What is a 'Comparison Universe'

A comparison universe is a comprehensive grouping of investment managers with similar mandates and investment objectives. It serves as a peer benchmark to measure a money manager's performance.

A comparison universe should not be confused with a fund’s index benchmark, which is a basket of investments that an active manager attempts to beat over a given period, often every year.

BREAKING DOWN 'Comparison Universe'

A comparison universe typically is compiled by one of two major companies: Lipper or Morningstar. Each has slightly different comparison-universe groupings.

Lipper, now owned by Thomson Reuters, got its start in 1973 and still provides comparison universes to mutual fund companies. A large number of mutual funds since have moved to Morningstar averages, a Chicago-based publicly traded company that started in 1984.

Each company creates universes for large-cap managers, small-cap managers and everything in between. Moreover, the companies offer comparison universes for sector managers, international managers, and ones who invest in assets classes other than stocks, such as investment-grade bonds. In addition, there are universes for blended funds that incorporate stocks, bonds and even high-yield investments, the latter being bonds that behave more like stocks.

Pros and Cons of a Comparison Universe

One criticism of using a comparison universe to measure how well a manager is doing is that the defined parameters sometimes are too broad to be an effective gauge of performance. For example, comparing a special situations manager who tends to like value companies with Morningstar’s broad large-cap comparison universe might not be a proper comparison.

Another drawback is that comparison universe sometimes set unrealistically high benchmarks by either excluding poorly-performing managers who are no longer in business, or including ones whose assets are merged with those of another manager. This latter issue is called survivorship bias.

The size of the fund or money management firm, in terms of assets under management, is another consideration in creating a relevant comparison universe. The best money managers generally figure in the top quartile of their comparison universe on a consistent basis, not just for a period of a few quarters or a few years.

What is good about a comparison universe, however is that it offers another type of benchmark entirely. An investment that consistently beats its index benchmark but regularly falls short of its comparison universe points to a problem: Either it’s not in the right comparison universe, or it its benchmark is too easy for the fund to beat, perhaps because the fund routinely takes on more relative risk than the index.

  1. Manager Universe (Benchmark)

    Manager universe - benchmark is a group of investment managers ...
  2. Universe of Securities

    A universe of securities generally refers to a set of securities ...
  3. Universal Banking

    Universal banking is a system in which banks provide a wide variety ...
  4. Active Risk

    Active risk is a type of risk that a fund or managed portfolio ...
  5. Sales Comparison Approach (SCA)

    The sales comparison approach is an appraisal method that compares ...
  6. Group Universal Life Policy (GULP)

    A group universal life policy is universal life insurance offered ...
Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    Want A Career In Asset Management? Read This First.

    When it comes to landing that job at an asset manager, not all university degrees are created equal. Here's a look at the best schools for the job.
  2. Personal Finance

    The Most Prestigious Universities in the World

    A list of 105 most prestigious universities demonstrates that the US and the UK continue to lead.
  3. Investing

    How's Your Mutual Fund Really Doing?

    Determine how mutual funds are doing by sizing them up against their peers.
  4. Investing

    Vanguard vs. Active Managers – A Performance Review

    Is Going Active in U.S. Large Caps Worth It?
  5. Investing

    Active Management: Is It Working for You?

    There are guidelines when comparing an actively managed investment strategy with a benchmark.
  6. Investing

    Benchmark To Show Winning Returns

    You can't win if you don't keep score. Read on to learn how to measure your returns.
  7. Financial Advisor

    Analyzing Mutual Funds: Lipper Rating Vs. Morningstar

    Read a comparison between the Morningstar and Lipper mutual fund rating systems and why it's important for investors to understand them.
  8. Investing

    Benchmark Your Returns With Indexes

    If your portfolio is always falling short, you may not be making an apples-to-apples comparison.
  9. Investing

    Should Investors Nix Actively Managed Funds?

    Index fund returns are on a tear but does this mean investors should nix actively managed funds?
  1. How do I judge a mutual fund's performance?

    Evaluate mutual fund performance utilizing resources such as Morningstar; compare the fund with others in its peer group ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center