DEFINITION of 'Business Judgment Rule'

The business judgment rule is a  legal principle which grants directors, officers, and agents of a company immunity from lawsuits relating to corporate transactions if it is found that they have acted in good faith. The rule assumes that a company’s officers act in the best interest of the company when making decisions.

BREAKING DOWN 'Business Judgment Rule'

Corporate executives and other managers are tasked with making decisions that can be complex, and that can have long-term implications for the health of the company. Often, officers are making decisions without perfect information, and must estimate the impact that the decisions will have. Sometimes, decisions such as a merger with another company or acquisition of a competitor, may ultimately result in financial loss.

Good Faith Actions

The business judgment rule provides some cover for these decisions. It is used by courts to determine whether an officer or director of a company should be held liable for his or her actions. Generally, the principle grants immunity for liability if it is found that the officer acted in good faith, with the care that an ordinary person would take if faced with the same situation, and in what the director reasonably believed was in the best interest of the company.

This legal principle creates a presumption of innocence in court cases, but can be overturned if it is found that an officer did not follow the three basic guidelines. For example, a company’s executive board may accept an acquisition offer that is less than the fair market value of the company. If it is determined that the officers hurried the decision or did not adequately complete the duties assigned to them, the courts may strip their immunity.

The courts may also remove the immunity if it is determined that the officer acted in self-interest. For example, an officer who is granted a position with an acquiring company if he or she accepts a lower bid would not be acting in the best interest of the company.

In deciding business judgment cases, courts apply the Aronson rule (from the case Aronson v. Lewis, 473 A.2d 805, 814, Del. 1984) for two tests which must be met, according to business attorney Steven Goldberg. "The complaint must allege particularized fact that establish a reasonable doubt that “(1) the directors are disinterested and independent [or] (2) that challenged transaction was otherwise the product of a valid exercise of business judgment.” The test is stated in the disjunctive."

  1. Judgment

    A judgment is a court order to the loser of a lawsuit to pay ...
  2. Excess Judgment Loss

    Excess judgment loss is the amount of additional loss that an ...
  3. Immunization

    Immunization is a strategy that matches the duration of assets ...
  4. Stipulated Judgment

    A Stipulated Judgment is a court decision ordering a debtor to ...
  5. Adverse Domination

    Adverse domination is a legal doctrine that allows regulators ...
  6. Deficiency Judgment

    A deficiency judgment is a court ruling against a debtor in default ...
Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    DOL's Fiduciary Rule Officially Shelved

    In a June 21st decision, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the DOL's fiduciary rule. The rule has been harshly scrutinized over the last two years.
  2. Personal Finance

    Government Grants for Women-Owned Businesses

    Explore options for financial grants as a female business owner, and discover helpful resources for alternate ways of funding a business, including loans.
  3. Insights

    Brexit Derailed: High Court Says Brexit Requires Parliamentary Approval

    British Prime Minister Theresa May does not have the power to decide to go ahead with Brexit.
  4. Investing

    Attention Home Buyers: Why You Need a Lawyer

    Property transactions are complex and subject to specific state/local rules. Hiring a lawyer can simplify the process.
  5. Financial Advisor

    How Trump Could Repeal, Soften Fiduciary Rule

    Donald Trump has threatened to repeal the new fiduciary rule. Here’s what he could do if he wants to kill the rule in its present form.
  6. Insights

    So, You Want to Take Your Broker to Court

    Find out how to file a claim with your broker, and what you can expect throughout the process.
  7. Tech

    Advisor Fintech Tools Aren't Waiting for Trump

    The new U.S. president might bring big change to financial regulation after he takes office. Here's how the financial technology sector is dealing.
  8. Small Business

    The Marketing Director's Pitch

    Are your shoulder's wide enough to carry a company's reputation?
  1. How should a change in accounting principle be recorded and reported?

    Learn about changes in accounting principle and why businesses make them, as well as the reporting and recording requirements ... Read Answer >>
  2. What are the generally accepted accounting principles for inventory reserves?

    As with most matters related to generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), accountants assigned with the task of applying ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center