The tracking error can be an important factor in portfolio management, although investors often overlook this measure for indexed exchange-trade funds (ETF) or mutual funds. All index funds do not perform exactly the same, nor do they all perfectly match up with the index or benchmark they are designed to track. The tracking error is simply the amount by which a fund's return, as indicated by its net asset value (NAV), varies from the actual index return.

The term "tracking error" can be misleading. It is not necessarily a negative, since the deviation from the index can be positive for investors if their chosen fund outperforms the index. However, one of the main reasons for investors to watch for a tracking error is the fact that historical analysis shows that, on average, many more index funds underperform, rather than outperform, the underlying index.

Analysts recommend considering the tracking error as one factor when making the decision of choosing one index fund over another.

How to Calculate the Tracking Error

You may calculate the tracking error by doing a standard deviation percentage calculation. However, a simpler method is to just subtract the index or benchmark return from the portfolio return.

For example, if an index or benchmark gains two percent over the course of a year, but an index mutual fund that tracks the index gains three percent over the same time period, then the tracking error for that mutual fund is one percent.

Variations between index funds can be significant, with one fund outperforming an index by as much as five percent while another fund aimed at tracking the same index may underperform it by almost five percent. Deviations in returns between funds and an underlying index tend to be greater for sector funds as compared to general market funds, such as those that track the S&P 500 Index.

Factors That Can Affect a Tracking Error

The NAV of an index fund is naturally inclined toward being lower than its benchmark because funds have fees, whereas an index does not. A high expense ratio for a fund can have a significantly negative impact on the fund's performance. However, it is possible for fund managers to overcome the negative impact of fund fees and outperform the underlying index by doing an above-average job of portfolio rebalancing, managing dividends or interest payments, or securities lending. The tracking error can be viewed as an indicator of how actively a fund is managed and its corresponding risk level.

Beyond fund fees, a number of other factors can affect a fund's tracking error. One important factor is the extent to which a fund's holdings match the holdings of the underlying index or benchmark. Many funds are made up of just the fund manager's idea of a representative sample of the securities that make up the actual index. Commonly, there are also differences in weighting between a fund's assets and the assets of the index.

Illiquid or thinly traded securities can also increase the chance of a tracking error, since this often leads to prices differing significantly from market price when the fund buys or sells such securities, due to larger bid-ask spreads. Finally, the level of volatility for an index can also affect the tracking error.

  1. How Do I Find Mutual Funds That Track Indexes?

    Two good sources for finding index funds are Fidelity Investments and Vanguard. Read Answer >>
  2. Is it possible to invest in an index?

    While you cannot buy indexes, which are just benchmarks, there are three ways for you to mirror their performance. Read Answer >>
  3. Is tracking error a significant measure for determining ex-post risk?

    Before we answer your question, let's first define tracking error and ex-post risk. Tracking error refers to the amount by ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    3 Reasons Tracking Error Matters

    Discover three ways investors can use tracking error to measure performance for a mutual fund or ETF, whether indexed or actively managed.
  2. Investing

    Calculating Tracking Error

    Tracking error is the difference between the return on a portfolio or fund, and the benchmark it is expected to mirror (or track).
  3. Investing

    ETF Tracking Errors: Protect Your Returns

    Tracking errors tend to be small, but they can still adversely affect your returns. Learn how to protect against them.
  4. Investing

    3 Index Funds with the Lowest Expense Ratios

    Read detailed information about index mutual funds with some of the lowest expense ratios in their categories, and learn about their pros and cons.
  5. Investing

    ETF Tracking Errors: Is Your Fund Falling Short?

    Find out the size and causes of ETF tracking errors and which funds are at risk.
  6. Investing

    5 Things You Need To Know About Index Funds

    Index funds, at their best, offer a low-cost way for investors to track popular stock and bond market indexes. But not all index funds are created equally.
  7. Investing

    Why Index Fund Investing Works

    Over time, index fund investing gained traction and ultimately reshaped the industry. Today, these once obscure funds comprise more than 22 percent of equity mutual fund assets, according to ...
  8. Financial Advisor

    The 4 Best U.S. Equity Index Mutual Funds

    Find out which four index mutual funds are among the best U.S. equities index mutual funds for core holdings in your investment portfolio.
  9. Investing

    Enhanced Index Funds: Can They Deliver Low-Risk Returns?

    These funds may look appealing. Find out whether they can really live up to all of their promises.
  10. Investing

    The Pros and Cons of Indexes

    Learn about the advantages and disadvantages of stock indexes and passive index funds. Discover how there is an opportunity cost to using index funds.
  1. Accounting Error

    An accounting error is an error in an accounting entry that was ...
  2. Active Index Fund

    Active index funds track an index fund with an additional layer ...
  3. Error Of Principle

    An error of principle is an accounting mistake in which an entry ...
  4. Indexing

    In the financial markets, indexing can be used as a statistical ...
  5. Enhanced Indexing

    An investment philosophy that attempts to amplify the returns ...
  6. Index ETF

    Index ETFs are exchange-traded funds that seek to track a benchmark ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Liquidity

    Liquidity is the degree to which an asset or security can be quickly bought or sold in the market without affecting the asset's ...
  2. Federal Funds Rate

    The federal funds rate is the interest rate at which a depository institution lends funds maintained at the Federal Reserve ...
  3. Call Option

    An agreement that gives an investor the right (but not the obligation) to buy a stock, bond, commodity, or other instrument ...
  4. Standard Deviation

    A measure of the dispersion of a set of data from its mean, calculated as the square root of the variance. The more spread ...
  5. Entrepreneur

    An entrepreneur is an individual who founds and runs a small business and assumes all the risk and reward of the venture.
  6. Money Market

    The money market is a segment of the financial market in which financial instruments with high liquidity and very short maturities ...
Trading Center