DEFINITION of 'Nataros v. Fine Arts Gallery of Scottsdale'

Nataros v. Fine Arts Gallery of Scottsdale was a court case involving an auction house and a buyer, in which the buyer alleged the price of items up for auction was rigged and that the items were sold at inflated prices.

BREAKING DOWN 'Nataros v. Fine Arts Gallery of Scottsdale'

In January, 1973, the Fine Arts Gallery advertised an auction containing furnishings from an estate and jewelry from another deceased individual. The auction was originally scheduled to be held at the private home from which the estate items came, but was then moved to a commercial location in Scottsdale, Arizona. Frank and Anna Nataros, the plaintiffs in the case, purchased numerous items over the course of a few days based on values provided by Allen Goald, a sales person at the Fine Arts Gallery. The total cost of all of their purchases totaled over $570,000 and included paintings, silver pieces and jewelry.

The day after the auction closed, Mr. Nataros stopped payments on the checks written for all of the items. After some discussion, the sale was canceled on some of the pieces of jewelry and a new check was issued $286,777 and the gallery provided written appraisals done in-house for the remaining items. Mr. Nataros discovered the items he purchased were not from the estate listed in large print in the newspaper ad, but rather from a New York art dealer, which was mentioned in smaller print reading, "Note — Due to Commitments Prior to the Contractual Arrangements for the Sale of McCune Items, Other Fine Collections Will Be Included in This Sale."

A year later, Mr. Nataros had the items in question appraised by Sotheby, Parke Bernet, and the appraisal values were much lower than what Mr. Nataros had paid and what Mr. Goald had said would be a reasonable price. As a result, Mr. Nataros filed suit against the Fine Arts Gallery of Scottsdale claiming consumer fraud, negligent misrepresentation and common law fraud. When the court ruled in favor of the gallery, the plaintiff appealed and the gallery filed a counterclaim seeking damages for slander and libel.

The lawsuit reached the Arizona court of appeals, where the court ultimately found for the defendants and dismissed their counterclaim. The plaintiffs were also ordered to pay court costs. This case is considered a landmark case in the art world, as it demonstrates how buyers believing they paid too much for something face an uphill battle when it comes to winning a claim against a seller, and that an item ultimately having a lower resale value does not automatically mean the initial estimated value was incorrect.

  1. Auction

    An auction is a process where potential buyers place competitive ...
  2. Chandelier Bid

    A bid that is announced by an auctioneer during an auction that ...
  3. Auction Market

    An auction market is one where buyers and sellers enter competitive ...
  4. Lyon & Turnbull

    Lyon & Turnbull is an auction house established in Edinburgh, ...
  5. IRS Publication 561: Determining ...

    IRS Publication 561: Determining The Value Of Donated Property ...
  6. Appraisal

    An appraisal is a valuation of property (ie. real estate, a business, ...
Related Articles
  1. Managing Wealth

    Importance of Title in Art Transactions

    A work of art can be a valuable investment, but it’s important to verify that it isn’t stolen property when you purchase it.
  2. Managing Wealth

    3 Reasons To Buy Government Surplus for Your Small Business

    Learn why it's wise to access government surplus auctions to buy furnishings, equipment and other items to start a new business or expand an existing business.
  3. Investing

    Should you buy a house at auction?

    The traditional real estate market isn't the only place to conduct your home search. Auctions also bring many buying opportunities.
  4. Managing Wealth

    How To Master Online Auctions For Fast Cash

    Online selling is just as easy as in-person selling and can yield five to 10 times the profit.
  5. Managing Wealth

    Which Collectibles Are Worth the Most?

    Classic cars, fine art, jewelry and more can be safe havens to invest funds. Find out which asset classes performed best in 2015.
  6. Investing

    Explaining Dutch Auction

    A Dutch auction is a public offering auction.
  7. Investing

    Takung Threatens The Sotheby's-Christie's Duopoly (BID)

    Takung and other art-world startups are nipping at the heels of the world's two dominant auction houses, Sotheby's and privately owned Christie's.
  8. Financial Advisor

    Top 5 Places to Find and Meet Potential Wealthy Clients

    Personal connections with affluent people can grow a business quickly. It costs money to join the right organizations, but your new connections should pay off.
  9. Insights

    How the Case Against BofA's Ken Lewis Fizzled

    The regulatory cloud has lifted for Kenneth D. Lewis. Last week, the former head of Bank of America received a modest penalty, paid for by his former employer, and a temporary ban from an industry ...
  1. What is the difference between cost and price?

    Consider how cost affects a product's price. Corporate expenses and the current cost of living both impact the final sticker ... Read Answer >>
  2. How much renters insurance do you need?

    Learn how much renters insurance you need to replace your belongings and how to calculate exactly how much is necessary to ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Financial Risk

    Financial risk is the possibility that shareholders will lose money when investing in a company if its cash flow fails to ...
  2. Enterprise Value (EV)

    Enterprise Value (EV) is a measure of a company's total value, often used as a more comprehensive alternative to equity market ...
  3. Relative Strength Index - RSI

    Relative Strength Indicator (RSI) is a technical momentum indicator that compares the magnitude of recent gains to recent ...
  4. Dividend

    A dividend is a distribution of a portion of a company's earnings, decided by the board of directors, to a class of its shareholders.
  5. Inventory Turnover

    Inventory turnover is a ratio showing how many times a company has sold and replaces inventory over a period.
  6. Watchlist

    A watchlist is list of securities being monitored for potential trading or investing opportunities.
Trading Center