Market Moves

U.S. stocks jumped higher in price to start the trading session today while bond prices fell, marking a cautious optimism about the potential for the market to rally in the days to come. However, throughout the trading session, several key signs emerged to hint that investors are indeed quite cautious still. While several of the day's market bellwether stocks closed higher than they opened, many showed signs of late session selling and, in many cases, traded on the lowest volume in a month.

These signs of nervousness were clearly on display in the market for U.S. Treasury bonds. The iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT), which has seen a stunning run since Aug. 1, showed a significant gap down in price to start the trading day. Such a move would likely signal that investors were not as worried this week as they have been the previous two weeks. However, as the trading session wore on, the price of bonds increased, demonstrating that many investors remain unconvinced that stocks can rebound from recent drops.

Chart showing the performance of the iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond ETF (TLT)

Bellwether Stocks Display Conflict Between Buyers and Sellers

Broad market indexes and bellwether stocks all gapped higher to begin today's trading session. Of the top 25 stocks that most heavily influence the stock market's major sector indexes, the four whose shares showed the best returns for the day were Netflix, Inc. (NFLX), Dow Inc. (DOW), Apple, Inc. (AAPL), and The Home Depot, Inc. (HD). Although these were the leading stocks for the day, the price action they displayed by the day's close gave pause to those who might think the day's action was so very bullish after all.

With the exception of Home Depot, these stocks traded on the lowest volume in a month. Even Home Depot volume is suspect considering that the company reports earnings tomorrow and the rise in volume is likely attributable to that event alone. All four stocks showed a retreat from the day's high in a narrow trading range after the open. Apple shares actually closed lower than they opened.

This price dynamic may simply be a function of investors calming down after the past two week period of increased volatility. However, there may also be a more pessimistic explanation. Investors who show so little conviction for buying shares after they have been pushed measurably lower may be tipping their hand that they are too nervous to create a sustained rally in stocks over the weeks ahead.

Chart showing the share price performance of bellwether stocks

Read more:

Gold Stocks that Outperform Gold

If stock and bond investors are showing their tendency toward nervousness, then the price of gold may be worth keeping an eye on. The SPDR Gold Shares (GLD) has performed well since the last week in May, so it is natural to expect that gold mining company stocks would also show strong performance. In fact, some have performed better than the price of gold, while others have not (see chart below)

Chart showing the performance of numerous gold stocks vs. gold prices

The Bottom Line

Monday's market performance started with an optimism that diminished throughout the trading day. Investors appear to be conflicted in their desires to buy up the dips, divest from stocks, or simply wait on the sidelines. Gold prices fell, although they remain in an uptrend, while bond prices seem to indicate that, despite the recent run-up in prices, investors are still interested in hedging against the stock market.

Enjoy this article? Get more by signing up for the Chart Advisor newsletter.