What is 'Hawthorne Effect'

The Hawthorne Effect is the inclination of people who are the subjects of an experimental study to change or improve the behavior being evaluated only because it is being studied, and not because of changes in the experiment parameters or stimulus.

BREAKING DOWN 'Hawthorne Effect'

The Hawthorne Effect refers to the fact that people will modify their behavior simply because they are being observed. The effect gets its name from one of the most famous industrial history experiments that took place at Western Electric’s factory in the Hawthorne suburb of Chicago in the late 1920s and early 1930s. However, subsequent analysis on the effect by University of Chicago economists in 2009 revealed that the original results were likely overstated.

The Hawthorne experiments were originally designed by the National Research Council to study the effect of shop-floor lighting on worker productivity at a telephone parts factory in Hawthorne. However, the researchers were perplexed to find that productivity improved, not just when the lighting was improved, but also when the lighting was diminished. Productivity improved whenever changes were made in other variables such as working hours and rest breaks. The researchers concluded that the workers’ productivity was not being affected by the changes in working conditions, but rather by the fact that someone was concerned enough about their working conditions to conduct an experiment on it.

The Hawthorne Effect and Modern Research

For many types of research that utilizes human subjects, the Hawthorne effect is an unavoidable bias that researchers must try to take into account when analyzing results. How a subject's awareness of a study might modify their behavior is extremely difficult to quantify. All a researcher can really do is attempt to factor the effect into the research design, which is a tough proposition with no universally agreed-upon methodology. The presence of the Hawthorne Effect renders most social research into a matter that requires experience and human judgment to assess.

As an example of the Hawthorne Effect in action, consider a 1978 study to establish whether cerebellar neurostimulators could mitigate the motor dysfunction of young adults with cerebral palsy, results showed that the Hawthorne Effect adversely affected the findings. Objective testing showed that all of patients reported that their motor functions improved and that they were happy with the treatment.

Quantitative methods, however, showed that there was little improvement, and researchers invoked the Hawthorne Effect as the main factor skewing the results. They believed that the extra attention given to the patients, by the doctors, nurses and therapists, was the reason for the reported improvements in the initial study.

  1. Event Study

    An event study is an empirical analysis done on a security that ...
  2. September Effect

    The September effect refers to historically weak stock market ...
  3. Behavioral Finance

    Behavioral finance is a field of finance that proposes psychology-based ...
  4. Experience Rating (Insurance)

    Experience rating (insurance) is the amount of loss that an insured ...
  5. Market Research

    Market research is the use of surveys, product testing and focus ...
  6. Calendar Effect

    The calendar effect is a collection of theories asserting certain ...
Related Articles
  1. Tech

    How Advisors' Personality Traits Impact Success

    Research shows that the advisor industry is made up all type of personalities, and that matching those up strategically can result in business growth.
  2. Personal Finance

    The Key To CFP Exam Success

    Up to 60 of the questions on CFP exam are case studies. Are you up for the challenge?
  3. Investing

    SpaceX HQ Houses Elon Musk's Very Private School

    An unconventional educational experiment attracts high interest for just a dozen or so spots.
  4. Investing

    An Introduction to Behavioral Finance

    Curious about how emotions and biases affect the market? Find some useful insight here.
  5. Personal Finance

    How Much Will It Cost To Study Abroad In The U.K.?

    The most popular destination for U.S. students studying abroad has a lot to offer – and ways to make it affordable.
  6. Investing

    What Is The Impact Of Research On Stock Prices?

    Find out how stock prices are impacted by the issuance of research reports. Determine the benefits of research to investors and the larger market.
  7. Investing

    When Mortgage Rates Rise, Home Improvement Will Follow

    As mortgage rates increase over the next few years, homeowners are likely to take on more home improvement projects. This may seem counterintuitive, but you can expect two somewhat opposing effects: ...
  8. Taxes

    How Do Apple's Taxes Compare to Other Tech Giants? (AAPL)

    Analyze Apple's recent tax history to determine how geographic sales mix, foreign profit reinvestment and tax credits are influencing tax rates versus peers.
  9. Trading

    Understanding Investor Behavior

    Discover how some human tendencies can play out in the market, posing the question: are we really rational?
  10. Investing

    Facebook Is a Great Stock But Bad For Your Health

    A detailed study suggests Facebook users may be less happy and less healthy
  1. What's the difference between the income effect and the price effect?

    The price effect is the impact on the market based on how the consumer is spending money as a result of the income effect. Read Answer >>
  2. How do you calculate the income effect distinctly from the price effect?

    Learn more about how the income and substitution effects operate in economics and how to separate either of these while calculating ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is the effective interest method of amortization?

    Find out more about the rationale and advantages of the effective interest rate method and how it is used to amortize a discounted ... Read Answer >>
  4. How does economics study human action and behavior?

    Find out why economics can be considered a deductive social science, like sociology, and how human action and behavior informs ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center