The “three-legged stool” is an old phrase that many financial planners once used to describe the three most common sources of retirement income: Social Security, employee pensions, and personal savings. It was expected that this trio would together provide a solid financial foundation for the senior years. None of the three was expected to support most retirees on its own.
Times have changed, though, and so has the three-legged stool.
- The “three-legged stool” is an old term for the trio of common sources of retirement income: Social Security, pensions, and personal savings.
- One leg of the stool, pensions, has been replaced by defined-contribution plans that place the investment burden on the individual.
- Another leg of the stool, Social Security, is looking rickety, with predictions that the system could be bankrupt by 2035.
A New Leg to the Stool
For younger workers in the private sector, the pension leg has mostly been replaced. Instead of pensions, also called “defined-benefit plans,” which were funded by a combination of company and employee contributions, workers now have 401(k) and other defined-contribution plans, also known as retirement savings accounts.
Originally, 401(k)s and other retirement savings plans were never meant to serve as a pension; they were to be supplementary savings accounts, building up the third leg of the stool. Nevertheless, ever since the 1990s, employers have been systemically saving themselves money and financial responsibility by replacing the guaranteed corporate pension with these tax-advantaged plans. Some companies will match the employee contribution up to a certain percentage, but many do not even offer that degree of assistance.
Traditional pensions, officially known as defined-benefit plans, guarantee a given amount of monthly income in retirement and place the investment and longevity risk on the plan provider. Defined-contribution plans, such as 401(k)s, place the investment and longevity risk on individual employees, asking them to choose their own retirement investments with no guaranteed minimum or maximum benefits.
The State of Social Security
As for Social Security, the 2019 Annual Report of the Board of Trustees of the Federal Old-Age and Survivors Insurance and Federal Disability Insurance Trust Funds, warned that the Social Security trust fund could run dry within two decades at the current rate of output: “Under the Trustees’ intermediate assumptions, OASDI cost is projected to exceed total income starting in 2020, and the dollar level of the hypothetical combined trust fund reserves declines until reserves become depleted in 2035."
Of course, the emphasis is on the hypothetical; the projection does not take into account changes to the system, such as later retirement ages, which are already being implemented, and it is unlikely that the U.S. government will let a meltdown happen without stepping in. The projections also do not account for rising interest rates, increased revenue, or several other factors. Nevertheless, it is a date that still causes concern. Workers in the United States can go online and review their Social Security accounts to see how much in benefits they receive at early retirement, full retirement, and age 70.
The percentage of your paycheck that financial advisors recommend regularly investing in a retirement savings account.
Personal Savings for Retirement Remain Low
That leaves our third leg, personal savings. Savings rates have been extremely low for U.S. workers over the last decade—recessions and stagnant wages have made it tough to put money aside. Nevertheless, with the rest of the stool looking wobbly, individuals will need to start saving a larger portion of their income and continue to utilize tax-advantaged retirement plans such as IRAs and annuities to build their retirement nest eggs.
Financial advisors recommend earmarking at least one-fifth of your annual earnings for retirement. The earlier you start, the better set up you are to take advantage of compounding investment returns. At the very least, advisors recommend contributing enough to your 401(k) to max out the employer match, if your employer offers one.
The Bottom Line
With pensions being replaced by retirement savings accounts, we're almost down to a two-legged stool—not something you could actually rest on securely. The government has debated possible solutions to Americans' retirement-savings issues, including hybrid pension plans, creating national or state-level retirement savings plans for people who do not have one offered through their work and even opening up the federal Thrift Savings Plan (a defined-contribution plan, currently available to government employees and those in uniformed service) to all Americans. It is also weighing options to prop up Social Security, and ensuring it doesn't run out of funds.
In the meantime, it may help to think of tax-advantaged retirement plans as the stool's second leg and work on building up the third leg with other savings, including investments such as real estate. Or maybe we just need a new metaphor.