What is a 'Duty of Care'

Duty of care is a fiduciary responsibility for company directors that requires them to make decisions in good faith and in a reasonably prudent manner. The duty of care requires directors to make business decisions after taking all available information into account, and then act in a judicious manner that promotes the company's best interests. Directors are required to exercise the utmost care in making business decisions in order to fulfill their fiduciary duty. The other main fiduciary duty is the duty of loyalty.

Breaking Down 'Duty of Care'

Duty of care can be summed up in the requirement that a director should be present, informed, engaged, use good and independent judgment, utilize expert advice and trusted information, refer to meeting minutes, and seek to stay abreast of legal developments, good governance, and best practices. Directors should also schedule and be prepared to discuss and review of budget issues, executive compensation, legal compliance, and strategic direction.

Failure to uphold the duty of care may result in legal action being brought against the board of directors by shareholders. However, the courts will not rule on whether or not a business decision was a sound one (known as the business judgment rule, in which courts defer to the judgment of corporate executives). Instead, their main focus is on assessing whether the directors:

  1. Fulfilled their duty of care by acting in a reasonably prudent manner when making the decision (in the best interest of the corporation)
  2. Conducted an adequate degree of due diligence (otherwise known as ordinary care)
  3. Acted in good faith
  4. Have not wasted corporate assets or resources on overpaying for goods, property or labor.

Duty of Care Example

Assume a public company PubCo makes a large acquisition of rival firm ABC Holdings that effectively doubles its size. The market reaction, judging by the decline in PubCo's share price after the acquisition is announced, is that PubCo paid too much for ABC Holdings. PubCo's management is initially very confident that the acquisition will be accretive to earnings. But a few months after the deal closes, PubCo announces that ABC's management had been engaged in accounting fraud that grossly inflated its revenue and profitability. Despite PubCo's management asserting that they had no inkling anything was amiss at ABC, PubCo's shares plunge 30% and shareholders launch a class-action lawsuit against PubCo's directors.

In such a situation, if the case does go to trial (most such cases are settled out-of-court), the court would not rule on whether PubCo paid too much for ABC. Rather, it would assess whether PubCo's board of directors conducted their due diligence on ABC and acted in good faith. The fact that the directors failed to detect the accounting fraud at ABC does not necessarily constitute a breach of the duty of care. But if PubCo's directors were aware of it and chose to go ahead with the acquisition anyway, this could be construed as a breach of duty.

Duty of Care Criticism

Given that the courts tend to defer to the judgment of executives, it can be exceptionally hard to prove a duty of care breach. In fact, in Brehm v. Eisner, the Delaware Supreme Court found that the business judgment rule protected The Walt Disney Co. board after it awarded $150 million in pay to Michael S. Ovitz for just 14 months of work as part of a no-fault termination of his employment agreement. The court found that Disney's board had exercised bad business judgment but was covered under procedural requirements by the fact that they had consulted an expert before allowing Ovitz's severance. The decision reinforced the belief that there is little shareholders can do to hold directors accountable.

  1. Duty of Loyalty

    Duty of loyalty is a director's responsibility to act at all ...
  2. Business Judgment Rule

    The business judgment rule helps to guard a corporation's board ...
  3. Omission

    Omission is a failure to act that causes harm.
  4. Independent Outside Director

    An independent outside director is a member of a company's board ...
  5. Default Judgment

    A default judgment is a binding judgment issued by a court for ...
  6. Stamp Duty

    A stamp duty is the tax placed on legal documents, usually in ...
Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    Which Firms Are Sticking with Fiduciary Rule Changes Anyway?

    The Fiduciary Duty Rule is under scrutiny again and may be scrapped altogether, but that doesn't mean all financial firms will abandon the standard.
  2. Financial Advisor

    Fund Boards: What They Do and Why You Should Care

    Fund boards oversee management and operations of the fund on behalf of shareholders. Make sure you've got a board that will look out for you.
  3. Insurance

    What Will Your Long-Term Care Look Like?

    As much as we don't want to talk about it, it's important to have a long-term care plan.
  4. Retirement

    Why Retirement Plan Sponsors Could Face Litigation

    A Supreme Court decision makes it easier for retirement plan participants to sue their employers. Apathy is not a strategy for plan sponsors.
  5. Financial Advisor

    How Trump Could Let the Fiduciary Rule Die on the Vine

    If Donald Trump keeps his promise to repeal the fiduciary rule his administration could do so by not defending it against pending lawsuits.
  6. Insights

    Can the Fiduciary Rule Be Saved?

    The rule has been delayed numerous times, with full implementation now scheduled for June 2019. However, recent federal court action threatens the rule.
  7. Personal Finance

    How to become a managing director at an investment bank

    Find out what it takes to become managing director at a major investment bank, starting from business school and surviving all of the titles in between.
  8. Financial Advisor

    How Advisors Can Defend from Fiduciary Litigation

    The new fiduciary rules mean that many advisors need to overhaul their business models to stay in compliance and guard against potential litigation.
  9. Financial Advisor

    Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibility

    Learn the responsibilities that come along with being a fiduciary. These four steps will reduce your liability when managing other people's money.
  10. Financial Advisor

    Coverage of Fiduciary Liability Insurance

    As fiduciaries, retirement plan sponsors have tremendous personal liability exposure. Find out how fiduciary liability insurance can protect personal assets.
  1. Who is Responsible for Shareholders Interests?

    Several parties are supposed to be responsible for protecting and managing shareholders' interests, including the company's ... Read Answer >>
  2. How do a corporation's shareholders influence its Board of Directors?

    Find out how shareholders can influence the activity of the members of the board of directors and even change official corporate ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center