Student loans can sometimes feel like a scam. In January 2022, Navient, one of the largest student loan providers, reached a $1.85 billion settlement with 38 states and the District of Columbia following claims that it made predatory student loans. It was embroiled in lawsuits and allegations from several states and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).
The company will cancel the outstanding balance on $1.7 billion in subprime private student loan balances owed by over 66,000 borrowers nationwide.
While the worst student loan companies may behave like scammers, there are also actual student loan forgiveness scams that borrowers may encounter. When loan holders seek help with some aspects of their loans, like reducing their balance or monthly payment, repaying their loans faster, stopping payments temporarily, or getting loans out of delinquent status, student loan scammers may make it difficult for them to get actual help.
Here are the worst and most common student loan scams you might encounter and how to identify them so you won’t get your money stolen or your credit trashed.
- Scammers often try to take advantage of student loan borrowers.
- You don’t have to pay anyone to make changes to your student loans.
- The Department of Education provides and processes applications for income-driven repayment, consolidation, deferment, and forbearance for free and also provides free guidance on how to complete the paperwork.
- Don’t believe companies that say they can reduce or eliminate your student loan debt, and don’t give them any money.
- Ignore unsolicited requests for personal information that appear to come from student loan providers.
Scam #1: Filling out Forms for a Fee
Do you want to lower your monthly student loan payment to an amount you can afford based on your income? You can pay someone to complete an income-based repayment plan request for you, but you can also fill out the application yourself.
Paying for the Help You Need vs. Getting Scammed
It's totally up to you if you choose to pay someone to complete these forms. Keep in mind that you do have the option to complete them for free, but some companies have taken advantage of borrowers who don’t understand their options. They’ve charged them for help without explaining the free alternative.
Consider a similar situation regarding a potential tax refund. You may prepare your taxes on your own for free, or you may pay a preparer to help pull your return together. In either case, your financial situation is the exact same and your tax standing is not impacted by whether you've paid a preparer or not.
Some people find the process confusing and time-consuming, so they hire a tax accountant, visit their local tax preparation store, or pay for tax software. They might find that the service pays for itself in the time and frustration it saves them and that they might even owe less in taxes—more than offsetting the tax prep fee they choose to pay—by getting professional help.
In either case, paying an advisor regarding your student loans does not limit your options regarding loan payments.
Free Repayment Options and Loan Consolidation
Legitimate services exist to help borrowers evaluate their student loan repayment options and apply for the program that best suits their needs. It is possible to make costly mistakes when repaying your student loans.
To avoid getting scammed, it’s important to know that paying to apply for deferment, forbearance, or a different repayment plan is optional. Neither the federal government nor the private companies that service (collect payments) on student loans charge borrowers money to request different loan terms.
The same is true of federal student loan consolidation. You can complete and submit the student loan consolidation application yourself for free. Private student loan consolidation does not exist, but you may be able to combine several private student loans into one and lower your interest rate with a refinance.
Any loan fees associated with refinancing will not be charged until your loan is finalized and are usually deducted automatically from your loan proceeds. You don’t have to pay anything upfront.
Scam #2: Getting Loans Forgiven, Canceled, Discharged, Reduced, or Eliminated for a Fee
Who wouldn’t love to have their debt erased? Unfortunately, the reality is that when you borrow money, you almost always have to repay it in full—with interest. Even if you die, your estate may have to repay your debt (or any taxes on forgiven debt) before any assets you left behind can be distributed to your heirs.
Between the way that borrowing laws and tax laws are written, it’s safe to assume that if a company promises to negotiate a student loan debt settlement on your behalf, it’s a scam. If they say they can help you get your student loans discharged in bankruptcy, don’t believe it. They also can’t get your debt eliminated by representing you in a lawsuit against your student loan company.
Scams in this area typically involve telling the borrower that if they pay a large sum to some company, the company will get their loan discharged. In some cases, they might tell the borrower to send their student loan payments directly to the company instead of to their student loan servicer.
Either way, the result is likely to be that the company takes the borrower’s money and the borrower falls behind on their loan. They end up owing even more because of the additional interest and late fees that accrue, and their credit scores may drop when the loan servicer reports the late payments to the credit bureaus.
Public Service Loan Forgiveness (Not a Scam)
Public Service Loan Forgiveness may apply to certain federal loans in limited circumstances. This program has been rife with problems since the first borrowers became eligible for forgiveness in October 2007, but it is legitimate. Teacher loan forgiveness and Perkins loan cancellation may also be available to borrowers with eligible employment or volunteer service.
Federal student loans can only be discharged in the following circumstances:
- Total and permanent disability
- School closure
- False certification
- Unpaid refund
If one of these situations applies to you or a family member, make sure you check out the appropriate form on StudentAid.gov.
The American Rescue Plan passed by Congress and signed by President Biden in March 2021 includes a provision that student loan forgiveness issued between Jan. 1, 2021, and Dec. 31, 2025, will not be taxable to the recipient.
The administration also offers debt cancellation for certain student loan borrowers as long as they meet certain income limits. Federal courts issued orders to block Biden's student loan debt relief program on Nov. 11, 2022, and the outcome of the American Rescue Plan is pending.
Scam #3: False Relief or Forgiveness Programs
The CARES Act, passed in March 2020, provided some relief for federal student loan borrowers. This included 0% interest along with a pause on payments and any related collection activity. The White House made several extensions to these provisions.
The most recent extension was issued on November 22, 2022 and calls for a repayment pause until 60 days after the U.S. Department of Education is permitted to implement debt relief efforts. If the program has not yet been implemented or legislation resolved by June 30, 2023, repayments will resume 60 days later at the end of August.
Beware of anyone claiming they can get your loan erased as part of the CARES Act or “Biden's loan forgiveness” or a “pandemic grant.” These are several common scams that have been circulating, according to Federal Student Aid, and office of the U.S. Department of Education and the country’s largest provider of student financial aid.
Always be on high alert when someone asks for personal information, such as bank account details or your Social Security number (SSN), in order to gain access to a program.
A scammer may tell you that you have to act quickly before a federal program expires or enrollment is capped. Don't believe it.
Scam #4: Requesting Personal Details
The Department of Education will not contact you and ask for personal details such as your SSN, account number, date of birth, FSA ID number and password, address, or account balance. Nor will your student loan servicer or a government-contracted private collection agency. But scammers will.
They might try to fool you by asking you to confirm your information. That could sound like a legitimate request: They need to make sure that they’re actually talking to the borrower, right? If you find yourself in this situation, disengage. End the interaction immediately. Don’t worry about being rude. Your financial health could be at stake. Think about it: If the entity requesting such information was reaching out to you, they would already have this information.
If a letter, email, or phone call you’ve received seems legitimate but you’re not sure, here’s how to check:
- Do not call the phone number listed on the letter or send information to the address it provides.
- Don’t reply to an email, call a phone number provided in an email, click on any links, or download any attachments.
- Tell a caller you’re not available right now and hang up.
Then, contact your student loan servicer directly using the information at the servicer’s official website. They’ll be able to look up your account and tell you whether the letter, email, or phone call you received was real or fake.
What could happen if you fall victim to this scam? Identity theft. Unauthorized changes to your student loan account. Damage to your credit. Way too many wasted hours cleaning up the mess.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Do Student Loan Scams Work?
There are many different student loan scams that work in different ways. Many of the scams will claim to offer a service and charge a fee for doing so. This may take the form of a fee for consolidating your loans, for example, which is actually done without a fee on a government website.
Do Student Loan Services Call You for Loan Forgiveness?
Many scammers call students with loans offering loan relief or forgiveness. These scammers offer a service in exchange for money or personal information. This does not have to be a call either; it can be an email, letter, or text. There are relief and forgiveness programs available, but most often the student has to seek these out; it is unlikely that the Department of Education will be contacting students to do so.
Is Student Loan Forgiveness Available?
In August 2022, President Biden announced student loan forgiveness of up to $20,000 for students that received Pell Grants and $10,000 for those that did not receive the grants. To be eligible, an individual has to have an income of less than $125,000 ($250,000 for couples). The program was blocked on November 11, 2022.
On November 22, 2022, the U.S. Department of Education announced student loan repayments would be paused until the resolution of the program and pending litigation. Should the litigation not be solved by June 30, 2023, repayments will begin at the end of August.
The Bottom Line
To avoid student loan scams, stay away from companies that approach you or that show up in search engine ads. Even if you get a letter or phone call from someone who appears to know the details of your student loan, such as how much you owe, it could be a scam. Companies can purchase information about borrowers’ obligations and use that information in their marketing efforts.
Also, steer clear of any company that pressures you to act quickly. They’re trying to get your money before you have enough time to step back from the situation and think clearly about whether it's a good idea. Ignore their high-pressure tactics and firmly tell them, no thanks.