What is a 'Pigovian Tax'

A Pigovian tax is a strategic effluent fee assessed against private individuals or businesses for engaging in a specific activity. It is meant to discourage activities that impose a net cost of production on third parties; economists call this a “negative externality.” Pigovian taxes were named after English economist Arthur C. Pigou, a major contributor to early externality theory in the Cambridge tradition.

BREAKING DOWN 'Pigovian Tax'

According to Pigou, negative externalities prevent a market economy from reaching equilibrium when producers do not internalize all costs of production. This negative externality might be corrected, he contended, by levying taxes equal to the externalized costs.

Negative Externalities

Negative externalities are not necessarily “bad” in the normative sense. Instead, a negative externality occurs whenever an economic actor does not fully internalize the costs of their activity, meaning third parties unwillingly subsidize extra production.

A popular example of a Pigovian-style tax is a tax on pollution. Pollution from a factory creates a negative externality because part of the cost of pollution is borne by third parties nearby. This cost might manifest through dirtied property or health risks.

The polluter only internalizes the marginal private costs, not the marginal external costs. Once Pigou added in the external costs — creating what he called marginal social cost — he argued the economy suffered deadweight loss from excess pollution beyond the “social optimal” level.

Social Optimal Taxes

A.C. Pigou popularized the concept of a Pigovian tax in his influential book “The Economics of Welfare” (1920). Building on Alfred Marshall’s analysis of markets, Pigou believed state intervention should correct negative externalities, which he considered a market failure. This could be accomplished, Pigou contended, through scientifically measured and selective taxation.

To arrive at the social optimal tax, the government regulator must estimate the marginal social cost and marginal private cost, extrapolating from those the deadweight loss to the economy.

The Problem of Social Cost

Pigou’s externality theories were dominant in mainstream economics for 40 years, but lost favor after Nobel Prize-winner Ronald Coase published “The Problem of Social Cost” (1960). Coase demonstrated that Pigou’s examination and solution were often wrong, and for at least three separate reasons.

Using Pigou’s analytical framework, Coase showed negative externalities did not necessarily lead to an inefficient result. Second, even if they were inefficient, Pigovian taxes did not tend to lead to an efficient result. Last, Coase argued the critical element was transaction cost theory, not externality theory.

Calculation and Knowledge Problems

Pigovian taxes encounter what Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises first described as “calculation and knowledge problems” in his “Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth” (1920). A government regulator cannot issue the correct, social optimal Pigovian tax without knowing in advance what the most efficient outcome is.

This would require knowing the precise amount of externality cost imposed by the polluter, as well as the correct price and output for the specific market and all associated goods and services. If lawmakers overestimate the external costs involved, Pigovian taxes cause more harm than good.

  1. True Cost Economics

    True cost economics is an economic model that seeks to include ...
  2. Pigou Effect

    A term in economics referring to the relationship between consumption, ...
  3. Cap And Trade

    Cap and trade is a regulatory system designed to provide a profit ...
  4. Green Levy

    A tax imposed by a government on sources of pollution or carbon ...
  5. External Diseconomies Of Scale

    External diseconomies of scale are the result of outside factors ...
  6. Taxes

    An involuntary fee levied on corporations or individuals that ...
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Explaining the Coase Theorem

    The Coase theorem states when there are competitive markets and no transaction costs, bargaining will lead to a mutually beneficial outcome.
  2. Small Business

    Training New Employees Vs. Hiring Skilled Workers

    The decision to hire internally or externally is based on many considerations, and not all of them are financial.
  3. Insights

    What Are Economies Of Scale?

    Is bigger always better? Read up on the important and often misunderstood concept of economies of scale.
  4. Insights

    A Concise History Of Changes In U.S. Tax Law

    We look at how U.S. taxes have changed since their inception.
  5. Financial Advisor

    These 13 States Tax Your Social Security Benefits

    It may surprise many that Social Security benefits are taxed. The best way to not let it derail your tax situation is to plan for it. Here's how.
  6. Investing

    Gauging Major Turns With Psychology

    Knowing what the market is thinking is the best way to determine what it will do next.
  7. Retirement

    Will the Social Security Cap Increase Help It Last Longer?

    The Social Security cap increase will be 7% in 2017, but even that may not be enough to keep Social Security from running out of funds.
  8. Retirement

    How Social Security works for the self-employed

    As both employee and employer, you have to pay more in Social Security, but there are deductions that can help lighten the tax burden. Find out how Social Security works for the self-employed. ...
  9. Retirement

    How to Fix an Error on Your Social Security Check

    For many seniors, social security benefits checks are their income stream which means the benefit has to be correct. If you spot an error, you can fix it.
  1. Who developed the theory of economic externality?

    Discover which economist developed the theory of economic externalities, and learn how and why some advocate for taxation ... Read Answer >>
  2. How can individuals or businesses handle transaction costs for economic externalities?

    Find out how businesses can work with each other, their customers or third parties to help internalize external costs or ... Read Answer >>
  3. What would happen to a company's external fund requirements if it reduces the payout ...

    In short, the stronger the company's internal cash flow, and in turn cash position, the less the need to draw on an external ... Read Answer >>
  4. Do negative externalities affect financial markets?

    Learn how negative externalities affect financial markets where parties to financial transactions do not pay full costs for ... Read Answer >>
  5. How can companies reduce internal and external business risk?

    Understand the difference between internal business risk and external business risk. Learn how a company can reduce each ... Read Answer >>
  6. What are some examples of economies of scale?

    Take a look at different examples of economies of scale, including how marginal costs can be reduced through external and ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Federal Funds Rate

    The federal funds rate is the interest rate at which a depository institution lends funds maintained at the Federal Reserve ...
  2. Call Option

    An agreement that gives an investor the right (but not the obligation) to buy a stock, bond, commodity, or other instrument ...
  3. Standard Deviation

    A measure of the dispersion of a set of data from its mean, calculated as the square root of the variance. The more spread ...
  4. Entrepreneur

    An entrepreneur is an individual who founds and runs a small business and assumes all the risk and reward of the venture.
  5. Money Market

    The money market is a segment of the financial market in which financial instruments with high liquidity and very short maturities ...
  6. Perfect Competition

    Pure or perfect competition is a theoretical market structure in which a number of criteria such as perfect information and ...
Trading Center