What is an 'Invisible Hard Market'

An invisible hard market refers to rising prices for property and casualty insurance that fails to result in higher profits for insurers.

Under normal circumstances, limited supply for insurance results in more underwriting income for insurers, as well as more net profit. In an invisible hard market, the net profit either doesn’t budge or declines, largely due to weak demand or abnormal market conditions.

BREAKING DOWN 'Invisible Hard Market'

Invisible hard market first became a term when former MMC President and CEO Brian Duperreault, who became CEO of AIG in 2017, coined the phase in 2009. The longtime industry veteran used it to describe the insurance market in the aftermath of the Great Recession, in which the supply of insurance decreased, as some insurance companies declared bankruptcy, and others consolidated and became part of larger firms.

Normally, consolidation results in higher prices, which coincides with a so-called market hardening. This indeed was the case in some market niches. However, overall lackluster demand for insurance during the Great Recession negated the effect of these higher prices, resulting in disappointing insurance income for companies.

Invisible Hand vs. Invisible Hard Market

Invisible hard market shouldn’t be confused with Adam Smith’s invisible hand, which describes how the self interests of individuals drives the economy and promotes the well-being of societies.

Invisible hard market seemingly is contradictory to invisible hand, as it fails to leverage the two most critical facets of Smith’s invisible hand definition. In his foundational work, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Smith describes how voluntary trades in a free market produce unintentional and widespread benefits. Second, these benefits are greater than those of a regulated, planned economy.

Neither of these tenets hold true in an invisible hard market. To the contrary, an invisible hard market for insurance points to market inefficiency, at least in the short term. An invisible hard market does not benefit the bottom line of insurance companies, and also fails to help consumers, who must pay higher insurance rates.

In modern interpretations of Smith’s theory, however, short-term market inefficiencies such as the invisible hard market tend to straighten out in the long term. As a result, Smith’s invisible hand seemingly cures the invisible hard market for insurance over time.

In addition, some argue the term invisible hard market still is in line with Smith’s definition, in that Smith’s invisible hand relies on market free of government intervention.

Government intervention played a large role in the Great Recession. Leading up to the crisis, policies that promoted homeownership for individuals who couldn’t afford it bloated home values and led to asset bubbles. Once these bubbles burst, government intervened in an unprecedented way, by borrowing trillions and bailing out the private sector, neither of which fits Smith’s free market definition.

  1. Invisible Trade

    Transactions that occur across borders but without the exchange ...
  2. Insurance Industry ETF

    An insurance industry ETF invests primarily in insurance companies ...
  3. Self-Interest

  4. Insurance Premium

    An insurance premium is the amount of money that an individual ...
  5. Assigned Risk

    Assigned Risk is when an insurance company is required to provide ...
  6. Classified Insurance

    Classified Insurance is coverage provided to a policyholder that ...
Related Articles
  1. Insights

    Adam Smith and "The Wealth Of Nations"

    Adam Smith's 1776 classic "Wealth of Nations" may have had the largest global impact on economic thought.
  2. Insights

    Adam Smith: The Father of Economics

    Adam Smith is renowned as "The Father of Economics" for his work in pioneering ideas such as free trade and GDP.
  3. Insurance

    How To Easily Understand Your Insurance Contract

    Understanding your insurance contracts can go a long way in making sure that your advisor's recommendations are on track. Learn how to read yours today.
  4. Insurance

    How To Invest In Insurance Companies

    Knowing the special circumstances that insurance companies operate under helps in evaluating whether or not a listed insurance company is a good investment and whether the economic environment ...
  5. Insurance

    Bundle Your Insurance for Big Savings

    Bundling your insurance can save you money and time. Read on to see how to get the most out of multi-line insurance discounts.
  6. Trading

    Deep Web Vs. Dark Web

    Understanding how the Internet includes much beyond what most users are familiar with.
  7. Insurance

    4 Things That Keep You From Getting Life Insurance

    We look at four common reasons people give for not applying for life insurance, and see if they're legitimate.
  8. Insurance

    Choosing Between Whole and Term Life Insurance

    For most people, term life insurance is more suitable than whole life insurance. Here's why.
  9. Insurance

    World's Top 10 Insurance Companies

    These are the 10 largest insurance companies in the world.
  1. What does the term 'invisible hand' refer to in the economy?

    Discover and understand the concept of the "invisible hand" as explained by Adam Smith, considered the founder of modern ... Read Answer >>
  2. Which economic factors most affect the demand for consumer goods?

    Understand how key economic factors such as inflation, unemployment, interest rates and consumer confidence affect the level ... Read Answer >>
  3. How does the insurance sector work?

    Learn more about the insurance sector, a historically safe place for equity investors and the home of some of the largest ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center