What is the 'Benefits Received Rule'

The Benefits Received Rule actually has two related definitions, one as a tax theory and one as a tax provision. The two definitions are:

1. The Benefits Received Principle, which is a theory of income tax fairness that says people should pay taxes based on the benefits they receive from the government.

2. A tax provision that says a donor who receives a tangible benefit from making a charitable contribution must subtract the value of that benefit from the amount claimed as an income tax deduction.

BREAKING DOWN 'Benefits Received Rule'

The Benefits Received Rule is thought to be appealing for its apparent fairness in that those who benefit from a service should be the ones who pay for it. However, this is not how the tax system works in the United States. The U.S. tax system is a "progressive" or "ability-to-pay" system, meaning that those who make more money tend to pay taxes at a higher rate and those who make less money tend to pay taxes at a lower rate or even receive taxpayer-funded benefits while paying no taxes at all. Another alternative taxation system is a flat tax system in which everyone pays the same tax irrespective of income, which again, is not how the US tax system works, as the US system is income-based, meaning not everyone pays the same amount of taxes.

Example of the Benefits Received Rule

Under the first definition of the Benefits Received Principle, supporters believe that taxpayers that use certain services in disproportionate amounts should pay higher taxes on those goods or services than taxpayers who do not utilize them. For example, taxpayers who own or drive cars should pay more taxes that go towards road maintenance than taxpayers who do not own or use cars. However, it is difficult to separate what goods and services are for the good and maintenance of the entire nation and not just an individual.

Under the second definition of the benefits received rule, an individual must subtract his or her contribution towards a tax deduction in order to reflect the true value of the contribution. So, for example, if Jane bought a $500 ticket to a nonprofit fundraising gala and received a dinner worth $100, she could only claim $400 as a tax deduction. This rule, in theory, might help curb attempts to avoid paying taxes by donating money for tax deduction purposes.

  1. Income Tax

    An income tax is a tax that governments impose on income generated ...
  2. Total Tax

    The composite total of all taxes owed by a taxpayer for the year, ...
  3. Tax Relief

    Tax relief is any program or incentive that reduces the amount ...
  4. Tax Liability

    A tax liability is the amount an individual, corporation or other ...
  5. Flat Tax

    A flat tax system which applies the same tax rate to every taxpayer ...
  6. Progressive Tax

    A progressive tax is a tax that puts a lower rate on low-income ...
Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    3 Federal Income Tax Facts You Didn't Know

    Learn about three federal income tax facts that most Americans may not know from one of the most trusted financial resources on the Web.
  2. Taxes

    Who Does The Current Tax Code Benefit?

    Are the non-workers benefiting from the current tax code in any way or is it the wealthy who are still getting the big breaks?
  3. Taxes

    What's IRS Form 1040 For?

    Most U.S. taxpayers will be familiar with the 1040. By the end of filling it out, you'll know how much tax you owe, or what your refund is.
  4. Taxes

    5 State Tax Issues For When You Leave the Military

    When you're budgeting for post-military life, certain state tax issues need to be considered.
  5. Insights

    A Concise History Of Changes In U.S. Tax Law

    We look at how U.S. taxes have changed since their inception.
  6. Taxes

    Do Canadians Really Pay More Taxes Than Americans?

    We look at the difference in tax rates and services offered on both sides of the border.
  7. Taxes

    What's a Marginal Tax Rate?

    The marginal tax rate is based on a progressive tax system, where tax rates for an individual will increase as income rises. This method of taxation aims to fairly tax individuals based upon ...
  8. Taxes

    10 Money-Saving Year-End Tax Tips

    Getting organized well before the deadline will curb your frustration and your tax liability.
  9. Taxes

    What to Do This Year with Tax Cuts Coming in 2017?

    Here are several strategies that taxpayers can use to make the most of the likely coming tax cuts following Donald Trump's win.
  10. Taxes

    Minimizing the Amount of Income Tax You Owe

    The amount of income you receive and tax deductions and credits you take impact how much you'll owe.
Trading Center