What is 'Policyholder Surplus'

Policyholder surplus are assets of a policyholder-owned insurance company (also called a mutual insurance company) minus its liabilities. Policyholder surplus is one indicator of an insurance company’s financial health. It gives an insurance company another source of funds, in addition to its reserves and reinsurance, if it needs to pay a higher than expected amount of claims. When an insurance company is publicly owned, its assets minus its liabilities are instead called shareholders’ equity.

BREAKING DOWN 'Policyholder Surplus'

Policyholder surplus is one metric that insurance rating companies use when developing the simple letter ratings ranging from A++ to F. Consumers can turn to these ratings for help in choosing an insurance company that is strong financially. It’s important for consumers to choose an insurer that can afford to pay its policyholders’ claims under varying circumstances, even if a widespread disaster like a severe storm means that thousands of policyholders are simultaneously filing claims.

Policyholder surplus is also a component of various other calculations that ratings companies use to evaluate the financial strength of insurance companies. These calculations include ratios such as reserve development to policyholder surplus, loss to policyholder surplus, net liabilities to policyholder surplus and net premiums written to policyholder surplus, among others. Calculations involving policyholder surplus are also used by state insurance regulators to determine which insurers might need their attention, due to financial weakness or over-reliance on reinsurance. For publicly traded insurance companies, the same calculations can be performed by substituting shareholders’ equity for policyholder surplus.

Interpreting the results of these calculations requires specialized knowledge, not just common sense. For example, insurance company examiners will consider the company’s change in policyholder surplus from year to year as one component of assessing whether the insurer is becoming financially stronger, weaker or staying about the same. While it might seem like a large increase in policyholder surplus from one year to the next would always be a good sign, it could sometimes indicate that the insurer is on the verge of insolvency.

More Policyholder Surplus Creates More Competitiveness

When the insurance industry is flush with policyholder surplus, the insurance marketplace becomes more competitive. Fueled by lower premiums, relaxed underwriting and expanded coverage across the industry, carriers begin to compete more. This is called a soft market. Historically, soft markets are very temporary. Lower premium prices bring down underwriting profits, and the industry’s return on average net worth begins to deteriorate. The industry also starts attracting less capital. As liabilities begin to chip away at policyholder surplus, insurance companies are forced to raise premium prices, underwriting tightens and coverage is restricted. Then, the soft market becomes a hard market.

RELATED TERMS
  1. Return On Policyholder Surplus

    Return On Policyholder Surplus is the ratio of an insurance company’s ...
  2. Experience Refund

    Experience refund is the portion of an insurance company’s premiums ...
  3. Developed Premium

    A developed premium is an initial quote from an insurer based ...
  4. Capital Stock Insurance Companies

    Capital stock insurance companies are companies that get their ...
  5. Future Purchase Option

    A future purchase option is a feature of long-term disability ...
  6. Assessable Policy

    Assessable Policy is a type of insurance policy that may require ...
Related Articles
  1. Insurance

    Dividend-Paying Whole Life Insurance: What to Know

    Many whole life insurance policies pay dividends. Here are what policyholders need to consider.
  2. Insurance

    How To Invest In Insurance Companies

    Knowing the special circumstances that insurance companies operate under helps in evaluating whether or not a listed insurance company is a good investment and whether the economic environment ...
  3. Insurance

    For Life Insurers, Making Money Is A Numbers Game

    Life insurance is a data-driven industry that relies on complex financial models to predict future expenses and income from premiums and investments.
  4. Insurance

    Examples of Adverse Selection in the Insurance Industry

    Find out what the term "adverse selection" refers to in the insurance industry, and learn how insurance companies protect themselves from adverse selection.
  5. Insurance

    Do You Need Casualty Insurance?

    Find out how different types of coverages can protect you and which policy is right for you.
  6. Insurance

    How To Easily Understand Your Insurance Contract

    Understanding your insurance contracts can go a long way in making sure that your advisor's recommendations are on track. Learn how to read yours today.
  7. Financial Advisor

    Buying a Life Insurance Policy? Read This First

    Knowing who needs life insurance, how it works and the different types of insurance can help consumers make informed decisions about this product.
  8. Insurance

    Insurance, Excess Insurance and Reinsurance: What's the Difference? (ALL)

    Understanding the differences might help you avoid being overinsured or underinsured.
  9. Insurance

    Homeowner's Insurance Guide: A Beginner's Overview

    Everything new homeowners need to know about homeowner's insurance to protect their residence.
RELATED FAQS
  1. Can your insurance company cancel your policy without notice?

    Learn about your rights as an insured when it comes to your insurance policy being canceled, including how to access your ... Read Answer >>
  2. How can an investor evaluate the leverage of an insurance company?

    Learn about insurance leverage, what leverage means in the context of insurance companies and what metrics investors should ... Read Answer >>
  3. How does the insurance sector work?

    Learn more about the insurance sector, a historically safe place for equity investors and the home of some of the largest ... Read Answer >>
  4. What is an elimination period?

    Elimination period is a term used in insurance to refer to the time period between an injury and the receipt of benefit payments. Read Answer >>
Trading Center