Gold vs. Bitcoin: An Overview
Analysts and amateur economists love to sound alarms over a looming recession. The Great Recession of the 2000s was followed a decade later by the COVID-19 recession, one of the shortest in history. The reoccurrence of recessions has renewed the interest investors have in making sure they lose as little as possible if a recession hits.
As an investor, you'd traditionally hold a portion of your portfolio in precious metals like gold. This provides a hedge against the losses stocks can take during a downward economic trend. This has proven effective and still is—but a new alternative is challenging this old-school capital preservation method. Bitcoin is proving to be an interesting asset for investors because it has been around long enough to gain recognition and support—it is even showing a few trends.
- Gold has been an asset that holds value over long periods and is used to hedge against market downturns.
- Bitcoin is young and unproven as an investment, but cryptocurrency speculators are using it to store value and hedge against corrections and recessions.
- Which one is a better investment depends on your risk tolerance, investing goals, strategy, and how much capital you can handle losing.
Bitcoin launched in 2009—the decentralized technology ushered in a new era in finance and investing. Initially, these digital currencies were only attractive to a few niche enthusiasts. In 2010, early speculators discovered the Bitcoins they had previously purchased for fractions of a cent had grown to $0.09 per Bitcoin. Large-scale Bitcoin mining farms and pools became popular, and cryptocurrency exchanges emerged.
When the Covid-19 pandemic began to shut down economies worldwide in 2020, speculators and investors noticed that Bitcoin's value wasn't falling alongside stock values. They started pouring capital into it, institutional investors continued looking for ways to create investment instruments and funds from it, and its price soared—by April 2021, Bitcoin's price hit $61,000.
Investors and speculators began to use Bitcoin in a buy-and-hold strategy as its price fluctuated wildly over 2021, hoping it would maintain value as the pandemic continued.
Gold historically performs well during market corrections because it maintains its value; its price holds somewhat steady, then tends to rise as investors move from stocks to gold if a recession is threatening. This makes it useful as a hedge—an investment that moves opposite another—against market corrections or recessions.
During the Covid-19 pandemic, not all investors turned to Bitcoin; many followed traditional strategies and transitioned to gold. As a result, gold's price skyrocketed from just below $1,300 in late 2019 to nearly $2,100 in mid-2020. Through 2021, its price dropped as economies slowly recovered, but it still averaged higher than pre-pandemic recession levels.
Gold has dominated the economies and markets for thousands of years as a means of exchange and holding wealth. Bitcoin was launched in 2009 and only achieved widespread recognition several years later. Other key differences can provide clues into which one you might want to include in your portfolio.
|Regulations||Depends on the country||Some restrictions|
|Utility||The number of uses is growing||Used across many industries and products|
|Liquidity||Depends on the market||Depends on market and type of asset|
|Volatility||Started 2021 at $32,222, rose to a high of $69,000, closed the year at $46,211.||Started 2021 at $1,943 an ounce, dropped to a yearly low of $1,683, ended year at $1,805.|
Gold’s established system for trading, weighing, and tracking is pristine. It’s very hard to steal or fake; it's also highly regulated. In many countries, you cannot cross borders while carrying gold without regulatory permission. When investing in gold, you'll generally only be able to purchase it from registered dealers and brokers; one caveat is that you should only buy physical gold if you can safely store it.
Bitcoin is also difficult to steal and fake, thanks to its encrypted and decentralized system. It is generally legal to use across the borders of different countries, with a few exceptions. However, the regulatory infrastructure that could exist to ensure that users are safe is not yet in place—the anonymous nature of cryptocurrency also makes it challenging to regulate.
Gold has historically been used in many applications—currency, luxury items, specialized applications in dentistry, electronics, and much more. This cross-functional utility has given gold its ability to maintain value when other asset values fall.
Bitcoin is limited in its utility. It is currently only used as a digital currency and a speculative investment. However, there is an emerging financial technology whose concept is to use cryptocurrency for financial transactions called decentralized finance. Bitcoin has utility in this emerging tech as a form of lending, borrowing, and possibly more. It also has the potential to be involved in nearly as many applications as gold—but following the same line of thought, it has just as much potential to become useless and invaluable.
One primary concern for investors looking toward Bitcoin as a haven is its liquidity. Cryptocurrencies are generally very liquid assets; however, this may not always be the case. There are times when it might be more liquid than other assets and times when it isn't.
If you're looking for an asset that you can quickly move in and out of without losing value in a short time (like Bitcoin can), gold might be a better option. It is a much more liquid asset and can allow you to reallocate your portfolio quicker when the market fluctuates.
For example, if you had several hundred Bitcoin, you might have a hard time liquidating them if you wanted to get out of cryptocurrency in a hurry—exchanges such as Coinbase only allow for $50,000 liquidation of cryptocurrency per day. If Bitcoin's price is higher than the daily limit allowed by your exchange, you'll only be able to do it in smaller increments. If you don't own many Bitcoins, it might be a much more liquid asset for you. Additionally, if the market swings wildly and many investors begin selling their Bitcoin, its price would drop dramatically in response.
Bitcoin has historically proven to be subject to the media effect, investor sentiment, regulatory actions, and hype. News from the digital currency sphere could prompt investors to panic and make quick decisions, quickly sending Bitcoin's price upward or downward. This volatility is not inherent to gold for the reasons mentioned above, making it perhaps a safer asset.
In recent years, several alternative cryptocurrencies have been launched which aim to provide more stability than Bitcoin. These coins are called "stablecoins" because their prices are pegged to fiat currency or another stable asset. For instance, Tether is linked to the value of the U.S. dollar.
Whether Bitcoin is a better investment than gold boils down to your investment goals, whether you enjoy speculating, your risk tolerance, and how much capital you can stand to lose if the market turns. A financial advisor can help you create investing goals and decide whether Bitcoin is a good investment for you.
Is Bitcoin Rarer Than Gold?
Gold is one of the more rare metals. Bitcoin is rare compared to other cryptocurrencies, and gold is rare compared to other metals. They are both rare in their respective categories.
Is Bitcoin Like Gold?
Bitcoin is similar to gold in that it has become an alternate investment for some investors. It has the potential for many uses and can be a worthwhile investment if used in the right strategy.
Is Bitcoin a Better Investment Than Gold?
Which is better depends upon your risk tolerance, investing strategy, how much capital you have to use, and how much you can tolerate losing. Bitcoin is much more volatile than gold, making it a riskier investment than gold.
Investing in cryptocurrencies and other Initial Coin Offerings (“ICOs”) is highly risky and speculative, and this article is not a recommendation by Investopedia or the writer to invest in cryptocurrencies or other ICOs. Since each individual's situation is unique, a qualified professional should always be consulted before making any financial decisions. Investopedia makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or timeliness of the information contained herein.
The Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis. "Gold Fixing Price 10:30 A.M. (London time) in London Bullion Market, based in U.S. Dollars."
U.S. Department of State - Bureau of Consular Affairs. "Customs and Restrictions."
Coinbase. "What Are the Limits on Coinbase Pro?"
What Is Bitcoin? How to Mine, Buy, and Use It
How Bitcoin Works
How to Buy Bitcoin
What are the Safest Ways to Store Bitcoin?
How Does Bitcoin Mining Work?
How to Pay with Cryptocurrency
Bitcoin vs. Credit Card Transactions: What's the Difference?
Benefits and Risks of Trading Forex With Bitcoin
Cryptocurrency IRAs: Advantages and Disadvantages
Gold vs. Bitcoin: Which Is Better?
How Much of All Money Is in Bitcoin?