Best Return of Premium Life Insurance

AAA Offers High Limit Life Insurance

We publish unbiased product reviews; our opinions are our own and are not influenced by payment we receive from our advertising partners. Learn more about how we review products and read our advertiser disclosure for how we make money.

Term life insurance is only valid for a specific period of time and once the timeline is over, you lose coverage and your premiums are gone. Fortunately, it is possible to purchase a specific type of term life insurance coverage that won’t leave you empty-handed when your policy expires. With return of premium (ROP) life insurance, you’ll pay a flat rate for the duration of your policy, but you’ll get all your money back at the end of the term.

The best return of premium life insurance is offered from reputable providers with high financial strength ratings and overall positive reviews. These companies offer policies with varying terms and policy limits as well as guaranteed death benefits and convertible policies. 

The 5 Best Return of Premium Life Insurance of 2021

Best for High Coverage Limits : AAA Life Insurance Company


AAA Life Insurance

AAA Life Insurance

  • AM Best Rating: A
  • Plans: 7
  • Issue Ages: Up to 85
Why We Chose It

AAA offers a return of premium life insurance rider in amounts up to $5 million+, which makes it a good option for families with considerable income and assets.

Pros and Cons
Pros
  • Term coverage with return of premium from $100,000 to $5 million+

  • Terms between 15 and 30 years

  • AAA membership is not required

Cons
  • Speak with an agent to get a quote

  • No additional riders available with this coverage

  • Health screening will be required

Overview

We chose AAA Life Insurance Company as best for high coverage limits based on the fact that they offer return of premium life insurance coverage in amounts up to $5 million+. Founded in 1902, AAA started its journey by fighting for better roads. This led to the creation of AAA’s auto clubs, which are well known for offering award-winning roadside assistance options. These days, AAA offers a variety of products to its customers, ranging from auto insurance to life insurance and homeowners insurance.

When it comes to their return of premium life insurance coverage, AAA Life lets you choose from 15, 20, or 30-year terms. No additional riders are available with this type of coverage, but you can purchase up to $5 million+ in term life insurance with the promise of having your premiums returned.

You don’t have to be an AAA member to apply for life insurance with this provider. Note that, once you apply for coverage, receiving it is not instant as there is an underwriting and screening process.

Unfortunately, you will have to answer health questions and take a health exam in order to qualify. AAA Life is also lacking when it comes to allowing consumers to get a free quote online. You’ll have to speak with an agent to apply and find out how much you’ll pay for coverage.

Read the full review: AAA Life Insurance Company

Best Personalized Experience : Cincinnati Life Insurance


Cincinnati Life Insurance

 Cincinnati Life Insurance

  • AM Best Rating: A+
  • Plans: Multiple
  • Issue Ages: Contact agent
Why We Chose It

Cincinnati Life Insurance stands out with best personalized experience because you work with a licensed agent in your area who can provide you with a personalized, tailored experience without a pressured sales pitch.

Pros and Cons
Pros
  • Return of premium policies are offered for 20-, 25-, or 30-year terms

  • Personalized agent experience.

Cons
  • You cannot get a quote without speaking with an agent and providing your personal information

  • Return of premium is only guaranteed for the base premium of your policy

  • Medical exam required

Overview

While Cincinnati Life Insurance isn’t as well known as some of the providers on our list, this provider can be a good option if you prefer to buy insurance from an agent instead of an online portal. With the help of an agent, you can determine the exact amount of return of premium coverage you need with the ideal term, and you can receive assistance as you walk through the application process. The company prides itself on making sure each new customer has a positive experience with a no-pressure sales approach.

Cincinnati Insurance Companies date back to 1950, and they have grown their influence and financial strength since then. For example, Cincinnati Life Insurance boasts an A+ rating for financial strength from AM Best. Don't let the regional name fool you; Cincinnati Life is available in many places with headquarters in Fairfield, Ohio.

Term life insurance coverage is available from Cincinnati Life Insurance in 10-, 15-, 20-, 25-, or 30-year terms. However, you’ll need to speak with an agent to talk over your options and apply for a quote. Cincinnati Life doesn’t offer any meaningful information on their policies on their website, which makes it difficult for you to shop around.

Best for Longer Terms : Assurity Life Insurance


Assurity Life Insurance

Assurity Life Insurance

  • AM Best Rating: A-
  • Plans: 3+
  • Issue Ages: Contact agent
Why We Chose It

Assurity Life Insurance is ideal if you want a longer term of 20 or 30 years with return of premium protection to insure yourself in your most vulnerable years.

Pros and Cons
Pros
  • Get premium payments back if you outlive your policy

  • Agent provides you with a personalized quote

  • You can convert your policy to a permanent policy

Cons
  • Shorter term coverage isn’t available if you want return of premium

  • Not available in New York

Overview

Because Assurity Life Insurance only offers return of premium coverage for policies that last for 20 or 30 years, this provider is our top pick for ROP coverage for longer terms. Fortunately, you won’t be pursuing coverage from a fly-by-night insurance provider. With a long history that dates back to 1890, Assurity Life Insurance has stood the test of time. This company also has strong ratings for financial strength, including an A- rating from AM Best. 

Term policies from Assurity Life Insurance offer the option to convert your policy to permanent life insurance, which is a major plus. Their return of premium policies also come with a level premium and a guaranteed death benefit your family can count on. 

In terms of potential downsides, Assurity Life Insurance only offers two choices of terms for their ROP policies. Also know that you’ll need to answer health questions and pass a medical exam to qualify.

Best for Building Cash Value to Borrow Against : State Farm


State Farm

State Farm

  • AM Best Rating: A++
  • Plans: 10
  • Issue Ages: Up to 75
Why We Chose It

State Farm lets you purchase term life insurance coverage with a return of premium benefit, and you get the chance to build cash value you can borrow against in a pinch.

Pros and Cons
Pros
  • Term coverage for 20 or 30 years with return of premium

  • Convert policy to permanent life insurance up to age 75

  • Apply for a free quote online

  • Customize your policy with additional riders

  • Qualify for a multi-policy discount

Cons
  • Only two terms for return of premium coverage

  • Not available in Massachusetts or Wisconsin

Overview

State Farm return of premium life insurance policies build cash value you can borrow against, which is a feature frequently attributed to whole life insurance policies. This provider has also been around since 1922, and they have a strong history of financial strength and integrity. While originally started as an auto insurance provider, State Farm now offers more than 100 products and services including homeowners insurance, banking products, investments, and more.The fact that State Farm boasts an A++ rating for financial strength from AM best should also give you peace of mind and provides the kind of stability that makes State Farm best for building cash value you can borrow against.

State Farm is one of the few providers who lets consumers apply for a free quote online. Their return of premium policies are available for 20 years or 30 years, and you can customize them to meet your needs with additional riders for children or waiver of premium in the event of a disability.

According to State Farm, a 25-year-old woman in Illinois could buy a term policy worth $250,000 with the return of premium coverage starting at $49.59 per month, whereas a 30-year policy in the same amount would start at $51.77 per month. Note that State Farm isn’t licensed to sell life insurance in Massachusetts or Wisconsin, so you’ll need to look for another provider if you live in one of these states.

Read the full review: State Farm Life Insurance

Best Convertible Coverage : Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance


Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

 Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance

  • AM Best Rating: A
  • Plans: 3+
  • Issue Ages: Contact agent
Why We Chose It

Indiana Farm Bureau policies let you convert to a paid-up permanent life insurance policy or a partially paid-up permanent policy if you wish. While many providers let you convert term coverage to permanent, Indiana Farm Bureau’s partially paid-up conversion option is unique because you can receive part of your premiums back in cash.

Pros and Cons
Pros
  • Convert your policy to permanent insurance

  • Choose from a 20-year or 30-year term

Cons
  • You cannot apply for a free quote online

  • Offices are not available nationwide

  • Medical exam required

Overview

Indiana Farm Bureau policies come with some unique options when it comes to converting your coverage. When you buy a return of premium policy and your term ends, you can receive all the premiums you paid back on a tax-free basis. However, you can also select to use your premiums for a paid-up permanent life insurance policy, or you can get part of your premiums back and use the rest to pay for permanent coverage. All of this makes the company our choice for best convertible coverage.

Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance has been around since 1934, so they have a long company history. In addition to life insurance, they also offer homeowners insurance, auto insurance, umbrella policies, and coverage for your business. The company has an A rating from AM Best for financial stability.

In terms of their return of premium life insurance policies, you have the option to buy this term coverage for 20 or 30 years. As a potential downside, you should note that you do have to work with an agent to get a quote for a return of premium insurance policy, and a medical exam will be required.

Final Verdict

All of the providers on our list offer the best returns of premium life insurance. They are all reputable companies with strong financial standings and industry experience. Some companies provide online quotes and others offer high coverage limits. Some offer personalized experiences with knowledgeable agents. Overall, we recommend checking out AAA. You don’t need to be a member to get a policy and they offer competitive rates on term coverage with return of premiums up to $5 million.

Compare the Best Return of Premium Life Insurance

  Company   AM Best Rating Coverage Capacity    Issue Ages Premiums    Policies Offered
AAA A $5 million Up to 85 Vary Term, whole, universal, and accident
Cincinnati Life Insurance  A+ Contact agent Contact agent  Contact agent Term, whole, and universal
Assurity Life Insurance  A- Contact agent Contact agent $120+/month Term, whole, and universal
StateFarm  A++ Contact agent Up to 75 $49.59+/month Term, whole, and universal
Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance  A Contact agent Contact agent Contact agent Term, whole, and final expense

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Return of Premium Life Insurance?

Return of premium life insurance works almost exactly how the name implies. You can buy this coverage in various terms, usually 10 to 30 years, and you’ll pay a flat premium during that time. 

But your money doesn’t disappear once your policy duration ends. When your term life insurance policy ends, all the premiums you put into the policy will be paid back to you in a lump sum.

This transforms return of premium life insurance riders into a forced savings product of sorts. You’ll pay higher premiums for this type of coverage than you would for traditional term life insurance, but you’ll have the benefit of getting your premiums back when your policy ends. Also be aware that some return of premium policies build cash value you may be able to borrow against. 

Do You Get Your Money Back If You Cancel Return of Premium Insurance?

If you decide to surrender your return of premium life insurance policy before the term ends, you may or may not receive part of your premiums back. It all depends on the insurance provider you select and the terms their policies include. Generally speaking, however, you’re more likely to get your premiums back the longer you have owned your policy. Many providers do not offer any return of premium within the first few years. 

How Much Does Return of Premium Life Insurance Cost?

The cost of a return of premium life insurance policy is typically 30% more than traditional term life insurance coverage. However, you do get your premiums back when your term expires, so that doesn’t mean this coverage is a poor value.

That may seem like a big increase, but keep in mind how your policy will play out over 20 years. With traditional term coverage, you would still pay thousands in life insurance premiums over the course of the term, but you wouldn’t have anything to show for it after 20 years.

With a return of premium policy, on the other hand, you would pay more, but you would get all of your money back if you outlive your policy. 

Is Return of Premium Life Insurance Worth It?

Only you can decide if paying a higher premium is worth it to get your money back when your policy ends. However, these policies can be great if you don’t mind the extra premium amount and you can afford it.

In some ways, return of premium life insurance is almost like a savings account that comes with free life insurance.

Just keep in mind that you could also pay for a traditional term policy without a return of premium rider and invest the difference instead. This option could leave you further ahead, but you would have to have the discipline to invest the savings instead of spending it elsewhere in your budget.

How much difference could it make? Considering the examples above with a $250,000 policy for 20 years, you could be left with an additional $8 per month to invest if you choose a traditional term policy without a return of premium rider. If you invested $8 per month for 20 years and earned a return of 6%, you would have $3,531.42. That’s more than the difference you would pay between a traditional term policy and one with a return of premium rider ($1,920), but you do have to pay taxes on investment returns, whereas life insurance proceeds are not taxed.

What Should I Do When Buying Insurance?

If you've decided that return of premium life insurance is a good fit for you, the next step is to locate an insurance carrier and policy that suits your individual needs. Finding the right insurance plan will likely require a bit of research on your part.

In addition to keeping an eye out for any potential discounts, you'll need to compare the offerings of different insurance companies to ensure you're getting the best policy for your money. When determining how much money your dependents will need, it's crucial to consider factors like your total debt, how large a payout would be needed to be to replace your current income over a certain period of time, anticipated financial needs like children's college tuition, and if others in your family (such as an income-earning spouse) may also need to be insured.

During a recent interview with Andrew Mais, Connecticut Insurance Commissioner, he said "So, as you go to buy insurance, if you have questions, ask. We've got people who love to talk to you about insurance, which—if you're at a cocktail party—we may not be the people you want to hang out with. But if you're looking for info, you come to us because it's so much easier. We've got publications and info on our websites. This is where I think your state insurance departments are just so strong, so helpful and can do so much for consumers." The National Association of Insurance Commissioners offers a comprehensive map of each state's insurance department contact information.

Most insurance companies require new applicants to chose either "male" or "female" when applying for insurance, and don't always offer an option for those who identify as nonbinary or transgendered. While being nonbinary doesn't disqualify you from getting insurance, you should be aware that most insurance companies haven't updated their underwriting processes to reflect an awareness of gender issues.

Methodology

Few insurance companies advertise return of premium life insurance coverage, yet we were able to find quality companies that offer ROP insurance with flexible terms. We compared providers in terms of their financial strength and the options available in terms of customizing your policy. We also gave preference to return of premium life insurance that is convertible to permanent life insurance or builds cash value. Finally, we looked for life insurance providers who make it easy to get a free quote online.

Article Sources

Investopedia requires writers to use primary sources to support their work. These include white papers, government data, original reporting, and interviews with industry experts. We also reference original research from other reputable publishers where appropriate. You can learn more about the standards we follow in producing accurate, unbiased content in our editorial policy.
  1. AM Best. "AM Best Upgrades Issuer Credit Ratings of Cincinnati Financial Corp and Its P/C Members; Upgrades Ratings of Life Ins Sub." Accessed December 22, 2020.

  2. AM Best. "A.M. Best Affirms Ratings of Affiliates of Security Mutual Life and Lincoln Ins. Group, Inc.; Revises Outlook to Positive." Accessed December 22, 2020.

  3. AM Best. "AM Best Affirms Credit Ratings of State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company and Most of Its Subsidiaries." Accessed December 22, 2020.

  4. AM Best. "AM Best Upgrades Credit Ratings of United Farm Bureau of Indiana Group Members." Accessed December 22, 2020.

  5. Policy Genius. "Compare, buy, & learn about return of premium life insurance." Accessed December 22, 2020.

  6. Investopedia. "Taking the Mystery Out of Life Insurance." Accessed December 22, 2020.