Because these five requirements rarely exist together in any one industry, perfect competition is rarely (if ever) observed in the real world. For example, most products have some degree of differentiation. Even with a product as simple as bottled water, for example, producers vary in the method of purification, product size, brand identity, etc. Commodities such as raw agricultural products, although they can still differ in terms of quality, come closest to being identical, or having zero differentiation. When a product does come to have zero differentiation, its industry is usually concentrated into a small number of large firms, or an oligopoly.

Barriers to Entry Prohibit Perfect Competition

Many industries also have significant barriers to entry, such as high startup costs (as seen in the auto manufacturing industry) or strict government regulations (as seen in the utilities industry), which limit the ability of firms to enter and exit such industries. And although consumer awareness has increased with the information age, there are still few industries where the buyer remains aware of all available products and prices.

As you can see, there are significant obstacles preventing perfect competition from appearing in today's economy. The agricultural industry probably comes closest to exhibiting perfect competition because it is characterized by many small producers with virtually no ability to alter the selling price of their products. The commercial buyers of agricultural commodities are generally very well-informed and, although agricultural production involves some barriers to entry, it is not particularly difficult to enter the marketplace as a producer.

Economists' Thoughts on Perfect Competition

No economist believes perfect competition is representative of the real world. Very few believe perfect competition is ever achievable. The real debate among economists is whether perfect competition should be considered a theoretical benchmark for real markets. Neoclassical economists argue that perfect competition can be useful, and most of their analysis stems from its principles. Many other smaller schools of thought disagree.

Many economists are highly critical of the neoclassical reliance on perfect competition. These arguments can be broadly separated into two groups. The first group believes the assumptions built into the model are so unrealistic it cannot produce any meaningful insights. The second group argues that perfect competition is not even a desirable theoretical outcome.

Nobel laureate F.A. Hayek argued that perfect competition had no claim to be called "competition." He pointed out that the model removed all competitive activities and reduced all buyers and sellers to mindless price-takers.

Joseph Schumpeter noted that research, development and innovation are undertaken by firms that experience economic profits, rendering perfect competition less efficient than imperfect competition in the long run.

(For related reading, see: Economic Basics: Competition, Monopoly and Oligopoly.)

RELATED FAQS
  1. Are perfect competition models in economics useful?

    Take a look at some of the arguments made by the proponents and critics of the theory of perfect competition in contemporary ... Read Answer >>
  2. What factors influence competition in microeconomics?

    Find out what influences competition in microeconomics and how perfect competition, monopoly and oligopoly vary in their ... Read Answer >>
  3. How does a monopoly contribute to market failure?

    Read a simple overview of the theory of market monopoly, where it originated and some contemporary challenges to the classical ... Read Answer >>
  4. What are the most famous cases of oligopolies?

    Learn about famous examples of oligopolies currently in place in the United States, Canada and worldwide. Explore imperfect ... Read Answer >>
  5. What are the key barriers to entry in electronics?

    Learn how the entry barriers of economies of scale and scope, research and development, capital, and brand loyalty affect ... Read Answer >>
  6. What is a utility stock?

    Investing in difficult economic conditions requires knowledge of different stock classes. Utility stocks are one vehicle ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Perfect Stocks Based on Book Value (HDNG, CLMS)

    Searching for perfection can improve long-term returns.
  2. Investing

    Capital Intensive Companies: What Are The Pros & Cons for Investors?

    Learn about the pros and cons of investing in capital-intensive industries. Find out how barriers to entry and mature industries impact investment outlook.
  3. Investing

    Should You Invest In Agricultural Commodities And Stocks?

    With rising food prices and a booming agricultural industry, we look at whether the current market is a good investment opportunity.
  4. Investing

    Should Water Be Privatized?

    Could water privatization mean lower costs, greater efficiency and higher quality compared to public sector providers? A look at the evidence so far.
  5. Investing

    Great Company Or Growing Industry?

    Look at the big picture when choosing a company - what you see may really be a stage in its industry's growth.
  6. Small Business

    Porter's Five Forces

    Porter’s Five Forces is an analysis scheme created by Harvard Business School professor Michael E. Porter. Using this analysis tool, business managers can gauge the level of competition within ...
  7. Investing

    Rising Prices: Inflation or Quality Improvements?

    Price indices are used to measure inflation, but qualitative improvements in products complicates attempts to isolate the true cause of rising prices.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Imperfect Competition

    Imperfect competition exists whenever a market, hypothetical ...
  2. Perfect Competition

    Pure or perfect competition is a theoretical market structure ...
  3. Monopolistic Competition

    Monopolistic competition characterizes an industry in which many ...
  4. Competitive Pricing

    Competitive pricing is the process of selecting strategic price ...
  5. Barriers to Entry

    Barriers to entry are the costs or other obstacles that prevent ...
  6. Substitute

    A substitute, or substitute good, in economics and consumer theory ...
Trading Center