What is 'Cookie Jar Accounting'

Cookie jar accounting is a disingenuous accounting practice in which periods of good financial results are used to create reserves that shore up profits in lean years. “Cookie jar accounting” is used by a company to smooth out volatility in its financial results, thus giving investors the misleading impression that it is consistently meeting earnings targets. This reliable earnings performance is generally rewarded by investors, who assign the company a premium valuation. Regulators frown on the practice since it misrepresents a company’s performance, which may be very different in reality from what it purports to be.

The term may be derived from the fact that a company which employs this practice dips into the “cookie jar” of reserves whenever it feels like it. But the company may have to answer tough questions if it is caught with its hand in the proverbial cookie jar.

BREAKING DOWN 'Cookie Jar Accounting'

One-time charges and special items are a couple of areas where a company can manipulate numbers to create cookie jar reserves. Potential investors should, therefore, scrutinize these numbers carefully before committing investment capital to the stock.

Example of Cookie Jar Accounting

One of the best-known cases of cookie jar accounting in recent years was that of computer giant Dell, which in July 2010 agreed to pay a $100 million penalty to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to settle SEC allegations that it used cookie jar reserves. The SEC maintained that Dell would have missed analysts’ earnings estimates in every quarter between 2002 and 2006 had it not dipped into these reserves to cover shortfalls in its operating results. The cookie jar reserves were created through undisclosed payments that Dell received from chip giant Intel in return for agreeing to use Intel’s CPU chips exclusively in its computers. (Intel made these payments to Dell to lock out rival chipmaker Advanced Micro Devices from Dell computers.)

The SEC also said that Dell did not disclose to investors that it was drawing on these reserves. The Intel payments made up a huge chunk of Dell’s profits, accounting for as much as 72% of its quarterly operating income at the peak. Dell’s quarterly profits fell significantly in 2007 after it ended the arrangement with Intel. The SEC alleged that while Dell said the decline in profitability was due to an aggressive product-pricing strategy and higher component prices, but the real reason was that it was no longer receiving the payments from Intel.

  1. Absorbed

    1. In a general business sense, when a cost is treated as an ...
  2. Original Equipment Manufacturer ...

    An OEM provides the components in another company's product, ...
  3. Securities And Exchange Commission ...

    A government commission created by Congress to regulate the securities ...
  4. Reserve Ratio

    The portion (expressed as a percent) of depositors' balances ...
  5. Free Reserves

    Free reserves are the reserves a bank holds in excess of required ...
  6. 500 Investor Rule

    A SEC stipulation requiring a company that exceeds 500 individual ...
Related Articles
  1. Personal Finance

    The Cookie Jar Method of Budgeting

    The cookie jar method of budgeting can get you on the path to saving and reaching financial goals.
  2. Investing

    Dell Stock Doesn’t Exist. Here is Why

    Discover why going private has been helpful for Dell, and how it could be back to the stock market soon.
  3. Investing

    Dell CEO Reports Q3 Results After EMC Acquisition

    After completing the largest tech merger to date, Dell's CFO says the firm is on track.
  4. Insights

    HP CEO Slams Dell on Excessive Debt (HPE)

    As HPE and Dell employ drastically different strategies to slim down versus beef up, Whitman points to the Dell balance sheet to ignite uncertainty.
  5. Investing

    Look For These Red Flags In The Income Statement

    Companies can overstate their revenues and understate their losses to boost investor confidence. Learn how to spot the these red flags in income statements.
  6. Trading

    VMware Stock Breaks Below Key Support After Dell RTO News

    VMware shares moved lower in response to reports that Dell is considering an RTO, but traders will be watching these key levels.
  7. Investing

    Dell Says It Saw Best PC Sales in Six Years

    After completing big tech deals with EMC and VMware, Dell posts its 16th consecutive segment gain.
  8. Investing

    Corporate America's $100 Billion Refinancing Spree

    U.S. companies refinanced $100 billion worth of loans in January amid favorable market conditions.
  9. Investing

    VMware in $500M Stock Repurchase Plan With Dell

    VMware agreed to buy Class A common stock held by EMC Corp., which Dell bought for $67 billion.
  10. Investing

    Dell Acquires EMC in the Largest Tech Deal Ever

    Dell and private equity company Silver Lake have announced a plan to acquire EMC (NYSE: EMC) for $67 billion, which would mark the biggest tech deal in history. The New York Times reports that ...
  1. How are bank reserve requirements determined and how does this affect shareholders?

    Learn how bank reserve requirements are determined and how bank reserves affect shareholders through improved bank stability ... Read Answer >>
  2. What are the key barriers to entry for companies in the electronics sector?

    Learn how the entry barriers of economies of scale and scope, research and development, capital and brand loyalty affect ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is the difference between proven and probable reserves in the oil and gas sector?

    Learn how those in the oil and gas sector classify oil reserves and the specific differences between proven and probable ... Read Answer >>
  4. How does an oil and gas company measure and state their reserves?

    Understand how oil and gas companies estimate possible reserves and how different classifications are used to designate the ... Read Answer >>
  5. Why does financial accounting have to comply with GAAP?

    Read about the roles of the FASB and the SEC as it relates to generally accepted accounting principles for publicly traded ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Money Market

    The money market is a segment of the financial market in which financial instruments with high liquidity and very short maturities ...
  2. Perfect Competition

    Pure or perfect competition is a theoretical market structure in which a number of criteria such as perfect information and ...
  3. Compound Interest

    Compound Interest is interest calculated on the initial principal and also on the accumulated interest of previous periods ...
  4. Income Statement

    A financial statement that measures a company's financial performance over a specific accounting period. Financial performance ...
  5. Leverage Ratio

    A leverage ratio is any one of several financial measurements that look at how much capital comes in the form of debt, or ...
  6. Annuity

    An annuity is a financial product that pays out a fixed stream of payments to an individual, primarily used as an income ...
Trading Center