What is a 'Buyout Settlement Clause'

A buyout settlement clause is an insurance contract provision allowing the insured party to refuse a settlement offer proposed by the insurer and the claimant.

When an insurance company underwrites a new policy, it agrees to defend the interests of the policyholder against claims from third-parties. This is referred to as indemnification. If an individual or business files a claim against the insured’s policy, the insurance company collects the relevant information to the claim, and typically handles the legal expenses associated with defending the policyholder in court.

Often, the insurer seeks a settlement with the claimant to avoid the courts making a decision on the amount of damages awarded. The insured doesn't always agree with the terms or amount of the settlement, and sometimes elects to reject it.

BREAKING DOWN 'Buyout Settlement Clause'

A buyout settlement clause removes the insurer from having any further responsibility for defending against claims once respective insured parties rejects them. In this instance, the insurer “buys out” policyholders by providing the amount of their negotiated claim settlements. 

At this point, the insured becomes responsible for their own defense, including all legal fees incurred after rejecting the claim. Policyholders benefit from this option if they fight the claim and settle for less than the amount of the buyout. If this occurs, the policyholder keeps the difference between any ultimate settlement and the amount paid to them in the buyout. However, if the cost of defense exceeds the settlement amount, policyholders pay for those extra expenses out of pocket.

Why Policyholders May Opt for a Buyout

In many cases, policyholders want to settle cases against them quickly. A quick settlement allows the policyholder to reduce any expenses associated with working on the case. For some business, a quick settlement reduces the possibility that a drawn-out negotiation damages the business’ reputation.

In some cases, however, the policyholder won't approve of the terms of the settlement, perhaps believing the claim lacks merit. In this case, agreeing to any settlement amounts to an admission of wrongdoing. Rejecting the claim puts the interests of the policyholder at odds with the desire of the insurer to reduce the cost of defending against a claim.

  1. Hammer Clause

    A hammer clause is an insurance policy clause that allows an ...
  2. Loss Settlement Amount

    Loss settlement amount is a term used to denote the amount of ...
  3. Policyholder Surplus

    Policyholder surplus are assets of a mutual insurance company ...
  4. Cooperation Clause

    An insurance contract clause that requires the policyholder to ...
  5. Return On Policyholder Surplus

    Return On Policyholder Surplus is the ratio of an insurance company’s ...
  6. Net Settlement

    Net settlement refers to the resolution of all of a bank's transactions ...
Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    Mutual vs. Stock Insurance Companies

    Learn about the differences between stock and mutual insurance companies and which is best for you as a policyholder.
  2. Managing Wealth

    Protect Your Company From Employee Lawsuits

    Understanding employment practices liability insurance is easy, once you know the basics.
  3. Insurance

    How To Invest In Insurance Companies

    Knowing the special circumstances that insurance companies operate under helps in evaluating whether or not a listed insurance company is a good investment and whether the economic environment ...
  4. Insurance

    Understanding Taxes on Life Insurance Premiums

    Learn about the tax implications of life insurance premiums, including when they might be taxable and whether they are tax deductible.
  5. Taxes

    The truth about IRS tax settlement firms

    Tax Settlement firms claim that they can reduce or even eliminate what you owe to the IRS. Find out the facts behind this alluring fiction.
  6. Insurance

    How To Easily Understand Your Insurance Contract

    Understanding your insurance contracts can go a long way in making sure that your advisor's recommendations are on track. Learn how to read yours today.
  7. Insurance

    For Life Insurers, Making Money Is A Numbers Game

    Life insurance is a data-driven industry that relies on complex financial models to predict future expenses and income from premiums and investments.
  8. Insurance

    The History of Insurance in America

    Insurance was a latecomer to the American landscape, largely due to the country's unknown risks.
  1. Why would you want a monthly benefit versus a daily benefit?

    An insurance benefit is the amount of money paid to or on behalf of the policyholder. Depending on what kind of insurance ... Read Answer >>
  2. Can an Insurance Company Deny Coverage?

    Insurance isn't always as straightforward as other products, and insurers can deny coverage in many different instances. ... Read Answer >>
  3. Why do insurance policies have deductibles?

    Learn the basic concept of an insurance deductible and why they mitigate moral hazards and provide financial viability to ... Read Answer >>
  4. Do I Own a Stock on the Trade Date or Settlement Date?

    Find out why you don't become a legal shareholder until the settlement date. Read Answer >>
Trading Center