DEFINITION of 'Negative Arbitrage'

Negative arbitrage is the opportunity lost when municipal bond issuers assume proceeds from debt offerings and then invest that money for a period of time (ideally in a safe investment vehicle) until the money is used to fund a project, or to repay investors. The lost opportunity occurs when the money is reinvested and the debt issuer earns a rate or return that is lower than what must actually be paid back to the debt holders.

BREAKING DOWN 'Negative Arbitrage'

Negative arbitrage occurs when a borrower pays its debt at a higher interest rate than the rate the borrower earns on the money set aside to repay the debt. Basically, the borrowing cost is more than the lending cost. For example, to fund the construction of a highway, a state government issues $50 million in municipal bonds paying 6%. But while the offering is in process still, prevailing interest rates in the market drop. The proceeds from the bond issuance are invested in a money market account paying only 4.2% for a period of one year, because the prevailing market will not pay a higher rate. In this case, the issuer loses the equivalent of 1.8% interest that it could have earned or retained. The 1.8% results from negative arbitrage which is, in fact, an opportunity cost. The loss incurred by the city translates into less available funds for the highway project.

The concept of negative arbitrage can be explained with refunding bonds. If interest rates decrease below the coupon rate on existing callable bonds, an issuer is likely to pay off the bond and refinance its debt at the lower interest rate prevalent in the market. The proceeds from the new issue (the refunding bond) will be used to settle the interest and principal payment obligations of the outstanding issue (the refunded bond). However, due to the call protection placed on some bonds which prevents an issuer from redeeming the bonds for a period of time, proceeds from the new issue are used to purchase Treasury securities held in escrow. On the call date after the call protection elapses, the Treasuries are sold and the proceeds from the sale are used to retire the older bonds.

When the yield on the Treasury securities is below the yield on the refunding bonds, negative arbitrage occurs resulting from lost investment yield in the escrow fund. When there is negative arbitrage, the result is a significantly greater issue size and the feasibility of the advance refunding is often negated. When high interest rate bonds are advance refunded with low interest rate bonds, the amount of government securities required for the escrow account will be greater than the amount of outstanding bonds being refunded. To match the debt service of the higher interest payments of the  outstanding bonds with the lower interest of Treasuries, such as Treasury bills, the difference must be derived through more principal since the cash flow from the escrow must equal the cash flow on outstanding bonds to be refunded.

  1. Refunding

    Refunding is the process of retiring or redeeming an outstanding ...
  2. Escrowed To Maturity

    An escrowed to maturity bond has been repaid in advance via an ...
  3. Double Barreled

    A double barreled bond is a municipal bond in which the interest ...
  4. Call Risk

    Call risk is the risk faced by a holder of a callable bond that ...
  5. Bond Market

    The bond market is the environment in which the issuance and ...
  6. Negative Bond Yield

    A negative bond yield is an unusual situation in which issuers ...
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Why Bond Prices Fall When Interest Rates Rise

    Never invest in something you don’t understand. Bonds are no exception.
  2. Investing

    Here's What Happens When a Bond Is Called

    Learn why early redemption occurs and how to avoid potential losses.
  3. Investing

    The Basics Of Municipal Bonds

    Investing in municipal bonds may offer a tax-free income stream, but such bonds are not without risks. Check out types of bonds and the risk factors of muni-bond.
  4. Investing

    Why Companies Issue Bonds

    When companies need to raise money, issuing bonds is one way to do it. A bond functions as a loan between an investor and a corporation.
  5. Investing

    Basics Of Federal Bond Issues

    Treasuries are considered the safest investments, but they should still be analyzed when issued.
  6. Investing

    Investing in Bonds: 5 Mistakes to Avoid in Today's Market

    Investors need to understand the five mistakes involving interest rate risk, credit risk, complex bonds, markups and inflation to avoid in the bond market.
  7. Investing

    Why Muni Bonds and Bond Funds are Perfect Together

    Municipal bonds and bond funds differ in several ways, which is partly why they complement each other well.
  8. Investing

    Find the Right Bond at the Right Time

    Learn about the types of bonds you should consider investing in, when you should be buying them and how to compare yields against their time to maturity.
  9. Investing

    How To Evaluate Bond Performance

    Learn about how investors should evaluate bond performance. See how the maturity of a bond can impact its exposure to interest rate risk.
  1. What are the risks of investing in a bond?

    Are you thinking of investing in bond market? Learn more about bond market investment risk, including interest rate risk, ... Read Answer >>
  2. Which factors most influence fixed-income securities?

    Learn about the main factors that impact the price of fixed-income securities, and understand the various types of risk associated ... Read Answer >>
  3. What determines bond prices on the open market?

    Learn more about some of the factors that influence the valuation of bonds on the open market and why bond prices and yields ... Read Answer >>
Trading Center