A:

United States Steel Corportation (NYSE:X) was the world's first company to surpass the market capitalization mark of $1 billion dollars. In the early 1900s, John Piermont Morgan wanted to do for steel what he had done in railroads. The only problem was that Andrew Carnegie controlled the biggest and most efficient producer of steel, Carnegie Steel. Morgan worked with Charles Schwab to convince Carnagie to sell his business into the new entity envisioned by Morgan, U.S. Steel. Carnegie, already pondering retirement, agreed to sell to the Morgan-headed trust for an overall price of about $492 million in stocks and bonds of the new company. Carnegie went on to focus on philanthropy while Schwab necame the president of U.S. Steel.

Unfortunately for Schwab, U.S. Steel was an ungainly welding of mediocre businesses onto Carnegie Steel's lean frame. To bring the rest of the company up to snuff, U.S. Steel needed to raise huge amounts of capital. In 1901, Morgan issued $303 million in mortgage bonds, $510 million in preferred stock, and $508 million in common stock – creating a total capitalization of approximately $1.4 billion - on a company with real assets of $682 million. Thus, half of its worth was goodwill, but the public bought into the overvalued securities.

U.S. Steel would never fulfill its potential and, although Schwab's management postponed the reckoning, saw its market share eaten up by hungrier companies, including Schwab's Bethlehem Steel, formed when he left U.S. Steel in frustration. In fact, one of the owners of U.S. Steel's dissapointing shares was Benjamin Graham's widowed mother. Watching the family's wealth shrink with the shares might have motivated the intelligent investor to focus on hard assets and intrinsic value, discounting egregious amounts of goodwill. (Read more about the famous J.P. Morgan in our article, The Kingpin Of Wall Street: J.P. Morgan.)

This question was answered by Andrew Beattie.

RELATED FAQS
  1. What are the most famous instances of backward integration?

    Learn more about backward integration in the supply chain and see how two famous examples, Carnegie Steel and Apple, used ... Read Answer >>
  2. Which commodities are the main input materials for the automotive sector?

    Explore the materials used by automakers to create modern cars and trucks. Find out more about the materials market as it ... Read Answer >>
  3. What raw materials do auto manufacturers use?

    Learn about some of the raw materials required for auto manufacturing, including iron for steel, aluminum, rubber, and petroleum ... Read Answer >>
  4. What are Common Examples of Monopolistic Markets?

    Providers of water, natural gas, telecommunications, and electricity have all been historically monopolistic markets. A monopoly ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    How China Impacts the Global Steel Industry

    The Chinese economy is having a significant impact on the performance and profitability of steel and mining stocks.
  2. Insights

    United States Steel Upgraded By JPMorgan (X)

    Shares of U.S. Steel climbed as much as 4.22% Monday, reaching a session high of $19.75 after the company's shares were endorsed by analysts at JPMorgan.
  3. Investing

    Top 4 Steel Stocks for 2018

    Trump's plan to impose tariffs on steel imports and use U.S. steel for all new pipelines and pipeline repairs, positions these four steel stocks for gains.
  4. Small Business

    How Did Andrew Carnegie Get Rich?

    Andrew Carnegie rose from poverty to become one of the world's wealthiest men and the creator of the first billion-dollar corporation, U.S. Steel.
  5. Investing

    Trump's Wall Could Be Great News for Steel Stocks

    So Trump signed the order for the Wall. Some industries stand to gain. A lot.
  6. Investing

    Steel Stocks Reach 52-Week Highs on Trump Rally (AKS, NUE)

    Several steel manufacturers soared to 52-week highs on Tuesday, as did the Market Vectors Steel ETF.
  7. Investing

    U.S. Steel Earnings Coming Up, What to Expect (X)

    U.S. Steel comes highly recommended, according to Barron's, which expects the stock to reach $37 per share in 12 months.
  8. Investing

    AK Steel Stock Get Downgraded by Jefferies (AKS)

    One would need fortitude as strong as steel to invest in steel stocks over the past month.
  9. Insights

    The Giants of Finance: Andrew Carnegie

    Though not as well-remembered as some of his contemporaries, Andrew Carnegie's legacy is strong and moralistic.
  10. Insights

    Is Now the Time to Buy Steel Dynamics? (STLD)

    After 15% declines over the past three months, it certainly seems as if the risk-versus-reward profile of Steel Dynamics has drastically improved.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Akio Mimura

    Akio Mimura served as chairman and president of Nippon Steel ...
  2. Delivery Instrument

    A delivery instrument is a document given to the holder of a ...
  3. Anti-Dumping Duty

    Anti-dumping duty is a protectionist tariff that a government ...
  4. Commodity Price Risk

    Commodity price risk is price uncertainty that adversely impacts ...
  5. Goodwill To Assets Ratio

    The goodwill to assets ratio is a ratio that measures how much ...
  6. David Tepper

    David Tepper, a co-founder of Appaloosa Management L.P., is among ...
Trading Center