What is an 'Invisible Hard Market'

An invisible hard market refers to rising prices for property and casualty insurance that fails to result in higher profits for insurers.

Under normal circumstances, limited supply for insurance results in more underwriting income for insurers, as well as more net profit. In an invisible hard market, the net profit either doesn’t budge or declines, largely due to weak demand or abnormal market conditions.

BREAKING DOWN 'Invisible Hard Market'

Invisible hard market first became a term when former MMC President and CEO Brian Duperreault, who became CEO of AIG in 2017, coined the phase in 2009. The longtime industry veteran used it to describe the insurance market in the aftermath of the Great Recession, in which the supply of insurance decreased, as some insurance companies declared bankruptcy, and others consolidated and became part of larger firms.

Normally, consolidation results in higher prices, which coincides with a so-called market hardening. This indeed was the case in some market niches. However, overall lackluster demand for insurance during the Great Recession negated the effect of these higher prices, resulting in disappointing insurance income for companies.

Invisible Hand vs. Invisible Hard Market

Invisible hard market shouldn’t be confused with Adam Smith’s invisible hand, which describes how the self interests of individuals drives the economy and promotes the well-being of societies.

Invisible hard market seemingly is contradictory to invisible hand, as it fails to leverage the two most critical facets of Smith’s invisible hand definition. In his foundational work, An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, Smith describes how voluntary trades in a free market produce unintentional and widespread benefits. Second, these benefits are greater than those of a regulated, planned economy.

Neither of these tenets hold true in an invisible hard market. To the contrary, an invisible hard market for insurance points to market inefficiency, at least in the short term. An invisible hard market does not benefit the bottom line of insurance companies, and also fails to help consumers, who must pay higher insurance rates.

In modern interpretations of Smith’s theory, however, short-term market inefficiencies such as the invisible hard market tend to straighten out in the long term. As a result, Smith’s invisible hand seemingly cures the invisible hard market for insurance over time.

In addition, some argue the term invisible hard market still is in line with Smith’s definition, in that Smith’s invisible hand relies on market free of government intervention.

Government intervention played a large role in the Great Recession. Leading up to the crisis, policies that promoted homeownership for individuals who couldn’t afford it bloated home values and led to asset bubbles. Once these bubbles burst, government intervened in an unprecedented way, by borrowing trillions and bailing out the private sector, neither of which fits Smith’s free market definition.

  1. Invisible Trade

    Transactions that occur across borders but without the exchange ...
  2. Invisible Supply

    Invisible supply refers to an unknown amount of stock of a commodity ...
  3. Personal Lines Insurance

    Personal lines insurance includes property and casualty insurance ...
  4. Insurance Industry ETF

    A sector-following fund that invests primarily in insurance companies, ...
  5. Capital Stock Insurance Companies

    Capital stock insurance companies are companies that get their ...
  6. Self-Interest

    Acting in the way that is most personally beneficial. Adam Smith, ...
Related Articles
  1. Personal Finance

    Odd eBay Sales

    Whether you need a ghost in a jar or a celebrity-owned socks, eBay can hook you up.
  2. Insurance

    Bundle Your Insurance for Big Savings

    Bundling your insurance can save you money and time. Read on to see how to get the most out of multi-line insurance discounts.
  3. Insurance

    12 Insurance Questions for High Net Worth Families

    High net worth families should ask themselves these 12 questions regarding comprehensive insurance.
  4. Financial Advisor

    Buying a Life Insurance Policy? Read This First

    Knowing who needs life insurance, how it works and the different types of insurance can help consumers make informed decisions about this product.
  5. Insurance

    How Much Life Insurance Should You Carry?

    Before purchasing life insurance it is important to decide if you really need it, what type of policy is best, and how much coverage you should get.
  6. Insurance

    Life Insurance

    Life insurance is an important component of basic financial planning. Find out how life insurance works and how insurance companies are able to profit through providing financial security to ...
  7. Financial Advisor

    Getting Life Insurance in Your 20s Pays Off

    Find out how Americans in their 20s can benefit from a well-thought-out life insurance policy, especially if they are able to build cash value for retirement.
  8. Insurance

    Do You Need Casualty Insurance?

    Find out how different types of coverages can protect you and which policy is right for you.
  1. How does the invisible hand affect a capitalist economy?

    Take a deeper look at how the invisible hand of the market works and why it is so crucial for understanding how capitalist ... Read Answer >>
  2. What does the term 'invisible hand' refer to in the economy?

    Discover and understand the concept of the "invisible hand" as explained by Adam Smith, considered the founder of modern ... Read Answer >>
  3. Which economic factors most affect the demand for consumer goods?

    Understand how key economic factors such as inflation, unemployment, interest rates and consumer confidence affect the level ... Read Answer >>
  4. What are insurance sector companies usual profit margins?

    Understand what the average profit margin for a company that serves in the insurance sector and what factors can affect the ... Read Answer >>
  5. Can your insurance company cancel your policy without notice?

    Learn about your rights as an insured when it comes to your insurance policy being canceled, including how to access your ... Read Answer >>
  6. How does the insurance sector work?

    Learn more about the insurance sector, a historically safe place for equity investors and the home of some of the largest ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Inflation

    Inflation is the rate at which prices for goods and services is rising and the worth of currency is dropping.
  2. Discount Rate

    Discount rate is the interest rate charged to commercial banks and other depository institutions for loans received from ...
  3. Economies of Scale

    Economies of scale refer to reduced costs per unit that arise from increased total output of a product. For example, a larger ...
  4. Quick Ratio

    The quick ratio measures a company’s ability to meet its short-term obligations with its most liquid assets.
  5. Leverage

    Leverage results from using borrowed capital as a source of funding when investing to expand the firm's asset base and generate ...
  6. Financial Risk

    Financial risk is the possibility that shareholders will lose money when investing in a company if its cash flow fails to ...
Trading Center